Imitation Learning for Robot Assistance in Open Surgery: A Multi-Policy Evaluation on Suture Following

Xucheng Wang, BS, Zhizhou Yang, MD, Xiaoman Zhang, PhD, Sung Eun Kim, MD, Romain Hardy, MS, Pranav Rajpurkar, PhD · 2026

Read Imitation Learning for Robot Assistance in Open Surgery: A Multi-Policy Evaluation on Suture Following by Xucheng Wang, BS, Zhizhou Yang, MD, Xiaoman Zhang, PhD, Sung Eun Kim, MD, Romain Hardy, MS, Pranav Rajpurkar, PhD (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2605-28736.txt.

Introduction

Xucheng Wang and five colleagues present the first test of general-purpose imitation learning for surgical-robot assistance in open surgery, focused on suture following. From 160 teleoperated demonstrations on a robot arm, they benchmark four imitation policies across 28 models and 32 configurations, varying dataset size, viewpoint, and background. Under ideal conditions the policies reach 50 to 75 percent success, with depth error the dominant failure mode, and π_0 leads thanks to a pretrained vision-language backbone. In a surgeon-robot suturing trial, π_0 reaches a 92 percent stitch completion rate, supporting collaborative robotic assistance as feasible.

Catalog record

CREATORXucheng Wang, BS, Zhizhou Yang, MD, Xiaoman Zhang, PhD, Sung Eun Kim, MD, Romain Hardy, MS, Pranav Rajpurkar, PhD
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE35996
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2605.28736

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Imitation Learning for Robot Assistance in Open Surgery: A Multi-Policy Evaluation on Suture Following Xucheng Wang, BS, Zhizhou Yang, MD, Xiaoman Zhang, PhD, Sung Eun Kim, MD, Romain Hardy, MS, Pranav Rajpurkar, PhD Abstract This study presents the first evaluation of general-purpose imitation learning for surgeon–robot collaborative assistance in open surgery , targeting suture following : the grab-pull-release motion an assistant performs at every stitch. We collect 160 teleoperated demonstrations (32,374 frames) on an open-source robot arm, benchmark four architecturally diverse imitation learning policies (ACT, Diffusion Policy, SmolVLA, π 0 \pi_{0} ) across 28 trained models evaluated in 32 configurations along three clinically motivated dimensions: dataset size , camera viewpoint , and background variation . Our results demonstrate that under ideal conditions, the four policies achieve 50–75% task success, with depth error as the dominant failure mode across all architectures. Among all policies, π 0 \pi_{0} achieves the strongest results with a pretrained vision–language backbone, demonstrating superior data efficiency, greater robustness to background variation, and smoother trajectories compatible with surgical workflow. When deployed in a surgeon–robot suturing trial, π 0 \pi_{0} yields a 92% stitch completion rate . These findings establish collaborative robotic assistance in open surgery as a feasible target for imitation learning and highlight depth perception and end-effector design as key priorities for clinical translation. 1 [2pt] 1,2 [2pt] 1 [2pt] 1 [2pt] 1 [2pt] 1 [2pt] † † volume: [VOLUME # TBD] † † year: 2026 1 Introduction Collaborative Open Surgery. Open surgery has been the primary treatment for the majority of surgical conditions worldwide ( 23 ; 19 ) , and is inherently collaborative: while the primary surgeon focuses on high-stakes dissection or reconstruction, an assistant provides exposure and performs critical assisting maneuvers at every step ( 6 ; 9 ) . This collaboration is especially evident during suturing: in a running closure or anastomosis, the assistant follows the suture, maintaining gentle tension and organizing the thread at each stitch so the surgeon can work efficiently. This grab-pull-release cycle is essential, highly repetitive, and a natural target for automation, particularly given the global shortage of trained surgical personnel ( 21 ; 11 ; 2 ; 12 ) and the limited availability of skilled assistants, even in well-resourced settings. Figure 1: Overview of the suture following task and experimental pipeline. (A) Four phases of a single suture-following cycle, shown from three camera views (overview, side, on-arm): Phase 1, the robot holds the suture taut while the surgeon drives the needle; Phase 2, the surgeon pulls the suture through as the robot returns home; Phase 3, the surgeon tightens the stitch while the robot locates the thread; Phase 4, the surgeon releases the thread to the robot, which grasps and tensions it before the cycle repeats. (B) 160 teleoperated demonstrations collected on open-source hardware are used to train four imitation learning policies, which are then evaluated across three axes in 32 configurations. Gaps in Existing Robotic Systems. Existing robotic surgical systems have largely focused on a different clinical setting: either enhancing or automating the primary surgeon’s tasks within the minimally invasive surgery (MIS) paradigm ( 25 ; 3 ; 22 ; 13 ) . Intra-procedural assistant roles in open surgery, by contrast, remain largely unstudied. In this work, we explore surgeon–robot collaboration for open surgery . The robot takes on the surgical assistant’s role, performing the repetitive supporting maneuvers at the bedside, while the surgeon retains the primary operative tasks, such as driving the needle and placing stitches. This keeps the robot’s responsibilities well-defined and lower-risk, while addressing a surgical setting that existing robotic platforms do not serve. Imitation Learning for Surgical Assistance. Realizing this collaboration requires a robot that can learn assistive behaviors from demonstration. Recent advances in imitation learning have demonstrated the feasibility of such assistive behaviors: open-source hardware and learning frameworks now enable a robot to acquire dexterous manipulation skills by observing human demonstrations ( 31 ; 8 ; 5 ) , and powerful policy architectures ( 7 ; 16 ; 4 ; 26 ) have pushed these capabilities to increasingly complex tasks. However, these approaches have seen limited application in surgical assistance: existing benchmarks ( 1 ; 28 ; 29 ) all target the surgeon’s role on MIS platforms, and no head-to-head comparison of general-purpose policies exists for any surgical assistive task. Our Approach and Contributions. In this work, we introduce suture following as a clinically grounded case study for surgeon–robot collaboration. Using an accessible, non-specialized open-source robotic platform, we collect 160 teleoperated demonstrations and conduct a systematic evaluation of four architecturally diverse imitation learning policies (ACT ( 31 ) , Diffusion Policy ( 7 ) , SmolVLA ( 26 ) , and \pi_{0} ( 4 ) ) across three clinically motivated axes: dataset size , camera viewpoint , and background variation (Figure 1 ). This offers an initial empirical comparison of how general-purpose imitation learning frameworks transfer to the precision requirements of surgical assistance, characterizing each architecture’s distinct failure modes and data efficiency. Generalizable Insights about Machine Learning in the Context of Healthcare • Imitation learning for intra-operative surgeon–robot collaboration in open surgery: We show the potential of imitation learning to support a robot taking on the surgical assistant’s role during an active open surgical procedure, establishing collaborative open-surgical assistance as a feasible and clinically relevant application domain for the ML-for-health community. • Pretrained vision–language backbones for clinical robustness: Our evaluation along three clinically motivated axes reveals that policies with pretrained vision–language backbones require fewer demonstrations to reach competent performance and degrade more gracefully under visual distribution shifts (camera viewpoint, background variation). This suggests that foundation-model-based architectures are particularly well suited for surgical environments, where visual conditions at deployment inevitably differ from those seen during data collection. 2 Related Work Surgical autonomy on MIS platforms. The dominant robotic surgical paradigm, exemplified by the da Vinci platform ( 25 ; 3 ) , is designed around the primary surgeon operating within minimally invasive surgery. Building on this hardware, learned surgical automation has progressed significantly on the da Vinci Research Kit (dVRK), from STAR’s supervised soft-tissue suturing ( 24 ) to SRT/SRT-H’s multi-task autonomy via imitation learning ( 15 ; 14 ) and SutureBot’s end-to-end suturing benchmark ( 10 ) . However, these methods rely on MIS consoles, limiting their direct transfer to open surgical workflows ( 22 ) . The literature targets the surgeon’s tasks (needle driving, knot tying) and pursues increasing levels of autonomous operation ( 13 ) ; the assistant’s subtasks, which are more repetitive and lower-risk, have received far less attention. Robotic surgical assistance. A nascent line of work has begun to target assistance rather than full autonomy. RoboNurse-VLA ( 17 ) automates the scrub nurse’s instrument handover role, which is independent from the surgical assistant and does not involve intra-procedural coordination with the surgeon’s actions on tissue. MoE-ACT addresses tissue retraction on the dVRK ( 20 ) and 18 demonstrates zero-shot sim-to-real for laparoscopic assistive tasks, but both operate within MIS through a teleoperated console rather than at the bedside. Collaborative intra-operative assistance in open surgery remains unstudied. Imitation learning policies. We evaluate four policies spanning three architectural families: ACT ( 31 ) , a conditional-VAE transformer; Diffusion Policy (

Read the complete text