DFT Accuracy on Crystal Structure Prediction with Machine Learning Interatomic Potentials Preprint: AIP/123-QED

Laurence I. Midgley, Chen Lin, J. Harry Moore, Flaviano Della Pia, Javier Antorán, Sten O. Nilsson Lill, Emma S. E. Eriksson, Felix A. Faber, Lars Tornberg, Anders Broo, Gábor Csányi · 2026

Read DFT Accuracy on Crystal Structure Prediction with Machine Learning Interatomic Potentials Preprint: AIP/123-QED by Laurence I. Midgley, Chen Lin, J. Harry Moore, Flaviano Della Pia, Javier Antorán, Sten O. Nilsson Lill, Emma S. E. Eriksson, Felix A. Faber, Lars Tornberg, Anders Broo, Gábor Csányi (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2605-28905.txt.

Introduction

Laurence I. Midgley and ten colleagues test CSP-MACE-Å, an atom model replacing DFT in crystal guessing. They split energy into inner and outer parts. They train the inner part on OMol25 with MACE-POLAR. They build the outer part from MACE-POLAR, spread, and delta terms. On 19 AstraZeneca compounds it matches PBE DFT. On 28 blind-test compounds it nearly matches B86bPBE-XDM DFT. Wave free scores beat energy ranking. It beats MACE-POLAR-1 and UMA-OMC.

Catalog record

CREATORLaurence I. Midgley, Chen Lin, J. Harry Moore, Flaviano Della Pia, Javier Antorán, Sten O. Nilsson Lill, Emma S. E. Eriksson, Felix A. Faber, Lars Tornberg, Anders Broo, Gábor Csányi
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE36460
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2605.28905

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

DFT Accuracy on Crystal Structure Prediction with Machine Learning Interatomic Potentials Preprint: AIP/123-QED Laurence I. Midgley, Chen Lin, J. Harry Moore, Flaviano Della Pia, Javier Antorán, Sten O. Nilsson Lill, Emma S. E. Eriksson, Felix A. Faber, Lars Tornberg, Anders Broo, Gábor Csányi Abstract Abstract We present an evaluation of CSP-MACE-Å, a machine learning interatomic potential intended to replace DFT in crystal structure prediction (CSP). We decompose the total energy into separate intramolecular and intermolecular components, allowing each component to be designed appropriately for its interaction type. For the intramolecular component, we adopt the MACE-POLAR architecture and train it on the OMol25 dataset. The intermolecular model is designed to capture the subtle intermolecular interactions in crystal structures. This intermolecular component combines three terms: an intermolecular contribution from the MACE-POLAR model, a long-range dispersion term with the functional form of the XDM correction, and a learned delta model trained to reproduce B86bPBE-XDM intermolecular energies. The learned delta model is trained on residual intermolecular targets derived from 50,000 B86bPBE-XDM calculations on molecular crystal structures. On an evaluation set composed of 19 compounds, including a salt, selected from AstraZeneca’s previous CSP publications, CSP-MACE-Å achieves performance comparable to PBE DFT with the Neumann–Perrin dispersion correction. On a second evaluation set composed of 28 compounds, including cocrystals and salts, collated from the seven CSP blind tests, CSP-MACE-Å achieves performance close to B86bPBE-XDM DFT. In both evaluation sets, reranking with harmonic free energies substantially improves performance relative to ranking by energy alone. Across our evaluation suite, CSP-MACE-Å is shown to outperform the MACE-POLAR-1 and UMA-OMC foundation models. Lastly, on a set of five compounds, CSP-MACE-Å is shown to capture temperature-dependent trends in the relative stability of polymorphs through estimation of the free energy under the harmonic approximation. By running multiple orders of magnitude faster than DFT, CSP-MACE-Å enables energy and free energy evaluation of far more candidate structures, providing greater confidence when derisking solid forms. I Introduction Solid-state form selection of an active pharmaceutical ingredient (API) is a critical aspect of drug development, as it affects bioavailability, manufacturability, and stability. Many drug- molecules exhibit crystal polymorphism, where different crystal forms possess distinct physicochemical properties such as solubility and dissolution behavior, making form selection both complex and essential. Polymorphism presents notable risks, particularly through late-appearing forms that may emerge during manufacturing or storage and alter product performance. Such events can lead to significant development and regulatory challenges, underscoring the importance of understanding the polymorphic landscape. Although experimental screening is the primary method for identifying suitable polymorphs, it may not capture all relevant forms. Computational approaches, especially crystal structure prediction (CSP), provide a valuable complement by enabling a more comprehensive exploration of possible crystal structures 8 . Together, these strategies support robust form selection and reduce the risk of unexpected solid-state transformations. CSP is generally broken down into two phases: structure generation and energy ranking. During generation, a large quantity of candidate structures (often in the millions) are produced. This is typically done by enumerating possible space groups and the number of formula units per cell in combination with random structure generation, to cover the crystal structure landscape. A preliminary ranking of the structures is performed via a computationally inexpensive method (e.g. a classical force field) and a small fraction of these, on the order of 1000 structures, are then passed onto the ranking phase. During the ranking phase, the structures are ranked using more computationally expensive and accurate techniques, to determine which are the most stable. The state-of-the-art for this phase is dispersion-corrected DFT (DFT-D), which has consistently dominated the seven CSP blind tests 25 ; 28 ; 11 ; 12 ; 2 ; 40 ; 21 ; 22 . Further accuracy at greater computational cost is often obtained by reranking with thermal free energies instead of lattice energies 14 . Despite its accuracy, DFT remains computationally expensive and slow. Crystal structure optimization typically takes hours, and free energy calculations can take days. Machine learning interatomic potentials (MLIPs) offer the possibility to replace DFT in CSP, potentially accelerating calculations by four orders of magnitude, while achieving close to DFT level accuracy. The most recent blind test was the first to include MLIPs; however, they showed subpar performance relative to DFT 21 . The key challenges for MLIPs in CSP are the need to model long-range electrostatics and dispersion, and to accurately capture subtle intermolecular interactions. The recently released MACE-POLAR-1 model is an MLIP that includes a principled treatment of long-range electrostatic interactions 3 . However, this model does not describe the long-range tail of dispersion, and is trained on the OMol25 dataset 24 which does not include crystal structures. In this work, we present an evaluation of CSP-MACE-Å which addresses these challenges to current MLIPs in CSP. The promise of a fast surrogate is not only to replace DFT in existing CSP workflows, but also to change the workflows themselves. The increased speed will allow more candidate structures to be studied in the ranking stage of CSP. This could improve accuracy in cases where viable polymorphs were excluded from the ranking stage due to the prohibitive cost of DFT 32 . Similarly, it could make free energy reranking practical in settings where the cost of DFT prohibits many structures (or any structures) from having their free energy computed. More broadly, the speed of an ML surrogate enables its use earlier in the drug development pipeline, and pairing it with property prediction (e.g. intrinsic solubility) would further extend its utility. II Methods II.1 CSP-MACE-Å The predicted energy of CSP-MACE-Å is decomposed into separate intermolecular and intramolecular components: E_{total}^{\text{CSP-MACE-Å}}=E_{intra}^{\text{CSP-MACE-Å}}+E_{inter}^{\text{CSP-MACE-Å}} (1) which provides flexibility to design each component of the model appropriately for the interaction type. We define the intramolecular energy as the sum of the energies of the constituent molecules in a crystal structure each isolated in vacuum. We then define the intermolecular energy as: E_{inter}=E_{total}-E_{intra} (2) where E_{total} is the energy of the full system with periodic boundary conditions and E_{intra} is the intramolecular energy. This definition is practical rather than canonical and allows us to easily decompose any energy function into its intramolecular and intermolecular contributions. This type of decomposition is common in the CSP literature and is sometimes referred to as monomer conformational energy corrections . It is typically used to combine higher level theory DFT or post-Hartree–Fock methods for the intramolecular term with less expensive DFT methods for the intermolecular term 19 ; 21 . II.2 Intramolecular model For the intramolecular component of CSP-MACE-Å, we train the MACE-POLAR architecture described in 3 , with the medium size setting, on the OMol25 dataset 24 . The MACE-POLAR architecture builds upon the local MACE architecture to include principled treatment of long-range electrostatics, which is critical for CSP. The OMol25 dataset is composed of 100 million ωB97M-V/def2-TZVPD 26 ; 39 DFT calculations covering a wide range of chemical space. The high level of theory and scale of the dataset make it well suited for training a model on intramolecular interactions. However, the MACE-POLAR architecture by itself is insufficient as it does not include long-range dispersion, which is of critical importance to CSP. Furthermore, the OMol25 dataset on which the MACE-POLAR model is trained is a poor choice for

Read the complete text