Model Independent Probe of Variation of Cosmic Opacity with Redshift

Savita Gahlaut 1 and Meetu Luthra 2 · 2026

Read Model Independent Probe of Variation of Cosmic Opacity with Redshift by Savita Gahlaut 1 and Meetu Luthra 2 (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2605-29805.txt.

Introduction

Savita Gahlaut and Meetu Luthra test whether cosmic opacity changes with redshift, free of any assumed cosmology. They build an opacity-free distance curve from strong lensing data and an opacity-sensitive curve from Pantheon+ supernova data, then tie the two through the distance duality relation. On average the universe looks transparent across the supernova sample's range. Yet splitting the sample into narrow redshift bins shows clear departures in several slices, so opacity appears to vary with redshift, with consequences for cosmological values drawn from supernovae.

Catalog record

CREATORSavita Gahlaut 1 and Meetu Luthra 2
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE30018
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2605.29805

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Model Independent Probe of Variation of Cosmic Opacity with Redshift Savita Gahlaut 1 and Meetu Luthra 2 Abstract Cosmic opacity may vary spatially due to the inhomogeneous distribution of dust, its grain properties, and the efficiency of photon attenuation. In this work, we present a model independent method to investigate the variation of cosmic opacity with redshift. Using strong gravitational lensing data we construct the opacity independent comoving distance function and we use latest supernovae type Ia (SNe Ia) Pantheon+ data to estimate the opacity dependent comoving distances. Using the distance duality equation, opacity parameter is constrained. Our analysis indicates a transparent Universe on average over the redshift range ( 0.01 ≤ z ≤ 2.26137 0.01\leq z\leq 2.26137 ) of Pantheon+ sample. However, if we split the dataset into subsamples with redshift bins of width △ z = 0.1 \bigtriangleup z=0.1 , we find appreciable deviation from the transparency in several redshift intervals. Particularly, in the redshift range 0.3 < z ≤ 0.4 0.3<z\leq 0.4 , the opacity parameter is ϵ = − 0.4283 − 0.2027 + 0.1914 \epsilon=-0.4283^{+0.1914}_{-0.2027} . The current SNe Ia observations indicate the variation of opacity parameter with redshift. These results may have a significant impact on the values of the cosmological parameters deduced from the SNe Ia observations. \affilOne 1 Department of Physics, Deen Dayal Upadhyaya College, (University of Delhi), New Delhi-110078, India \affilTwo 2 Department of Physics, Bhaskaracharya College of Applied Sciences, (University of Delhi), New Delhi-110075, India keywords Cosmology — Observations — Strong Gravitational Lensing — Physical Data and Processes — Distance Scales — Opacity \corres [email protected] \msinfo 20262026 \doinum 12.3456/s78910-011-012-3 \artcitid #### \volnum 000 0000 \pgrange 1– \lp 1 1 Introduction The cosmologists use a set of variables that define the evolution of the universe in terms of measurable quantities or parameters. Various independent sets of observations are used to estimate the values of these parameters. One such parameter being the deceleration parameter q_{o} and a negative q_{o} means an accelerating Universe at the present epoch. Type Ia supernovae (SNe Ia) observations indicate an accelerated expansion at present ( Riess et al. 1998 ; Perlmutter et al. 1999 ) . Evidence of this acceleration was considered to be SNe Ia appearing fainter than what they would appear in a decelerating universe. Gravitational forces, from ordinary matter and energy, alone result in deceleration but introducing a cosmological constant and/or a hypothetical substance, called dark energy, with negative pressure can result in repulsive forces and hence can account for an accelerating Universe. At the same time many other justifications for this dimming of SNe 1a were suggested. One such justification is photon number not being conserved along the ray path. This violation of conservation of photon flux can be due to some astrophysical effects such as photon attenuation due to interstellar dust, gas or plasmas in the host galaxy, intervening galaxies or the Milky Way ( M ´ e nard et al. 2008 ; Bovy et al. 2008 ) . Other reasons for this violation could be reappearing or disappearing of photons due to coupling with exotic particles in the presence of extra-galactic magnetic fields ( Avgoustidis et al. 2010 ) . Non-conservation of photon flux as it travels towards the earth from the source can affect the measurements of luminosity distance using SNe Ia observations and in consequence the estimated value of the cosmological parameters. It can also distort the observed evolution of the global stellar mass density with redshift. Thermal radiation of the intergalactic dust can add to the cosmic microwave background radiation (CMBR) and hence can alter the estimation of the cosmological parameters deduced from the observations ( Vavrycuk 2017 ; Narlikar et al. 2003 ) . The evidence of accelerating universe also comes from the observations of large scale structures, baryon acoustic oscillations and cosmic microwave background anisotropy . However, the question remains whether the accelerated expansion of the Universe alone is causing the dimming or opacity of the Universe can atleast partially account for the reduction of SNe Ia luminosity. The opacity of the universe has been examined using distance duality relation in multiple works with diverse cosmological observations. Distance duality relation expressed as: D_{L}=D_{A}(1+z)^{2} ; relates the luminosity distance D_{L} and the angular diameter distance D_{A} ( Etherington 1933 ) . The relation is true for any cosmological model if the following two properties are satisfied : (a) It is described by Riemannian geometry (b)The photon number is conserved and photons travel along the null geodesics ( Ellis 2007 ) . A model independent approach is used in some works while some specific cosmological models are used in others. Ma et al. 2019 obtained constraint on cosmic opacity using a combination of the observed and simulated data of strongly lensed SNe Ia and regular SNe Ia. Wei 2019 proposed a method to constrain cosmic opacity parameter by combining the gravitational wave (GW) observations with SNe Ia data in corresponding redshift ranges . Zhou et al. 2019 probed cosmic opacity at high redshifts using Gaussian process (GP) by reconstructing the luminosity distance from the GW data and comparing it with that deduced from the Pantheon SNe Ia and gamma ray burst (GRB) data in flat \Lambda CDM model. Liu et al. 2020 considered the nonlinear relation between X-ray and UV emissions of quasars to derive the luminosity distances and Hubble parameter H(z) measurements along with simulated GW events were used to derive the opacity-independent distances. While Xu et al. 2020 probed the opacity using the Pantheon SNe Ia and the Hubble parameter (H(z)) data in \Lambda CDM and wCDM models with or without spatial curvature, Fu et al. 2021 used the combination of future gravitational wave and SNe Ia observations to measure cosmic opacity. All of these works report a transparent Universe or small opacity on an average for the redshift range of the dataset used within 1\sigma error range; see Table 2. Elizalde & Khurshudyan 2022 used Bayesian machine learning to probe the cosmic opacity and Yang et al. 2024 measured curvature parameter and cosmic opacity by combining the observations of HII galaxies acting as standard candles with the H(z) observations and reported a slightly opaque Universe. In most of the works, the average cosmic opacity is probed for the entire redshift range of the datasets used. However, it is an integral quantity that depends upon the dust distribution along the path from source to observer, proper dust density and dust extinction efficiency. It is a spatially dependent quantity and varies with the frequency and redshift ( Aguirre 1999a ; Aguirre 1999b ; Aguirre 2000 ; Corasaniti 2006 ; Vavrycuk 2018 ; Vavrycuk 2019 ) . In this paper we present a model independent method to examine the variation of the cosmic opacity with redshift. We use strong gravitational lensing data to estimate the opacity independent angular diameter distances and latest SNe 1a Pantheon+ data to measure luminosity distances at the corresponding redshifts. In an opaque universe with optical depth \tau(z) , the flux received from SNe will be diminished by a factor of e^{-\tau(z)} . The optical depth varies with redshift z and is zero for a transparent Universe. The luminosity distance D_{L_{SN}} measured from SNe 1a

Read the complete text