Persistent Structural Inequality of Online Interactions Across Platforms

Giulio Pecile, Edoardo Di Martino, Edoardo Loru, Simon Zollo, Niccolò Di Marco, Matteo Cinelli · 2026

Read Persistent Structural Inequality of Online Interactions Across Platforms by Giulio Pecile, Edoardo Di Martino, Edoardo Loru, Simon Zollo, Niccolò Di Marco, Matteo Cinelli (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2605-30996.txt.

Introduction

Pecile and colleagues test whether inequality in online interaction is stable across time and platforms. A small subset of users captures most action while most stay small, a pattern often fit by power laws. From user-post networks, they count active posts and passive likes and comments, using divergence-based models, inverse coefficient of variation, and a log-transformed Gini index. They find interaction inequality stays stable over time within each platform, across varied systems. This reflects structural constraints on visibility and participation.

Catalog record

CREATORGiulio Pecile, Edoardo Di Martino, Edoardo Loru, Simon Zollo, Niccolò Di Marco, Matteo Cinelli
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE36103
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2605.30996

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Persistent Structural Inequality of Online Interactions Across Platforms Giulio Pecile, Edoardo Di Martino, Edoardo Loru, Simon Zollo, Niccolò Di Marco, Matteo Cinelli Abstract User interactions on social media platforms are unevenly distributed: a small subset of users consistently captures most of the activity, while the majority remains marginal. Although this pattern is well known and often described by power-law distributions, its consistency across time, platforms, and interaction types has not been systematically assessed. In this study, we analyze user–post bipartite networks from multiple social media platforms. We consider both active contributions (posts) and passive engagement (likes and comments), and quantify distributional properties and inequality using a KL-divergence–based model comparison, an inverse coefficient of variation, and a log-transformed Gini index. Our results show that interaction inequality remains stable over time within each platform. This holds across systems with different sizes, topical focuses, and governance models. These findings indicate that inequality in online engagement is not incidental but reflects structural constraints that shape how visibility and participation are distributed in digital environments. keywords social media, interaction patterns, interaction distribution, online behavior, interaction inequality, attention dynamics 1 Introduction The growth of social media has signified that the online domain has become an ever more dominant setting for public debate Di Marco et al. 2026 . This debate usually takes the form of an initial user publishing a post, and others replying or reacting to the message. Because of the online nature of these dynamics, users have access to much larger audiences, which, in turn, can interact with a wider range of posts and opinions. While this has increased the ability to participate in public debates, it has also fostered many unintended phenomena, including the spread of disinformation Diaz Ruiz and Nilsson 2023 ; Budak et al. 2024 and toxic debate Avalle et al. 2024 ; Tahmasbi et al. 2021 ; Loru et al. 2024 ; Falkenberg et al. 2024 , and the emergence of polarization Bail et al. 2018 ; Kubin and Von Sikorski 2021 ; Pecile et al. 2025 ; Falkenberg et al. 2023 ; Loru et al. 2025 . It is thus important to understand how responsibility for these phenomena is spread across its users. In the case of disinformation, for example, findings suggest that an extremely small group is responsible for very high exposure of misinformation for Countering Digital Hate 2022 ; Budak et al. 2024 , particularly under information void regimes Scalco et al. 2026 . In particular, a well-documented feature of digital platforms is the unequal distribution of attention: a small share of users consistently attracts most interactions, while the majority remains marginal Adamic and Huberman 2000 ; Muchnik et al. 2013 ; Asur et al. 2011 ; Ross and Jones 2015 ; Mathews et al. 2017 . This pattern recurs across platforms with different user bases, content types, and algorithmic infrastructures, suggesting the presence of structural regularities Di Marco et al. 2024 ; Avalle et al. 2024 . Power-law and Zipf-like models are often used to describe these dynamics Robins et al. 2009 ; Ahn et al. 2007 , yet it remains unclear whether the observed inequality arises from platform-specific factors Agichtein et al. 2008 ; Zafarani et al. 2014 or from more general constraints on how attention is distributed online Cinelli et al. 2020 ; Sangiorgio et al. 2025 ; Di Marco et al. 2024 ; Zollo et al. 2026 . This uncertainty challenges the idea that design-level interventions alone can reshape interaction patterns: if inequality consistently re-emerges under different configurations, it may reflect deeper constraints inherent to digital systems. Some work has examined inequality in user activity on platforms such as Reddit Machado et al. 2025 ; Panek et al. 2018 ; Singer et al. 2014 and X Orellana-Rodriguez and Keane 2018 ; Zhu and Lerman 2016 ; Bagdouri 2021 ; Orellana-Rodriguez et al. 2017 , but a systematic account of temporal and cross-platform regularities is still missing. Most studies focus on single platforms or isolated events, making it difficult to systematically assess whether observed inequalities reflect transient conditions or more persistent constraints. In this work, we examine whether interaction inequality follows consistent trajectories over time and across platforms. In particular, we test whether the emergence of dominant contributors, users that attract disproportionate attention, is a transient artifact or a persistent structural feature. We adopt a network-based approach, modeling user–post interactions and tracking their evolution across time windows. The analysis covers both mainstream platforms and alternative ecosystems, which differ widely in terms of governance, user demographics, and content policies. By examining the concentration and scaling properties of attention across these contexts, we assess not only the internal dynamics of each platform but also whether structural regularities persist across diverse socio-technical environments. Our approach moves beyond a platform-specific focus to test whether interaction inequality reflects broader constraints linked to limited visibility, attention bottlenecks, and platform-mediated exposure. This perspective presents online engagement as a measurable pattern shaped by the architecture of participation, rather than an outcome of content or ideology. To this end, we adopt a set of complementary indices to capture functional form, tail dominance, and concentration. 2 Materials and methods 2.1 Data We analyze a broad dataset covering multiple social media platforms that differ in user experience, governance, and user base composition. While some platforms do allow users to perform other actions besides the ones in our analysis, our work is limited by the ones that were available to us. We also performed a selection of the considered type of interactions to have a coherent analysis across platforms. Among the mainstream platforms, we include X, where posts receive likes and replies; and YouTube, where videos receive likes and comments. We also include Gab, where posts receive favourites and replies. Notably, this platform stands in stark contrast to the others as an alternative network with significantly looser moderation policies. As some platforms also vary in levels of homogeneity of type of discourse, when possible, we also used multiple datasets from the same platforms, representing both casual conversations and politically relevant discussions. Below, we outline the data collection procedure for each. For what concerns mainstream platforms, we used posts on X that discussed the 26th Conference of the Parties, referred to as COP26 in this work Falkenberg et al. 2022 , and the Russo-Ukranian conflict Chen and Ferrara 2023 , created in 2021 and between 2022 and 2023 respectively. The COP26 dataset contains 11.7 million posts and the Ukraine dataset consists of 103.9 million posts. We also include two X datasets containing casual conversations: “X GoT”, with 218 thousand posts discussing the TV series Game of Thrones , and “X NASA”, with 151 thousand posts discussing the space agency. YouTube data were collected using the platform’s public API and consist of two datasets covering current events and political discussions, and a third one discussing football. Data from Gab Di Martino et al. 2025 were collected in two stages. Between June 1 and October 23, 2020, posts were retrieved through the general stream. After the API was deprecated, collection continued from the timelines of 930,000 previously identified users. Applying filters for the keywords “Trump” and “Biden” produced a subset of 468,000 posts covering the period from June to

Read the complete text