Hardware-Tailored Resource Estimation for Magic-State Distillation on Silicon Spin Qubits
Songqinghao Yang, Christopher K. Long, Rubén M. Otxoa, Prakash Murali, Crispin H. W. Barnes, David R. M. Arvidsson-Shukur · 2026
Read Hardware-Tailored Resource Estimation for Magic-State Distillation on Silicon Spin Qubits by Songqinghao Yang, Christopher K. Long, Rubén M. Otxoa, Prakash Murali, Crispin H. W. Barnes, David R. M. Arvidsson-Shukur (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2605-28936.txt.
Introduction
Songqinghao Yang and colleagues estimate resources to make high-fidelity logical magic states on silicon spin qubits. They compare shuttling, dense nearest-neighbor, and hybrid layouts, plus surface, color, and biased codes, across two protocols. A noise model built from a silicon-processor Hamiltonian with parameters and low-frequency non-Markovian noise feeds costs for spin dynamics, factoring, and quantum chemistry. Tuned control pulses cut distillation overhead by 42 percent against standard gates, and tailored biased codes shrink the footprint about threefold against the surface code.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Songqinghao Yang, Christopher K. Long, Rubén M. Otxoa, Prakash Murali, Crispin H. W. Barnes, David R. M. Arvidsson-Shukur |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 119135 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2605.28936
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Hardware-Tailored Resource Estimation for Magic-State Distillation on Silicon Spin Qubits Songqinghao Yang, Christopher K. Long, Rubén M. Otxoa, Prakash Murali, Crispin H. W. Barnes, David R. M. Arvidsson-Shukur Abstract We present a resource analysis for generating high-fidelity logical magic states on silicon spin-qubit platforms. We consider a range of architectures, including a shuttling-based SpinBus design, a dense nearest-neighbor layout, and a hybrid scheme with shuttling-connected patches. We compare surface, color, and biased error-correcting codes, and analyze the 5 → 1 5\to 1 and 15 → 1 15\to 1 magic-state distillation protocols. Our approach combines bottom-up and top-down methodologies. We construct a hardware-level noise model based on a silicon-processor Hamiltonian with realistic parameters and 1 / f 1/f non-Markovian noise, enabling estimation of physical resources required to reach target logical error rates. These results are propagated to system-level overheads for applications including spin dynamics, integer factorization, and quantum chemistry. Conversely, we fix target logical fidelities and derive corresponding constraints on hardware performance. Our framework enables systematic evaluation of resource-reduction strategies. We find that optimized control pulses reduce magic-state distillation overhead by 42% compared to standard gate implementations. In addition, silicon-tailored biased error-correcting codes achieve an approximately threefold reduction in physical footprint relative to the surface code, even without physical-bias-preserving operations. I Introduction Quantum computers process information in ways that are fundamentally different from classical computers, offering the prospect of advances in cryptography 167 ; 68 , Hamiltonian simulation 121 ; 33 ; 8 , computational chemistry 4 ; 51 ; 110 , and optimization 72 ; 57 . Rapid experimental progress across multiple platforms has led to steady improvements in qubit number, wall-clock time, and control fidelity, strengthening the case for scalable quantum computation 213 ; 80 ; 11 . However, current quantum hardware remains intrinsically noisy: decoherence and control imperfections prevent reliable execution of complex algorithms 62 ; 177 ; 48 ; 46 ; 151 ; 18 ; 132 . Scalable quantum computation, therefore, requires fault-tolerant architectures based on quantum error correction (QEC) 173 ; 26 ; 101 ; 78 ; 187 ; 63 . Recent years have seen several platforms take steps towards fault-tolerant architectures 7 ; 181 ; 152 ; 190 . In such architectures, logical qubits are encoded in multiple physical qubits. As long as the input states are restricted to stabilizer states and the operations to Clifford gates and Pauli measurements, standard QEC protocols actively detect and correct errors during computation. While QEC enables the detection and correction of noise, it does not provide a complete solution for universal quantum computation. In particular, Clifford gates and Pauli measurements are not universal 1 . To harness the full power of quantum computation, one needs access to non-Clifford operations. Magic-state distillation (MSD) provides one path to promote error-corrected quantum computers to universal ones 154 ; 20 ; 155 ; 156 ; 133 ; 94 ; 19 ; 117 . In MSD, noisy (non-stabilizer) magic states are prepared at the physical-qubit level. These states are then injected into the hardware’s logical space. In the logical space, the magic states are distilled to improve their fidelity. After the fidelity reaches some target value, the magic states can be injected into the error-corrected computer to implement high-fidelity non-Clifford operations, thus enabling universal quantum computing 19 ; 114 . Recent proof-of-principle experimental work has demonstrated high-fidelity preparation and distillation of logical magic states on error-corrected qubits 44 ; 162 . In the last years, several studies have estimated the resources needed to utilize fault-tolerant hardware. These studies consider the total number of physical qubits and the wall-clock time needed to implement a specific quantum algorithm 6 ; 82 ; 11 ; 195 ; 116 ; 137 ; 118 ; 59 ; 25 ; 180 . Typically, the QEC and MSD protocols utilized in a specific implementation are identified as the major contributors to the computational overhead. The overheads incurred by a certain MSD protocol can only be quantified in light of a specific QEC protocol, and vice versa 201 ; 117 . Moreover, noise profiles and qubit-connectivity architectures vary widely across such platforms, with direct implications on the suitability of various QEC and MSD protocols. Thus, to attain the highest accuracy in resource estimation, one must consider the specific physical platform in which the quantum hardware is implemented. Previous works have estimated quantum-computational resources for quantum computation with neutral atoms 91 ; 214 , photons 116 ; 119 , and superconducting qubits 71 ; 90 . However, to the best of our knowledge, no thorough resources estimation has been conducted for quantum computation with electron-spin qubits in silicon. Quantum-computing hardware with electron-spin qubits in silicon was originally proposed in the seminal work of Loss and DiVincenzo 126 . Currently, such hardware is experiencing a surge in research interest 196 ; 23 ; 179 ; 29 ; 149 ; 17 ; 169 ; 146 ; 113 ; 168 ; 135 ; 75 ; 104 ; 138 . In Loss-DiVincenzo processors, single electrons are trapped in arrays of gate-based quantum dots within a silicon substrate embedded in a semiconductor heterostructure 21 ; 215 . The spin of these electrons encode the physical qubits. A main selling point is the small spatial footprint of the physical qubits (tens of nanometers 197 ; 140 ; 216 ; 53 ). Moreover, the processors are compatible with current industrial production lines for CMOS and advanced semiconductor technologies, as well as with classical control electronics 172 ; 131 ; 216 ; 38 ; 183 ; 184 . Spin qubits in silicon can have long T_{1} times (around 1 \mathrm{ms} to 1 \mathrm{s} 85 ; 172 ; 146 ) and T_{2}^{*} times (around 10 to 100~$\mathrm{\SIUnitSymbolMicro s}$ 172 ). Current gate fidelities are competitive 41 ; 73 ; 107 ; 202 ; 210 with 99.9% 130 ; 143 ; 136 ; 176 for two-qubit operations and up to 99.999% 207 ; 205 for single-qubit operations. Earlier concerns about silicon spin-qubit connectivity have been partially alleviated by the demonstration of coherent electron shuttling over micrometer distances 165 ; 199 ; 36 at fidelities surpassing 99.5% over 10~$\mathrm{\SIUnitSymbolMicro m}$ 49 . To summarize, electron spin-qubits in silicon provide a competitive platform for future quantum computation. Motivated by these considerations, we present a hardware-tailored resource analysis of logical magic-state production in silicon spin-qubit architectures. We evaluate different physical-qubit-connectivity models, QEC codes and distillation protocols. With hardware-tailored noise modeling, we estimate the resulting space-time volumes for MSD. This allows us to estimate also the overheads for the implementation of specific quantum algorithms. Going beyond resource estimation, we also invert the analysis: for a target logical magic-state fidelity, we identify the corresponding hardware requirements on the physical noise and operational parameters. Thus, we can study the effect of hardware or software improvements on the resource budget for a specific algorithm. In particular, we gauge the potential resource benefits of using silicon-tailored QEC codes compared to standard QEC protocols. Together, our results clarify the tradeoffs between connectivity models, QEC codes , and MSD protocols in silicon spin-qubit systems. Further, our work provides a package for the analysis of experimental bottlenecks and a testbed for the construction and evaluation of new QEC and MSD protocols. The remainder