Supermassive black holes in six triaxial galaxies: Insights from SINFONI and MUSE observations
Sabine Thater, Avinash Chaturvedi, Davor Krajnović, Michele Cappellari, Sadegh Khochfar, Thorsten Naab, Marc Sarzi, Glenn van de Ven · 2026
Read Supermassive black holes in six triaxial galaxies: Insights from SINFONI and MUSE observations by Sabine Thater, Avinash Chaturvedi, Davor Krajnović, Michele Cappellari, Sadegh Khochfar, Thorsten Naab, Marc Sarzi, Glenn van de Ven (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2605-28959.txt.
Introduction
Sabine Thater and colleagues measure six supermassive black hole masses in early-type galaxies from stellar motions in SINFONI and MUSE observations. With Hubble photometry, they build triaxial Schwarzschild orbit-superposition models that recover the galaxies' complex 3D shapes. Strong triaxial features can bias mass estimates, and the authors correct for that effect. The six masses range from under half a billion to about three and a half billion solar masses. They agree with earlier axisymmetric models and Jeans models, and fit local black hole scaling relations.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Sabine Thater, Avinash Chaturvedi, Davor Krajnović, Michele Cappellari, Sadegh Khochfar, Thorsten Naab, Marc Sarzi, Glenn van de Ven |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 102146 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2605.28959
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Supermassive black holes in six triaxial galaxies: Insights from SINFONI and MUSE observations Sabine Thater, Avinash Chaturvedi, Davor Krajnović, Michele Cappellari, Sadegh Khochfar, Thorsten Naab, Marc Sarzi, Glenn van de Ven Abstract Dynamical modelling can be used to constrain the masses of central black holes; however, modelling massive galaxies is challenging due to their complexity. In this work, we report six new supermassive black hole mass measurements of massive early-type galaxies from stellar kinematics, which were extracted from adaptive optics-assisted SINFONI and MUSE observations. We combine the stellar kinematics with HST photometry to build DYNAMITE triaxial Schwarzschild orbit-superposition models. Our Schwarzschild models can recover the complex triaxial features of the galaxies and constrain the black hole masses of all six galaxies. We find that strong triaxial kinematic features can bias the mass measurements and correct for this effect. The derived black hole masses are ( 1.14 − 0.63 + 0.41 ) × 10 9 (1.14^{+0.41}_{-0.63})\times 10^{9} M ⊙ for NGC 3706, ( 1.19 − 0.80 + 1.34 ) × 10 9 (1.19^{+1.34}_{-0.80})\times 10^{9} M ⊙ for NGC 3923, ( 1.14 − 0.95 + 1.08 ) × 10 9 (1.14^{+1.08}_{-0.95})\times 10^{9} M ⊙ for NGC 4261, ( 4.68 − 4.26 + 2.99 ) × 10 8 (4.68^{+2.99}_{-4.26})\times 10^{8} M ⊙ for NGC 4636, ( 3.51 − 2.57 + 3.37 ) × 10 9 (3.51^{+3.37}_{-2.57})\times 10^{9} M ⊙ for IC 4296, and ( 2.43 − 1.65 + 1.53 ) × 10 9 (2.43^{+1.53}_{-1.65})\times 10^{9} M ⊙ for IC 4329 at 3 σ \sigma confidence level. We compare our measurements with published results from axisymmetric Schwarzschild modelling and with our Jeans Anisotropic Models (JAM), and obtain mostly consistent black hole masses. Most of our black hole mass estimates can be well constrained using only MUSE observations. All of our mass measurements are in agreement with local black hole scaling relations. 1 Introduction Supermassive black holes (SMBHs) are known to be hosted by almost all massive galaxies in the local universe and up to large redshifts. Their role in the evolution of galaxies is not yet fully understood, but the existence of tight scaling relations between SMBH mass ( M_{\rm BH} ) and different galaxy properties implies a co-evolution between the SMBHs and their host galaxies ( 79 ; 66 ; 129 ; 108 , e.g., reviews by) . The tightest scaling relations are found between M_{\rm BH} and the global velocity dispersion ( \sigma_{\rm e} ) or the stellar mass ( M_{*} ) of the host galaxy or its bulge. With nearly 200 SMBH masses estimated dynamically ( 152 , e.g. see compilation by) , an increased scatter has become apparent for both low-mass ( 67 ; 114 ; 115 ) and high-mass galaxies ( 44 ; 132 ; 38 ; 37 ) , suggesting a non-universal origin of the scaling relations. The origin of the scatter might be driven by evolutionary scenarios ( 82 ; 68 ) or by black hole seeding mechanisms ( 1 ; 91 , e.g.) . The key is that initial seed masses are above the current scaling relation, but the self-regulated feedback from black holes and mergers drives them towards the local scaling relations ( 70 , e.g.) . Photometric observations have shown that massive early-type galaxies (ETGs) can be distinguished in core and power-law galaxies depending on the shape of their nuclear profiles ( 59 ; 94 ; 92 ; 57 ; 123 ) . Instead of a continuously steep power-law surface brightness cusp, core galaxies have a shallow central light profile, depleted of stars with respect to the extrapolation of the outer surface brightness distribution ( 65 ) . While core scouring by merging black holes after one or more dissipationless galaxy mergers ( 109 ; 78 ; 119 ; 120 ; 63 ; 104 ; 122 ) is a popular scenario to explain this relation, the formation of depleted cores and the role of the SMBHs are still debated. This becomes apparent when one compares predictions of M_{\rm BH} from the scaling relations based on \sigma_{\rm e} and the core size ( R_{\rm b} ): M_{\rm BH} in large-core galaxies estimated from the {M_{\rm BH}-\sigma_{\rm e}} relation are under-massive, by up to a factor of 40, relative to expectations from their large R_{\rm b} values ( 44 ) . Table 1: The galaxy sample 1 1 1 Notes. Column 1: Galaxy name. Column 2: Morphological type ( 39 ) . For NGC 3706, we adopt the classification by 45 . Column 3: Distance to the galaxy taken from 17 for NGC 4261 and NGC 4636, and NED for the remaining galaxies. Column 4: Linear scale derived from the distance. Column 5: 2MASS total K-band magnitude ( 76 ) . Column 6: Break radius from a core-Sérsic fit to the surface brightness profiles. Values are taken from 46 , 32 , 125 , 32 , 13 and 93 . Column 7: Effective radius derived from SDSS r-band ( 19 ) or CGS B-band ( 72 ) imaging data. Column 8: Effective velocity dispersion derived by co-adding the spectra of the large-scale optical IFU data in elliptical annuli of the size of the effective radius. For NGC 4261 and NGC 4636 taken from 19 . Column 9: Inclination from 19 for NGC 4261 and NGC 4636 and 72 for the remaining galaxies. Column 10: Large-scale kinematics data used for the dynamical Schwarzschild models. Galaxy Type Distance Scale M K R_{\rm{b}} R_{\rm{e}} \sigma_{\rm{e}} i Large Scale (Mpc) (pc arcsec -1 ) (mag) (arcsec) (arcsec) (km s -1 ) (^{\circ}) (1) (2) (3) (4) (5) (6) (7) (8) (9) (10) NGC 3706 E 36.0 175 -25.10 0.11 30.6 270 79 SINFONI NGC 3923 E4-5 21.0 102 -25.09 1.68 86.4 240 48 MUSE NGC 4261 E2-3 30.8 149 -25.18 1.18 38.0 265 89 MUSE NGC 4636 E0-1 14.3 69 -24.36 1.52 89.1 181 89 MUSE IC 4296 E 49.8 241 -25.99 1.44 68.4 330 57 MUSE IC 4329 S0 56.9 276 -25.74 0.79 120.0 296 67 MUSE The evolution of SMBHs might also differ for low- and high-mass galaxies ( 82 , e.g.,) . While accretion of gas is the main process for growing SMBHs, high-mass SMBHs can also acquire a significant amount of mass via SMBH merging during gas-poor major mergers ( 134 ; 155 ; 121 ) . This effect can be up to a factor of two for the most massive galaxies ( 160 ; 89 ) . Furthermore, it is unclear whether the different evolutionary paths of the SMBHs or the host galaxies are the main driver for the large scatter at the high-mass end. Massive galaxies often exhibit triaxial features ( 7 ; 8 ; 25 ) that cannot be described by axisymmetric models, which may lead to biased or uncertain estimates of the SMBH mass. NGC3379 was the first galaxy for which axisymmetric and triaxial M_{\rm BH} estimates were presented. This galaxy has only a minor twist in the photometry, has very regular stellar kinematics, and overall shows weak signs of triaxiality. However, the two mass estimates differ by a factor of two ( 149 ) , albeit within the modelling uncertainties. A truly triaxial galaxy, PGC046832, with rotations around both the major