A Homogeneous Catalog of Rossiter-McLaughlin Systems: Distinct $e$-$λ$ Trends in Three Gas-Giant Mass Regimes
Xian-Yu Wang, Songhu Wang, Konstantin Batygin · 2026
Read A Homogeneous Catalog of Rossiter-McLaughlin Systems: Distinct $e$-$λ$ Trends in Three Gas-Giant Mass Regimes by Xian-Yu Wang, Songhu Wang, Konstantin Batygin (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2605-28719.txt.
Introduction
Xian-Yu Wang, Songhu Wang, and Konstantin Batygin refit 256 Rossiter-McLaughlin systems with one method, joining spectral energy curves, transit light curves, transit times, and radial speeds. Using 146 single-star systems with solid planet masses, they find eccentricity-tilt patterns that depend on planet mass. Sub-Saturns can be both eccentric and misaligned, Jupiters are misaligned only on circular orbits, and super-Jupiters and brown dwarfs stay aligned across all orbits. A 2D Kolmogorov-Smirnov test confirms three mass regimes differ clearly, showing obliquity alone does not trace past history.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Xian-Yu Wang, Songhu Wang, Konstantin Batygin |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 39502 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2605.28719
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
A Homogeneous Catalog of Rossiter-McLaughlin Systems: Distinct e − λ e-\lambda Trends in Three Gas-Giant Mass Regimes Facilities: Kepler , Spitzer , TESS allesfast ( 205 ; 204 ) , Allesfitter ( 205 ; 204 ) , barycorrpy ( 272 ) , dustmaps ( 202 ) , emcee ( 179 ) , EXOFASTv2 ( 152 ; 149 ) , lightkurve ( 297 ) , matplotlib ( 253 ) , ndtest ( 296 ) , numpy ( 369 ; 505 ; 213 ) , pandas ( 339 ) , PyDE , scipy ( 503 ) , wotan ( 236 ) https://github.com/hpparvi/PyDE Xian-Yu Wang, Songhu Wang, Konstantin Batygin Abstract Stellar obliquity ( λ \lambda ) and orbital eccentricity ( e e ) trace the dynamical histories of close-in giant planets, but the current observational picture is assembled from heterogeneous analyses that have obscured population-level trends. In this work, we homogeneously refit systems with Rossiter-McLaughlin (RM) measurements by performing a joint global fit to spectral energy distributions, transit light curves, mid-transit times, out-of-transit and in-transit radial velocities, yielding self-consistent posterior distributions for the physical and orbital parameters of both stars and planets across 255 systems 1 1 1 For completeness, our sample also includes 21 systems whose projected stellar obliquities were inferred solely from line-profile techniques, for which the relevant data products are often not uniformly accessible, or from analyses without publicly available RM data. As a result, our global analysis for these systems is limited to deriving self-consistent system parameters, while the spin-orbit angles are adopted from the published literature. . Restricting to 145 single-star systems with reliable planet-mass measurements, we uncover pronounced structure in the e − λ e-\lambda plane that depends on planet mass: (i) sub-Saturns ( M p ≤ ∼ 0.3 M J M_{\rm p}\leq\sim 0.3M_{\rm J} ) can be both eccentric and misaligned; (ii) Jupiters ( ∼ 0.3 M J < M p ≤ ∼ 3 M J \sim 0.3M_{\rm J}<M_{\rm p}\leq\sim 3M_{\rm J} ) are misaligned only on circular orbits; and (iii) super Jupiters and brown dwarfs ( M p > ∼ 3 M J M_{\rm p}>\sim 3M_{\rm J} ) are aligned across the full eccentricity range. A two-dimensional Kolmogorov-Smirnov test shows that the joint ( e , λ ) (e,\lambda) distributions differ significantly among these three mass regimes. These trends demonstrate that λ \lambda depends jointly on eccentricity and planet mass, implying that obliquity alone is not a unique tracer of evolutionary history and underscoring the need for a unified framework for the origins of spin-orbit misalignment. The full catalog from this work is publicly available at www.stellarobliquity.com . I Introduction The first planets to be discovered beyond the Solar System were the close-in giants whose short periods made them unmissable to early radial-velocity surveys. Their existence immediately raised a profound question that still has no fully satisfactory answer: how did these massive worlds end up skimming the surfaces of their stars? Because these planets occupy a relatively narrow band of orbital separations, their semimajor axes provide little leverage on the physics of their origins (except for the tidally shaped pile-up of hot Jupiters; see, e.g. 125 ; 495 ; 187 ; 546 ). Instead, the dynamical clues are carried by the remaining degrees of freedom. Accordingly, eccentricity and inclination distributions of close-in giants are often treated as fossil records of the processes that shaped them, potentially encoding traces of disk-driven migration, high-eccentricity past, and tidal evolution. Historically, distinct formation and migration pathways for close-in giant planets were associated with different predictions for their dynamical architectures. In-situ assembly ( 42 ; 57 ) and smooth disk migration ( 200 ; 298 ) were expected to maintain low eccentricities and small inclinations, while high-eccentricity channels such as planet-planet scattering ( 387 ; 514 ) , secular interactions ( 545 ; 380 ; 477 ) , and Kozai-Lidov cycling ( 246 ; 544 ; 169 ; 352 ; 501 ) were envisioned as natural pathways to generate large values of both e and i prior to tidal damping. This contrast inspired the long-standing expectation that individual diagnostics, particularly high eccentricity ( 349 ; 73 ; 139 ; 256 ; 207 , e.g.,) or large mutual inclinations ( 343 ; 333 ; 11 ; 348 ) , could be used to distinguish between formation channels, under the assumption that these dynamical signatures covary at least in a statistical sense. Observers have often relied on measurable proxies for these quantities, such as orbital isolation ( 459 ; 250 ; 47 ; 95 ; 543 ) as an indicator of a high- e past, or the 3-D stellar obliquity \psi ( 521 ; 414 ; 9 ; 7 ; 277 , e.g.,) as a surrogate for mutual inclination. A growing body of theory shows that this one-to-one mapping between mechanisms and observables is rarely preserved. Eccentricities can be excited without significantly altering spin-orbit alignment through co-planar secular resonances ( 294 ; 380 ) . Conversely, stellar obliquities can be tilted while leaving eccentricities essentially unchanged. Proposed sources of such misalignments include primordial star-disk tilting driven by chaotic accretion ( 40 ; 478 ; 177 ; 41 ) , magnetic warping ( 180 ; 288 ; 400 ; 399 ) , or internal gravity wave-driven stellar tumbling ( 398 ) , as well as disk torquing by stellar companions ( 43 ; 334 ; 466 ) . Tidal evolution adds further complexity because the characteristic damping timescales for e and \psi differ in both magnitude and functional dependence ( 289 ; 521 ; 9 ; 295 ; 559 ) . As a result, tides may efficiently erase eccentricity while leaving the stellar spin misaligned, or conversely realign the star while preserving a remnant of the planet’s dynamical past. As a means toward unraveling this complexity, previous studies have primarily linked stellar obliquity to stellar properties, with the most notable trends appearing across the T_{\mathrm{eff}} boundary ( 414 ; 521 ; 510 ) . While not immediately expected, there is no a priori reason that planetary properties cannot be equally important. Accordingly, we treat these as hitherto under-explored degrees of freedom and search for empirical structure in the e - \psi plane, recognizing that e and \psi need not rise and fall together but can retain specific, correlated imprints of distinct dynamical pathways. Figure 1: An example plot for the global modeling of HD 209458, the first exoplanetary system with RM measurement ( 385 ) . From left to right, each panel represents the fits to the spectral energy distribution (SED), TESS transits, radial velocities, and Rossiter-McLaughlin effects. Figures for all systems can be found here . A range of statistical techniques can be used to infer eccentricity from the photo-eccentric effect ( 129 ; 275 ) , estimate mutual inclinations from multiplicity statistics ( 299 ; 484 ) , transit-duration distributions ( 167 ) , and transit-timing and transit-duration variations (TTVs/TDVs, 569 ; 342 ). Simultaneously, line-of-sight stellar obliquity ( i_{\star} ) can be constrained from v\sin i_{\star} statistics ( 414 ; 534 ; 301 ; 300 ; 344 ; 51 ) or from the amplitude distribution of spot modulation in light curves (e.g., 338 ). Nevertheless, the