The Geometry of Activity Cliffs: Representation Dependence and Multi-Scale Characterization of Activity Landscapes

Pawel Dabrowski-Tumanski, Bartosz Topolski, Dariusz Plewczynski, Tomasz Jetka · 2026

Read The Geometry of Activity Cliffs: Representation Dependence and Multi-Scale Characterization of Activity Landscapes by Pawel Dabrowski-Tumanski, Bartosz Topolski, Dariusz Plewczynski, Tomasz Jetka (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2605-30831.txt.

Introduction

Dabrowski-Tumanski and colleagues argue that much about activity cliffs reflects the chosen lens rather than a trait of a molecule pair itself. They build a six-step method testing this claim across fifteen setups of vectors and metrics on three datasets. Morgan Tanimoto gives the strongest cliff boost. MACCS and RDKit Dice fingerprints are most sensitive to matched-pair transformations, and ChemBERTa fails through collapse. Varied representations encode varied aspects of molecular recognition, so choosing one defines what an activity cliff is.

Catalog record

CREATORPawel Dabrowski-Tumanski, Bartosz Topolski, Dariusz Plewczynski, Tomasz Jetka
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE54942
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2605.30831

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

The Geometry of Activity Cliffs: Representation Dependence and Multi-Scale Characterization of Activity Landscapes Pawel Dabrowski-Tumanski, Bartosz Topolski, Dariusz Plewczynski, Tomasz Jetka Abstract Activity cliffs, structurally similar compounds with large potency differences, are widely treated as intrinsic features of chemical datasets. We argue that apart from target biology, much of our cliff understanding is a consequence of the geometry induced by the chosen molecular representation, not a property of a molecule pair itself. We designed a six-step pipeline to systematically test this hypothesis. The pipeline consists of: assessing pairwise distance geometry, cliff enrichment, activity gradient distribution, persistent homology of the cliff subspace, predictive benchmarking for a chosen pair of an embedding and a metric, and eventually, analysis of the matched molecular pairs and stereoisomers. We applied the pipeline to fifteen configurations of embeddings and metrics to build a benchmark across three distinctive datasets known of activity cliffs challenges. No representation excels on all criteria: Morgan Tanimoto provides the strongest cliff enrichment and cross-scaffold generalization; MolFormer cosine provides the only meaningful stereochemical sensitivity; MACCS and RDKit Dice fingerprints are most sensitive to matched-molecular-pair transformations; ChemBERTa fails uniformly due to embedding collapse. These findings are not a ranking. They reflect the fact that different representations encode different aspects of molecular recognition, and that choosing one implicitly defines what an activity cliff actually is. keywords activity cliffs, molecular representations, structure-activity relationships, persistent homology, molecular fingerprints, learned embeddings, drug discovery, QSAR † † affiliation: Faculty of Mathematics and Information Science, Warsaw University of Technology, Warsaw 00-662, Poland † † affiliation: Faculty of Mathematics and Natural Sciences, University of Cardinal Stefan Wyszynski, Warsaw 01-938, Poland † † affiliation: Ingenix.AI † † email: [email protected] † † affiliation: Ingenix.AI † † affiliation: Faculty of Mathematics and Information Science, Warsaw University of Technology, Warsaw 00-662, Poland † † affiliation: Centre of New Technologies, University of Warsaw, Warsaw 02-097, Poland † † affiliation: Ingenix.AI † † affiliation: Ingenix.AI 1 Introduction Activity cliffs are pairs of structurally similar compounds with large differences in biological potency that demarcate the boundaries of predictability in structure-activity relationships. 7 ; 13 ; 14 Although the concept is now ubiquitous in medicinal chemistry and cheminformatics, its definition is operational rather than formal: it depends on two user-chosen thresholds: a potency gap typically of one log unit and a similarity cutoff. The latter requires an implicit choice of how molecular similarity is measured at all. This rests on an unexamined foundational choice: the selection of a molecular representation and a similarity metric. Indeed, while the target biology dictates the baseline roughness of the activity landscape, it is metric which dictates the arbitrary boundaries of the cliff, as the structural proximity is not an intrinsic property of a molecule pair, but rather a property of the metric space in which the molecules are embedded. A concrete illustration: on a single bioactivity dataset, the number of pairs that qualify as activity cliffs at a fixed similarity cutoff can vary by more than an order of magnitude – in our experiments by a factor of roughly 50 – across reasonable choices of representation, even though the compounds and the potency measurements are identical. An even sharper case is stereoisomers. In many commonly used 2D fingerprints, stereoisomeric pairs can collapse to identical or near-identical representations despite differing only in three-dimensional configuration. If their potencies differ, such pairs expose a representation-dependent discontinuity: they may appear as duplicate-label conflicts, extreme activity cliffs, or not cliffs at all. In neither case has the chemistry changed — only the metric in which the chemistry is read. Changing the embedding or similarity metric changes which pairs qualify as cliffs, how many exist, and whether they are predictable, without changing the underlying biology. This observation has a precise mathematical formulation. Let (\mathcal{M},d) be a metric space of chemical compounds and \varphi:\mathcal{M}\to\mathbb{R} an activity functional. The local Lipschitz constant L(x,y)=|\varphi(x)-\varphi(y)|/d(x,y) measures landscape roughness at the pair level; a pair constitutes an activity cliff if and only if L(x,y)>A/s , where A and s are the activity and similarity thresholds. L(x,y) is the Structure-Activity Landscape Index (SALI) of Guha and Van Drie, 6 reinterpreted as the empirical Lipschitz constant under d . Both the cliff indicator and L(x,y) are explicit functions of the representation. Despite this foundational role, the representation-dependence has not been systematically studied: the field has converged on Morgan/Tanimoto as a near-universal default 11 ; 16 ; 8 , while learned molecular embeddings have developed in parallel, without a principled framework for comparing how different representations organize the activity landscape. Figure 1: The exemplification of the metric-dependence. (A) The molecule pairs within different representations may seem artificially close. (B) An example of a molecule pair from SARS-CoV-2 dataset with activity difference |\Delta\text{pK}_{i}|=1.16 . (C) The distances between the molecules in different representations and corresponding SALI index. Depending on the representation, the pair may be classified as an activity cliff, or not a cliff at all. The present work provides that framework. We make three contributions. Conceptually , we establish that activity cliffs are convolution of representation geometry (embedding and metric) and target biology, not just intrinsic properties of molecule pairs. Methodologically , we introduce a six-step pipeline in which each step probes a geometrically distinct property of the activity landscape: discriminative range, cliff enrichment, gradient tail behavior, topological organization of the cliff subspace, and structure of cliff-relevant information in embedding space, followed by real-life validation on matched molecular pairs and stereoisomers. In particular, we train different models predicting the existence of activity cliffs. However, we do not aim in selecting the best possible model, but rather to use the performance gaps as diagnostic statistics about the embedding. Empirically , we apply the pipeline to fifteen (embedding, metric) configurations spanning classical fingerprints and three learned embeddings across three protein targets. Our thesis is, that selecting a molecule representation without characterizing its geometric properties produces conclusions about activity landscapes that may reflect the choice of metric rather than the underlying biology (Figure 1 ). Therefore, our goal is not to identify the best representation, but rather to understand how different representations encode different and partially non-overlapping aspects of molecular recognition. Especially, as it turns out, that no single configuration captures all of them. 2 Methods 2.1 Data We used three publicly available bioactivity datasets curated for activity cliff research. 4 The SARS-CoV-2 Main Protease (Mpro) set comprises 1 924 compounds with K_{i} values from the PostEra Moonshot initiative, 2 in which we right-censored the measurements with K_{i}\geq 99\;\mu M. The Factor Xa and Dopamine D2 receptor sets comprise 3 574 and 6 280 compounds respectively, both drawn from ChEMBL. 9 All K_{i} values were converted to \text{pK}_{i}=-\log_{10}(K_{i}) . Pairs with two censored measurements were excluded; mixed pairs were retained only where a large activity difference suffices. SMILES strings, K_{i} values, and pre-enumerated MMP lists were obtained from the accompanying repository. 1 1 1 https://github.com/MarkusFerdinandDablander/QSAR-activity-cliff-experiments 2.2 Representations Six (embedding, metric) pairs configurations were computed using RDKit 2025.9.3: Morgan (radius 2, 1 024 bits), 11 RDKit topological, and MACCS keys (166 bits), 15 each with Tanimoto and Dice similarity ( d=1-\text{sim} ). Three learned embeddings were included: MolFormer 12 – version from the HuggingFace repository ibm/MoLFormer-XL-both-10pct , ChemBERTa 3 from the

Read the complete text