Order-disorder trade-off in dirty quantum systems
Jinmin Yi, Chong Wang · 2026
Read Order-disorder trade-off in dirty quantum systems by Jinmin Yi, Chong Wang (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2605-28949.txt.
Introduction
Jinmin Yi and Chong Wang prove an order-disorder trade-off in one-dimensional quantum spin systems. For a disordered ensemble with exact Ising and average translation symmetry, gapped ensembles show one of two Edwards-Anderson-type features. Either an order parameter or an even-parity disorder parameter reaches order one. The result extends to nearly gapped ensembles with Griffiths-type rare-region effects. Applications include string order for symmetry-protected phases, a Lieb-Schultz-Mattis-type symmetry-breaking constraint, and trade-offs for fermion chains.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Jinmin Yi, Chong Wang |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 120405 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2605.28949
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Order-disorder trade-off in dirty quantum systems Jinmin Yi, Chong Wang Abstract We prove a trade-off theorem for order and disorder parameters in one-dimensional quantum spin systems with quenched disorder. For a disordered ensemble with exact Ising symmetry and average translation symmetry, any gapped ensemble must have one and only one of the following: an O ( 1 ) O(1) order parameter or an O ( 1 ) O(1) disorder parameter with even parity, both of the Edwards-Anderson type. The result extends to nearly gapped ensembles that accommodate Griffiths-type rare-region effects. These results offer a powerful and rigorous framework to understand the disorder effects beyond perturbative approaches. As applications, we (1) establish the existence of string order parameters for SPT phases; (2) derive a Lieb-Schultz-Mattis-type constraint for disordered ensembles, which requires a nearly gapped ensemble to spontaneously break the symmetry; and (3) discuss similar trade-off relations for disordered fermion chains, leading to an improved understanding of certain “intrinsically disordered” topological phases. I Introduction Quenched disorder plays a central role in condensed matter physics. In realistic dirty materials, its effects are both unavoidable and profound, ranging from disorder-induced localization to the quantized Hall effect. A key challenge in understanding disorder effects Sachdev 2011 is that disorder can give rise to intrinsically non-perturbative phenomena like rare region effects that lie beyond the reach of perturbative approaches Griffiths 1969 ; Vojta 2006 ; Fisher 1995 ; IGLOI and MONTHUS 2005 ; Yi and Burkov 2025 . Developing a rigorous framework for phases of dirty quantum systems therefore requires tools that can handle such non-perturbative effects. In this work, we establish a rigorous framework for understanding the effects of quenched disorder in the context of one-dimensional quantum spin chain. We focus on systems with an exact Ising symmetry and average translation symmetry, and we study the order and disorder parameters for such systems. The order and disorder parameters are powerful tools for understanding both the symmetry breaking phases and the symmetric topological phases in 1D clean systems, which also provides a useful foundation for the recent advance of the topological holography principle and symmetry topological field theory (SymTFT) Ji and Wen 2020 ; Chatterjee and Wen 2023 ; Kong et al. 2020 ; Huang and Cheng 2025 . In a clean chain with Ising symmetry S=\prod_{i}S_{i} , we say the system has an order parameter if there exist parity-odd local operators O_{i} such that \lim_{|i-j|\to\infty}\langle O_{i}O_{j}\rangle\neq 0, (1) detecting spontaneous symmetry breaking. Analogously, the system has a disorder parameter if there exist O_{i} , O_{j} with the same parity under S such that the string correlator \lim_{|i-j|\to\infty}\langle O_{i}O_{j}\prod_{i<k<j}S_{k}\rangle\neq 0, (2) detecting the symmetric phase. Levin Levin 2020 proved rigorously that any gapped, translationally invariant Ising chain has either an order parameter or a disorder parameter with even parity, but not both. In this work, we extend this dichotomy to quenched disordered systems. Since correlators can fluctuate in sign across disorder realizations, the correct diagnostic is the disorder average of the absolute value—the analogue of the Edwards-Anderson order parameter Edwards and Anderson 1975 . Thus for a disorder ensemble \{|\Omega_{\omega}\rangle\} with Ising symmetry S=\prod_{i}S_{i} we say it has an order parameter if there exist parity-odd local operators O_{i} such that \lim_{|i-j|\to\infty}\mathbb{E}_{\omega}\!\left(\left|\langle\Omega_{\omega}|O_{i}O_{j}|\Omega_{\omega}\rangle\right|\right)\neq 0, (3) where \mathbb{E}_{\omega} denotes the average over the ensemble, and analogously, it has a disorder parameter if there exist local operators O_{i} , O_{j} such that \lim_{|i-j|\to\infty}\mathbb{E}_{\omega}\!\left(\left|\langle\Omega_{\omega}|O_{i}O_{j}\prod_{i<k<j}S_{k}|\Omega_{\omega}\rangle\right|\right)\neq 0. (4) Our main result is that the clean dichotomy survives for gapped ensembles (all ground states uniformly gapped in its symmetry sector and in the same phase): any such ensemble has either an order parameter or a disorder parameter, but not both, and the endpoint operators of any disorder parameter must be even under S . The proof combines two ingredients: the principle that local perturbations perturb locally (LPPL) Bachmann et al. 2011 ; De Roeck and Schütz 2015 , which ensures that local order/disorder indicators depend only on nearby disorder variables, and a probabilistic analysis that relates the probabilities of local ordering and disordering events to the existence of global disorder-averaged parameters. The result extends to nearly gapped ensembles that accommodate rare Griffiths regions occurring with exponentially small probability in their size. Physically, the necessity of taking the absolute value before disorder averaging is straightforward to understand. For the order parameter, a spin-glass phase in which \langle O_{i}O_{j}\rangle_{\Omega_{\omega}} acquires random signs across the ensemble causes the first moment to vanish, while the Edwards–Anderson correlator remains finite. Similarly, for the disorder parameter, an “Anderson insulator” phase with localized yet randomly distributed \mathbb{Z}_{2} charge produces fluctuating signs of the disorder parameter, so that only the absolute moment survives disorder averaging. In our framework, both the random magnet and the Anderson insulator are viewed as simple gapped ensembles. Disorder also has a rich interplay with topological phases of matter. In this work we provide a rigorous handle on three examples: 1. For symmetry-protected topological (SPT) Chen et al. 2012 phases in 1d , we show that the Edwards-Anderson type disorder-averaged string order parameters Kennedy and Tasaki 1992 ; Pérez-García et al. 2008 ; Pollmann and Turner 2012 ; Haegeman et al. 2012 remain well-behaved diagnostics for different phases. 2. We derive a Lieb-Schultz-Mattis-type constraint Lieb et al. 1961 ; Oshikawa 2000 ; Hastings 2004 ; Cheng et al. 2016 ; Liu et al. 2025 ; Yi et al. 2025 ; Gioia and Wang 2022 ; Zou and Cheng 2026 for disordered ensembles Kimchi et al. 2018 ; Ma and Wang 2023 ; You and Oshikawa 2024 ; Xu and Jian 2025 ; Panahi et al. 2026 ; Li et al. 2026 : if a disorder ensemble has an average translation symmetry and an exact \mathbb{Z}_{2}\times\mathbb{Z}_{2} symmetry with a projective representation on each site, it cannot be nearly gapped without long-range order—it must develop an order parameter and break some symmetry. 3. Using Jordan-Wigner transform, the trade-off result can be translated to a similar result on fermion chains, now constraining two types of disorder operators, dressed by bosonic and fermionic operators, respectively. This result can be used to understand a class of “intrinsically disordered” topological phase proposed in Ref. Ma et al. 2025 . While many of the above results have been anticipated in some form in earlier literature based on physical arguments, our work puts them on a solid footing – this is particularly valuable for strongly disordered and interacting systems, where non-perturbative effects, such as rare regions, often render conventional methods uncontrolled. Indeed, without a proper understanding of rare-region effects, it was difficult even to formulate the correct statements, let alone establish them rigorously. From this perspective, one important implication of our work is that the notion of a “nearly gapped ensemble” provides the natural generalization of the familiar concept of a “gapped state” in clean systems. The rest of this paper is organized as follows. In Sec. II we introduce the setting, define order and disorder parameters for disordered ensembles, review the LPPL principle and our model of rare-region effects, and provide a road map for our main results. In Sec. III we prove the order-disorder trade-off theorem for gapped ensembles: Sec. III.1 fixes technical notation, Sec. III.2 introduces the probabilistic events for order