Tracing the dynamical states and mass accretion histories of galaxy clusters in IllustrisTNG 2026 Tracing the dynamical states and mass accretion histories of galaxy clusters in IllustrisTNG – B

Rashaad Reid, Syeda Lammim Ahad, Roan Haggar, Charlie T. Mpetha, James E. Taylor · 2026

Read Tracing the dynamical states and mass accretion histories of galaxy clusters in IllustrisTNG 2026 Tracing the dynamical states and mass accretion histories of galaxy clusters in IllustrisTNG – B by Rashaad Reid, Syeda Lammim Ahad, Roan Haggar, Charlie T. Mpetha, James E. Taylor (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2605-30595.txt.

Introduction

Reid and colleagues ask which shape measures best reveal how galaxy clusters assembled, using the IllustrisTNG simulations. Present-day clusters, the largest and latest-formed structures, vary widely in late assembly, which may explain scatter in their scaling relations. They compare the most and least relaxed clusters on intrinsic, projected, and stellar traits. The brightness gap between top galaxies and lopsided stellar mass picks out recent versus old accretion well, even in projection. The team urges adding structural classification to studies of completeness and scaling.

Catalog record

CREATORRashaad Reid, Syeda Lammim Ahad, Roan Haggar, Charlie T. Mpetha, James E. Taylor
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE83954
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2605.30595

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Tracing the dynamical states and mass accretion histories of galaxy clusters in IllustrisTNG 2026 Tracing the dynamical states and mass accretion histories of galaxy clusters in IllustrisTNG – B Rashaad Reid, Syeda Lammim Ahad, Roan Haggar, Charlie T. Mpetha, James E. Taylor Abstract As the largest and most recently formed stage of hierarchical structure, present-day galaxy clusters are predicted to have a broad range of late-time assembly histories. This diversity may explain much of the scatter in scaling relations and other cluster properties. Observationally, systems with more or less recent accretion should appear as unrelaxed and relaxed clusters, respectively. However, it is unclear which of the many possible structural measures best correlate with assembly history. Using the IllustrisTNG simulations, we explore the correlation between structural parameters and assembly history. To assess the effectiveness of different structural selection criteria, we define subsamples of the most and least relaxed clusters based on the values of various intrinsic, projected, and stellar structural parameters, and then compare the median assembly history of the subsamples in each case. We find that several observable quantities, including the magnitude gap between the brightest galaxies and the asymmetry of the stellar mass distribution, are very effective in selecting cluster samples with more or less recent accretion, even when applied in projection. Given the strong correlations between assembly history and present-day cluster structure, we suggest that structural classification be included explicitly in any analysis of catalogue completeness, scaling relations, or mean density profiles. 1 Introduction Galaxy clusters are the most massive gravitationally bound structures in the universe. As such, they constitute the most recent phase of hierarchical structure formation and continue to grow significantly up to the present day ( 55 ) . Thus, clusters provide an important probe of the growth of structure in the late-time universe, most often through studies of cluster abundance ( 4 ; 57 ; 38 ; 9 , e.g.) . These studies estimate the abundance of dark matter halos by measuring the cluster mass function and assuming an approximate correspondence between observed clusters and halos. Individual cluster mass determinations require considerable lensing or dynamical data, and thus they can only be made accurately for small numbers of systems. A more common approach is to estimate mass from simpler observable quantities, typically through scaling relations 49 ; 39 ; 60 . The mean formation history or instantaneous growth rate of clusters also depends on cosmology, and estimates of these quantities may provide complementary cosmological tests ( 85 ; 36 ; 66 ; 5 ; 6 ) . However, practical methods applicable to large samples have only recently been developed ( 42 ; 69 ) . These cosmological tests based on galaxy clusters are of particular interest given recent tensions between low-redshift measures of growth and measures based on the cosmic microwave background ( 1 ; 50 , and references therein) . Beyond their cosmological applications, galaxy cluster catalogues play a number of other important roles. Given their contrast relative to the field, they provide easily identified samples of high-z galaxies. Due to their high density, clusters are the site of significant morphological change for galaxies (e.g. 47 ; 77 , and references therein) , and they also allow many other tests of physics at high densities, temperatures, and/or gravitational curvature ( 33 ; 99 ; 86 ; 14 ; 18 ; 94 ) . These tests will become increasingly powerful as cluster samples grow. All current methods of cluster detection depend strongly on mass and/or redshift. Given the strong observational selection effects, cluster samples are naturally grouped using these two observed properties. The implicit assumption is that clusters in a small range of mass and redshift form a homogeneous sample appropriate for, e.g., calibrating scaling relations. However, clusters are continuously evolving systems; those with recent accretion experience significant short-term changes in dark matter structure ( 91 ; 101 ; 29 ; 30 ; 84 ; 100 ; 96 ) and detailed gas properties ( 17 ; 111 ; 51 ; 97 ) . Extensive theoretical work has studied the intrinsic variation in the properties of dark matter halos and galaxy clusters ( 45 ; 90 ; 105 ; 19 ; 43 ) . These studies typically find one or more important forms of variation correlated with the dynamical state and growth history of the system. Observationally, part of this structural variation has long been recognised as the distinction between “relaxed” and “unrelaxed” clusters. Originally, the distinction between the two categories was clearest in X-ray studies and corresponded to the presence or absence of a cool core of enhanced emission. Other X-ray features also trace the degree of dynamical relaxation, including centre of mass offsets ( 110 ; 89 , e.g.) , or asymmetries and substructure in X-ray maps ( 46 ; see 108 ; 107 for recent references). In the optical, a rich literature has developed studying and classifying tracers of dynamical activity or substructure, including the relative dominance of the brightest cluster galaxy (BCG), the concentration, and the projected shape of the halo (e.g. 80 ; 102 ; 109 ; 21 , and references therein) , or the phase-space distribution of the member galaxies ( 31 ; 12 ) . These dynamical features are known to correlate with scatter and offsets in scaling relations ( 70 ; 16 ) and can thus introduce bias in estimates of, e.g., mean cluster mass. They may also affect sample selection more broadly, introducing differences in purity and completeness correlated with dynamical state (e.g. 59 ; Reid et al. in preparation). Ongoing or forthcoming large optical surveys such as Euclid ( 35 ) and Vera C. Rubin Observatory’s Legacy Survey of Space and Time (LSST) ( 44 ) will expand the available samples of galaxy clusters by several orders of magnitude. On the other hand, most of the objects in these samples will be low signal-to-noise ratio (SNR) detections, with membership information for only a few of the brightest galaxies. X-ray, Sunyaev-Zel’dovich (SZ) or weak lensing information will be available only after stacking large numbers of systems and will thus require pre-selection using optical information alone. Given the intrinsic variation in cluster properties at fixed mass and redshift, a practical question arises: can we structurally classify clusters based on their optical properties alone to form more homogeneous subsamples for stacking? In this paper, we take the following “split sample” approach to evaluating possible structural classification methods. We consider a number of different potential indicators of the dynamical state, including centre of mass offset, projected shape, concentration, asymmetry, and mass or luminosity ratios of some of the brightest members. We sort a sample of simulated clusters according to the strength of the indicator and consider the extremes (roughly quintiles, i.e., the bottom and top 20%) of the distribution. We then determine the median mass accretion history (MAH) for each subset and compare how different these are for splits based on different indicators. We do this first for 3D indicators based on the full mass (dark matter + baryonic) distribution to understand how much intrinsic correlation exists between a structural feature and the growth history. Next, we consider projected versions of these measures; these are quantities that could be

Read the complete text