Too many protoclusters? Reconciling the overabundance of cluster progenitors within the first billion years of the Universe

Callum Witten, Jake S. Bennett, Pascal A. Oesch, Seunghwan Lim, Chamilla Terp, Jakob M. Helton, Kasper E. Heintz, Romain A. Meyer, William McClymont, Thomas Herard-Demanche, Emma Giovinazzo · 2026

Read Too many protoclusters? Reconciling the overabundance of cluster progenitors within the first billion years of the Universe by Callum Witten, Jake S. Bennett, Pascal A. Oesch, Seunghwan Lim, Chamilla Terp, Jakob M. Helton, Kasper E. Heintz, Romain A. Meyer, William McClymont, Thomas Herard-Demanche, Emma Giovinazzo (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2605-28930.txt.

Introduction

Callum Witten and colleagues revisit the apparent surplus of Coma-like cluster progenitors seen by JWST in the first billion years. They show past comparisons mixed two errors. Aperture-summed halo masses were set against virial-radius simulation masses, and backward-tracked growth was used where forward tracking fits better. Fixing both errors, plus merging coincident candidates and cosmic variance, removes the tension entirely: most candidates are likely proto-groups, and none looks set to become a Coma-like cluster.

Catalog record

CREATORCallum Witten, Jake S. Bennett, Pascal A. Oesch, Seunghwan Lim, Chamilla Terp, Jakob M. Helton, Kasper E. Heintz, Romain A. Meyer, William McClymont, Thomas Herard-Demanche, Emma Giovinazzo
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE55166
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2605.28930

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Too many protoclusters? Reconciling the overabundance of cluster progenitors within the first billion years of the Universe Callum Witten, Jake S. Bennett, Pascal A. Oesch, Seunghwan Lim, Chamilla Terp, Jakob M. Helton, Kasper E. Heintz, Romain A. Meyer, William McClymont, Thomas Herard-Demanche, Emma Giovinazzo Abstract JWST has revealed an overabundance of apparent (‘Coma’-like) cluster progenitors at z > 5 z>5 that is ∼ \sim two (300) times in excess of, and in 2.3 ​ σ 2.3\sigma ( 4 ​ σ 4\sigma ) tension with, the number density of such objects at present day and theoretical predictions from Λ \Lambda CDM. We present an analysis of protocluster candidates between 5 < z < 9 5<z<9 from the literature, and in the TNG-Cluster and TNG300 simulations, aimed at resolving this tension. We first identify an inconsistency in how protocluster candidates are characterised: observational halo masses are estimated by summing the stellar mass over very large apertures ( ≳ 50 ​ R vir \gtrsim 50\,R_{\rm vir} ), but are compared to the halo mass within the virial radius from simulations. In addition, these halo masses are commonly compared to the backward-tracked halo mass evolution of clusters, whereas a forward-tracked evolution of massive high-redshift haloes is more appropriate. Correcting these inconsistencies, while accounting for the merging of coincident protoclusters and the fluctuations associated with cosmic variance, entirely alleviates the tension. Ultimately, we find that 64 % 64\% of the protocluster candidates are instead likely to be proto-groups (i.e., M 200 ​ c < 10 14 ​ M ⊙ M_{200c}<10^{14}\,{\rm M_{\odot}} ) and none appear likely to become Coma-like clusters (i.e., M 200 ​ c > 10 15 ​ M ⊙ M_{200c}>10^{15}\,{\rm M_{\odot}} ) by z = 0 z=0 . Although some of these overdensities may not become clusters, they still trace extreme nodes of the cosmic web that may host early environmental effects, drive the first ionised regions, and contribute significantly to the cosmic star-formation rate density. These results demonstrate the need for more careful comparisons between observations and simulations of high-redshift protoclusters, and that improved selection criteria, potentially using the summation of the halo mass on Lagrangian scales, are vital for high-redshift protocluster science. 1 Introduction The formation of structure throughout the Universe is remarkably well described by the \Lambda cold dark matter ( \Lambda CDM) model ( 61 ; 12 ) . While small-scale perturbations in the dark matter distribution result in the formation of galaxies in the early Universe, large-scale overdensities, with time, collapse into massive clusters of galaxies. At present day we define galaxy clusters to be dark matter haloes with masses of M_{\rm halo}>10^{14}\,{\rm M_{\odot}} ( 83 ; 59 , e.g.) . The progenitors of these, coined protoclusters ( 59 ) , are thought to be some of the most massive haloes in the early Universe hosting extreme overdensities of galaxies ( 21 ) . At low redshift ( z<2 ) it is possible to measure an accurate halo mass using X-ray emission, the Sunyaev–Zeldovich (SZ) effect and velocity dispersion measurements ( 76 ; 15 ; 57 ; 47 ; 11 , e.g.) . However, in the first billion years, this is increasingly challenging. Protoclusters are in the early stages of virial heating and the development of a hot circumgalactic medium (see 9 for further discussion), meaning X-ray and SZ detections are very difficult. While detections have been made at high redshift ( 95 ; 13 ) , these are often tentative and may produce biased halo mass measurements, due to higher levels of non-thermal pressure support in unvirialised haloes ( 8 , see e.g.) . Moreover, the galaxies resident within high-redshift protoclusters are also unlikely to be virialised, and as such, their velocity dispersions will not trace the virial mass of the structure. Therefore, at high redshift, while galaxy overdensities are typically assumed to trace dark matter overdensities, and hence are thought to be key to identifying potential protocluster candidates ( 21 , e.g.) , alternative indirect tracers of their halo masses are required. The sensitivity and spectral coverage of JWST has facilitated the detection of an abundance of galaxy overdensities at z>5 ( 41 ; 32 ; 53 ; 52 ; 91 ; 26 ; 34 ; 33 ; 70 ; 17 ; 40 ; 50 ; 51 ; 78 ; 42 ; 69 ; 13 ; 35 ; 93 ; 88 ; 86 ; 18 ; 94 ; 92 ) . These overdense regions of the early Universe are seen to produce some of the most evolved galaxies at high redshift ( 3 ; 52 ; 90 ; 81 ; 27 ; 92 ) , although this is potentially a function of halo mass (see 91 ; 28 ; 78 for further discussion). They are also thought to be the engines behind the first ionised regions ( 46 ; 88 ; 19 ; 49 ) . These overdensities range from large-scale collections of relatively low-mass galaxies ( 26 , e.g.) to small-scale clusters of massive objects ( 32 ; 27 ; 85 , e.g.) , and it is therefore important to consider which environments trace the most massive dark matter haloes. Previous works have often focused on summing the halo masses of all galaxies within the overdensity to establish the ‘total’ halo mass. These total halo masses reported in the literature are typically summed over very large apertures. These have sizes that are comparable to the protocluster Lagrangian radius ( R_{\rm L}\sim 10-15 cMpc at z>5 ; 21 ), which is defined to be the radius encapsulating all galaxies that reside within the eventual cluster at z=0 . Often, this total halo mass is then compared to the typical halo mass of ‘Coma’-like cluster ( M_{\rm halo}>10^{15}\,{\rm M_{\odot}} ; 96 ; 97 ) progenitors at a given redshift from the simulation analysis of 21 . 21 utilise the Millennium Run N-body simulation ( 75 ) with semi-analytic galaxy formation models from 31 to follow the most massive progenitors, i.e. the backward-tracked evolution, of present-day Coma-like clusters (see Figure 2 of 21 ). Such simulations measure the halo mass ( M_{200c} ) within R_{200c} , which is defined as the radius of the volume within which the mass density is 200 times the critical density of the Universe, \rho_{\rm crit}(z) , at a given redshift: R_{200c}=\left[\frac{3M_{200c}}{4\pi\times 200\,\rho_{\rm crit}(z)}\right]^{1/3}\,. (1) For halo masses ranging from M_{200c}\,[{\rm M_{\odot}}]=10^{11}-10^{12} , the associated virial radius ranges from R_{200c}\sim 15-50 pkpc in the redshift range 5<z<9 . When the observed total halo mass is found to be consistent with, or in excess of, the M_{200c} evolution from 21 , these overdensities are typically reported to be protocluster candidates. While this is assumed to be an effective method for selecting protoclusters, a notable challenge arises: a significant excess in the number density of protocluster candidates relative to \Lambda CDM predictions. This excess has been previously noted by 34 , 43 and 26 , and even for comedic effect by 45 . This discrepancy is relative to the cluster mass function at present day, which is well constrained by a combination of simulations ( 5 ; 38 ; 25 ; 84 ; 79 ; 2 ) and observations ( 29 ; 66 ; 82

Read the complete text