Graph Neural Networks for Generalized Mundlak Estimator under Network Confounding

Lianyan Fu · 2026

Read Graph Neural Networks for Generalized Mundlak Estimator under Network Confounding by Lianyan Fu (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2605-29238.txt.

Introduction

Lianyan Fu proposes a graph neural network version of the generalized Mundlak estimator. It removes bias from group-level heterogeneity while allowing dependence within groups. Fixed-effects models use group intercepts but demand linear additivity and independence within groups. They support only within-group comparisons. Instead, balanced group-level sums control bias between groups, so groups can be compared fairly. Graph message-passing learns nonlinear forms and captures interaction effects within groups. Theory shows double robustness and a normal limit as samples grow.

Catalog record

CREATORLianyan Fu
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE66704
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2605.29238

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Graph Neural Networks for Generalized Mundlak Estimator under Network Confounding Lianyan Fu Abstract This paper proposes a generalized Mundlak estimator based on graph neural networks ( GME-GNN ). The estimator is designed to mitigate bias arising from group-level heterogeneity and to accommodate within-group dependence among individuals. Traditional fixed-effects models handle group heterogeneity via group-specific intercepts, but require overly strict linear additivity and intra-group independence assumptions, and are confined to within-group comparisons. Rather than relying on intercepts, GME-GNN uses aggregated group-level balancing statistics to fully control between-group confounding, enabling valid cross-group comparisons and relaxing linearity constraints. It further employs graph neural network message-passing to adaptively learn nonlinear representations and capture intra-group interaction effects. Theoretical analysis shows that the estimator satisfies double robustness and is asymptotically normal. Simulation and empirical studies confirm its performance. Keywords: Network Confounding, Group-level Heterogeneity, Graph Neural Networks, Generalized Mundlak Estimator 1 Introduction When estimating causal effects in observational studies, research units are typically grouped by factors such as geographical region and industry category. 1 have documented that unobserved characteristics across these groups can substantially influence study outcomes. The classical fixed-effects model accounted for unobserved group-level heterogeneity by incorporating group-specific intercepts. However, as pointed out by 2 , the estimation of causal effects using fixed-effects models relied on overly strict assumptions. These assumptions included homogeneous treatment effects, linear-additive relationships between treatment variables and covariates, and complete independence among individuals within groups. To relax these assumptions, the Mundlak estimator reinterpreted the fixed-effects model by replacing group fixed effects with group-level means of the treatment variables and covariates ( 18 ) . 2 further extended the classical Mundlak approach and demonstrated that group-level balancing scores sufficiently eliminated between-group confounding effects. However, it crucially relied on the stable unit treatment value assumption ( SUTVA ), which posed significant challenges for its application in network observational studies. Recent studies have developed inference methods for clustered data settings where interference is confined within clusters. This is sometimes called partial interference ( 21 ) . 10 proposed a framework for estimating causal effects in two-stage randomized designs under the constraint of partial interference. 17 proposed a doubly robust estimation method under partial interference, which helped reduce bias from model misspecification. 20 proposed generalized augmented inverse propensity weighted ( AIPW ) estimators for heterogeneous partial interference that are semiparametrically efficient and robust to model misspecification. However, these estimators still failed to adequately capture nonlinear dependencies and higher-order neighborhood effects. To overcome these limitations, 14 introduced a graph neural network ( GNN )-based framework that used message-passing to adaptively aggregate multiorder neighborhood information. In addition, 16 and 9 have demonstrated the effectiveness of GNNs for estimating individual treatment effects in network settings, addressing computational scalability and confounder disentanglement, respectively. These methods effectively captured nonlinear and higher-order dependencies, significantly improving causal estimation in complex network environments. To address the core challenge of violated SUTVA due to within-group interdependencies, this paper proposes a generalized Mundlak estimator based on graph neural networks ( GME-GNN ). This estimator synergizes the Mundlak method’s strength in modeling between-group heterogeneity with the power of graph neural networks ( GNNs ) to adjust for network confounding. It thereby relaxes the three core restrictive assumptions of traditional fixed-effects models discussed earlier. Specifically, we extend the classical Mundlak approach by constructing generalized group-aggregated balancing statistics that incorporate network-weighted aggregates of treatment and covariate information. This construction eliminates between-group unobserved confounding while accounting for network dependencies entirely ignored in the original framework. Meanwhile, we utilize the message-passing mechanism in GNNs ( 4 ) to learn adaptive node embeddings. These embeddings effectively capture dependency structures in the network by iteratively aggregating the features and treatment states of neighboring nodes. For statistical inference, we employ the network HAC estimator 13 and adopt the bandwidth selection procedure by 14 to account for the machine learning estimation error. We evaluated the propose theoretical framework through a combination of simulation studies and an empirical analysis examining the impact of the High-Tech Enterprise Certification policy. We simulate based on the Watts–Strogatz small-world network model, examining scenarios with both low/high inter-group heterogeneity and weak/strong network dependence. The results indicate that the bias of GME-GNN is significantly lower than that of the traditional Mundlak estimator under most settings. The empirical analysis is based on a sample of 4693 A - share listed companies in China in 2024. Firms are grouped into sectors according to the China Securities Regulatory Commission industry classification, and a network is constructed within each group using upstream - downstream supply - chain linkages. By using the balanced statistic \overline{S_{g}(i)} to control for inter-group confounding, the GME-GNN estimator captures both the direct causal effect of high - tech enterprise certification on financial performance and the indirect spillover effects transmitted through the supply - chain network. 2 Model Specification 2.1 Set up The initial fixed-effect model for estimating grouped causal effects is expressed as Y_{i}=\alpha_{g(i)}+W_{i}\tau+\boldsymbol{X}_{i}^{\top}\boldsymbol{\beta}+\varepsilon_{i}, (1) where g(i) denotes the group to which the i -th unit belongs. The term \alpha_{g(i)} represents the group fixed effect, capturing the influence of unobserved factors common to all units within the same group. Here, W_{i} denotes the treatment variable for individual i , and \tau represents the average causal effect of the treatment. The vector \boldsymbol{X}_{i} comprises control variables that may influence the outcome variable Y_{i} , and \boldsymbol{\beta} is the corresponding coefficient vector. The error term \varepsilon_{i} is assumed to be independent of both W_{i} and \boldsymbol{X}_{i} . As 2 point out, the ability of equation ( 1 ) to provide valid causal effect estimates is critically dependent on on a number of strong assumptions. This paper elucidates these assumptions by breaking them down into four components. First, the constant treatment effect assumption, this implies homogeneous treatment impacts. In practice, it is likely the effects of the treatment are heterogeneous. Second, the core of equation ( 1 ) is the assumption of group unconfoundedness. Third, the linearity and additivity assumption demands that relationships between the fixed effects \alpha_{g(i)} , treatment W_{i} , and covariates \boldsymbol{X}_{i} are linear and additive. In addition, the independence assumption requires that groups are independent, and that individuals within the same group are also independent. The original assumption requires that individuals within a group are independent. However, in reality, individuals within a group may be interrelated. Therefore, we first relax this assumption, the model is subsequently expressed in the following form Y_{i}=\alpha_{g(i)}+m(\mathbf{W}_{g},\mathbf{X}_{g},\mathbf{A}_{g})+\varepsilon_{i}, where \mathbf{W}_{g} denotes the vector of treatment assignments for all units within the group, \mathbf{X}_{g} represents the matrix of observable covariates for all units in the group, and the group comprises N_{g} units in total. The symbol \mathcal{N}_{{g}} refers to a set of units within the group. These units are interconnected through an adjacency matrix \mathbf{A}_{g} , where A_{ij}=1 indicates a connection between units i and j , whereas A_{ij}=0 signifies no connection. Due to the presence of group fixed effects, the estimation of causal effects is typically confined to within-group comparisons between treatment and control units. To allow for partial between-group treatment-control comparisons, 18 approach can be employed by incorporating group-level covariate averages as additional regressors. 2 further demonstrate that these group-average terms not only effectively control between-group heterogeneity but also accommodate more flexible regression specifications. Consequently, the

Read the complete text