Primary Constraints of Newer General Relativity

Carmen Ferrara, Alexey Golovnev, María José Guzmán · 2026

Read Primary Constraints of Newer General Relativity by Carmen Ferrara, Alexey Golovnev, María José Guzmán (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2605-30221.txt.

Introduction

Carmen Ferrara, Alexey Golovnev and María José Guzmán study the primary constraints of Newer General Relativity, built on torsionless teleparallel geometry. The action uses a scalar from quadratic nonmetricity combinations with free values. From the Lagrangian and momenta, they characterize when the velocity-momentum map becomes non-invertible, split into scalar, vector and tensor sectors. They recover five tensor and three vector primary constraints, and find an unreported scalar-sector degeneracy yielding one or two scalar constraints by parameter. They also obtain those of symmetric teleparallel gravity.

Catalog record

CREATORCarmen Ferrara, Alexey Golovnev, María José Guzmán
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE80595
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2605.30221

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Primary Constraints of Newer General Relativity Carmen Ferrara, Alexey Golovnev, María José Guzmán Abstract We study the primary constraint structure of Newer General Relativity, a gravity theory based on a torsionless teleparallel geometry. The gravitational action is built from a scalar formed by quadratic combinations of the nonmetricity tensor, with arbitrary coefficients c i c_{i} in the Lagrangian. We decompose the Lagrangian and compute the canonical momenta conjugate to the metric. We characterize the primary constraints arising from these momenta by identifying when the map between velocities and momenta becomes non-invertible, and organize the outcome through a fully nonlinear decomposition into scalar, vector and tensor sectors. Comparing with previous results in the literature, we recover five and three primary constraints associated with the tensor and vector sectors, respectively. We also identify a previously unreported degeneracy in the scalar sector, which yields either one or two scalar primary constraints depending on the conditions imposed on the parameters c i c_{i} . Finally, we obtain the primary constraints associated with the covariant formulation of symmetric teleparallel gravity. keywords Newer General Relativity; symmetric teleparallel gravity; Hamiltonian analysis; primary constraints; nonmetricity. PACS Mathematics Subject Classification 2020: 81Q10, 81Q15, 35J10 1 Introduction General relativity (GR) remains the most accurate classical description of gravitation available, having passed an extensive battery of tests ranging from precision solar system measurements to strong-field probes and gravitational-wave observations [ 83 , 70 , 32 , 1 , 3 , 2 , 82 , 66 ] . Yet, despite this empirical success, there are well-known theoretical and observational reasons to explore extensions of GR, and more broadly, alternative geometric formulations of gravity [ 23 , 18 , 30 , 81 , 25 ] . On the theoretical side, GR has not been reconciled with quantum field theory in a complete quantum theory of gravity, and its classical dynamics predicts spacetime singularities, indicating the breakdown of the classical description and motivating more fundamental frameworks [ 85 , 71 , 48 , 80 ] . On the observational side, the standard \Lambda CDM model fits a wide range of data but relies on ingredients whose microphysical origin remains unclear [ 77 , 8 ] , such as dark matter [ 68 , 24 , 13 ] , dark energy [ 28 , 9 ] , and the mechanism driving inflation [ 55 ] . It also faces persistent precision tensions, such as the H_{0} and \sigma_{8} tensions [ 12 , 33 , 72 ] . These tensions have become central data-driven tests of the concordance model and provide a concrete observational impetus for exploring new gravitational dynamics. The arena we will use for such explorations is the metric-affine framework, where the metric g_{\mu\nu} and the affine connection \Gamma^{\rho}{}_{\mu\nu} are treated as independent geometric structures [ 41 , 60 ] . In standard GR, one assumes vanishing torsion and metric compatibility, which uniquely selects the Levi-Civita connection [ 37 ] . Dropping one or both assumptions allows for torsion and/or nonmetricity as additional geometric fields [ 16 ] . This broader viewpoint contains alternative, and sometimes classically equivalent, formulations of GR: teleparallel gravity attributes gravity to torsion with vanishing curvature, while symmetric teleparallel gravity attributes gravity to nonmetricity with vanishing curvature and torsion [ 11 , 69 ] . We are motivated to study a gravitational theory built from an action containing quadratic combinations of the nonmetricity tensor, known as Newer General Relativity [ 17 ] . This theory is named in analogy with a similar construction based on quadratic combinations of the torsion tensor called New General Relativity [ 59 , 21 ] . In Newer GR, the vanishing of curvature and torsion determines the connection up to an arbitrary gauge field \xi^{a} representing a change of coordinates, which can be chosen in such a way as to trivialize the connection, leading to the so-called coincident gauge. Several aspects of this theory have been studied, including the propagation of gravitational waves [ 62 ] , the post-Newtonian limit [ 46 ] , spherically symmetric solutions [ 61 ] , the classification of primary constraints [ 36 ] , the weak gravity limit [ 53 ] , and cosmology [ 64 ] , among others. Current evidence indicates that there are two one-parameter families of Newer GR models with a post-Newtonian limit compatible with solar-system observations, which may also be free of instabilities and viable as gravitational theories [ 63 ] . However, the number of propagating degrees of freedom of the most general Newer GR models, including their one-parameter families, is not yet fully understood. Determining this number is crucial for justifying and characterizing statements about strong coupling issues, ghosts, and other possible instabilities that are relevant in gravity theories [ 40 , 38 ] . Similar issues have been identified in modified metric teleparallel theories such as f(T) gravity, where Hamiltonian analysis reveals extra degrees of freedom that do not all manifest at the perturbative level [ 67 , 44 , 56 , 45 , 19 , 51 , 52 ] In gravity and other gauge theories, it is often difficult to determine the physically relevant content from the field equations alone, due to the interplay between dynamical variables and gauge redundancies. This information is encoded in the constraint structure of the theory. Although recent proposals for determining the constraints and degrees of freedom of first-order field theories are formulated at the Lagrangian level [ 39 , 40 ] , their consistency must preferably be tested through the Dirac-Bergmann algorithm. This algorithm provides a systematic diagnostic: primary constraints signal a singular Legendre transform, secondary (and higher) constraints follow from demanding preservation of primary constraints under time evolution, and the classification into first- and second-class constraints determines the number of propagating degrees of freedom as well as the generators of gauge symmetries on phase space. For non-Riemannian gravity theories, this analysis is particularly decisive because an independent connection introduces additional gauge freedoms as well as additional constraint surfaces, whose consistency controls whether extra modes are eliminated or become pathological. This analysis could also clarify the role of projective symmetries in the action from projective transformations in the connection. Other ways of interpreting degrees of freedom in modified gravities consist in changes of variables, such as conformal and disformal transformations [ 49 ] . In this work we will start the first steps of the Dirac-Bergmann algorithm for Newer General Relativity, that is, to obtain the canonical momenta, and the conditions of invertibility of velocities by computing the kernel of the Hessian. The presence of arbitrary coefficients in the Lagrangian spans several different possibilities for the possible number of primary constraints, which later in the algorithm give rise to different branches, each one with different primary Hamiltonian, time evolution of constraints, and therefore number of degrees of freedom. To our knowledge, only Ref. [ 36 ] treats the classification of primary constraints in Newer GR, and Ref. [ 14 ] performs a more general analysis allowing torsion in the geometry in addition to nonmetricity. The paper is organized as follows. In Sec. 2 we introduce the symmetric teleparallel geometry. In Sec. 3 we discuss the different possibilities for defining the canonical variables. In Sec.

Read the complete text