Early warnings of critical transitions through vector autoregression: lessons from multiscale systems

Bryony Hobden, Paul Ritchie, Peter Ashwin · 2026

Read Early warnings of critical transitions through vector autoregression: lessons from multiscale systems by Bryony Hobden, Paul Ritchie, Peter Ashwin (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2605-28260.txt.

Introduction

Bryony Hobden, Paul Ritchie, and Peter Ashwin sharpen early warnings for tipping points where oscillations hide classic slowing-down signals. Their vector autoregression method recovers multiple system eigenvalues from several time series, identifying both stability and bifurcation type. Across fold, subcritical Hopf, and singular Hopf cases it beats watching single-series autocorrelation alone.

Catalog record

CREATORBryony Hobden, Paul Ritchie, Peter Ashwin
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE59228
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2605.28260

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Early warnings of critical transitions through vector autoregression: lessons from multiscale systems Bryony Hobden, Paul Ritchie, Peter Ashwin Abstract In a nonautonomous nonlinear dynamical system, generic critical transitions (tipping points) are not limited to slow passage through fold bifurcations. They can also correspond to slow passage through other generic bifurcations, such as subcritical Hopf or even (in the multiscale setting) singular Hopf bifurcation. In systems such as these, generic early warning signals associated with critical slowing down, such as observing an increase in variance and lag-1 autocorrelation, can be obscured by oscillatory behaviour. Here, we present a method using vector autoregression (VAR) that aims to identify multiple eigenvalues of the system from multiple time series. With this, we are not only able to deduce the system’s stability but also identify the type of bifurcation we are approaching and, therefore, the underlying dynamics, which gives us insight into the system’s future state post-tipping. In practice, this can be beneficial for estimation and mitigation of risk. We look at three bifurcations in particular: the fold, the subcritical Hopf bifurcation, and the singular Hopf bifurcation in the presence of an extra time-scale separation. We hope to show that VAR is potentially a powerful tool in an EWS toolkit and can be more enlightening than simply looking at AR(1) of individual time series, especially if there is more than one timescale present in the system. 1 Introduction Critical transitions or tipping points of nonlinear forced systems can be induced by slow passage through bifurcation points where an attracting equilibrium loses stability at some critical value of the forcing [ 35 ] . Such bifurcation-induced transitions (B-tipping) can be distinguished from noise-induced (N-tipping) and rate-induced (R-tipping) [ 5 ] . In this paper, we focus on generic mechanisms of bifurcation induced tipping for systems that may be multiscale. In the presence of noise, early warnings of loss of stability can be associated with the phenomenon of “critical slowing down” (CSD) (e.g. [ 10 , 11 ] ), where an increase in variance and autocorrelation of a typical observable correlates to a slowly changing system approaching a bifurcation point. This is typically assumed to be a fold (saddle-node) bifurcation, although other bifurcations can lead to critical transitions [ 23 , 39 , 7 , 20 ] . One can think of CSD as a way to estimate the leading (i.e. least stable) eigenvalue of the Jacobian at a nearby equilibrium. This method has been widely applied to try and identify indicators of imminent B-tipping in a slowly changing system, to warn whether a system may or may not tip into a different state. It has been observed that, in some circumstances, the warning may be missing [ 18 , 30 , 4 ] . Evaluating the skill of trends in CSD as early warnings of critical transitions can be challenging to extrapolate even in cases where CSD is applicable [ 27 , 4 ] , or may be misinterpreted in cases where there is N-tipping [ 12 ] . Note that early warning signals can be useful, even if the result is negative: the important factor is that they are skilful so that false positives and false negatives can be avoided. There is no unique way to find an early warning signal from a time series, even when assumptions about timescale separation and noise are satisfied. One may need to detrend, choose a sampling rate and window size that has enough points to give a good estimation of stability while still remaining approximately stationarity, though note that fitting a nonlinear model can help avoid detrending [ 13 , 26 ] . For rapidly forced slow systems, CSD typically does not work, but other approaches may be possible [ 20 , 9 , 32 ] . In most studies of bifurcation-induced tipping, only fold bifurcations have been considered. This occurs where a stable and unstable equilibrium collide and annihilate each other. This is often represented in diagrams showing 1D systems that can be written in terms of a gradient potential. However, at codimension 1 there are two generic bifurcations: fold (saddle-node) and Hopf bifurcations, and only the fold has such a gradient potential. In Section 2 we discuss which of these are considered “safe” and “dangerous” bifurcations in regards to tipping behaviour. It is very rare that Hopf bifurcations are considered for critical transitions, and very few studies consider early warnings for such bifurcations. One study [ 7 ] looks at deep learning for early warning signals in a range of bifurcations including Hopf. The paper highlights that normal forms of systems can reveal information about how the system will behave past the bifurcation or tipping point, i.e. if it will shoot off and go to an alternative stable state or oscillate. However, generic early warning signals extracted from a time series will not reveal this type of information. Hence a deep learning algorithm is able to identify normal forms in a range of applications. The paper [ 39 ] considers using vector autoregression (VAR) to obtain indicators for the approach to various types of bifurcation, in particular periodic attractors approaching homoclinic and Hopf bifurcations. For the homoclinic there are no signs of traditional critical slowing down, but a decreasing frequency which can be used as an indicator of approaching bifurcation. For the Hopf however, there is no significant frequency change but significant early warning with respect to the increasing real part of the eigenvalue. We build on [ 39 ] and we go one step further to consider Hopf bifurcation in a multiple time scale system, which can be a Singular Hopf bifurcation if the instability involves both fast and slow modes. To our knowledge, no study has proposed an early warning for a system exhibiting a singular Hopf bifurcation. However, fairly simple models in climate applications such as climate can certainly demonstrate Hopf instabilities (e.g. [ 1 ] in a 5-box model of Atlantic Meridional Overturning Circulation AMOC). Moreover, the singular Hopf bifurcation is already present in simple models (e.g. [ 33 ] for a model of ENSO). In previous work, [ 19 ] show that a regularization of the conceptual model [ 6 ] for Dansgaard-Oeschger (DO) events occurs via passage through a supercritical singular Hopf bifurcation at the onset of a DO event. The study [ 19 ] highlights that because of the singular Hopf instability, the predictability of tipping in the model using generic EWS is limited from the leading eigenvalue. In this paper, we focus on understanding and quantifying generic instabilities (using vector autoregressive processes) that may be associated with B-tipping from an attracting equilibrium in a multiscale system. Section 2 reviews some basic considerations from one-parameter bifurcation theory before highlighting that in multiple timescale systems, this needs interpretation due to the presence of eigenvalues with differing timescales. This means we can identify three distinct generic mechanisms where an equilibrium can lose stability. Section 3 recalls the \mathrm{VAR}(k,p) process and how \mathrm{VAR}(k,1) can be used to estimate stability for an equilibrium in a k dimensional system with noise. We consider not only the estimators but also the propagation of uncertainty through to the eigenvalues. Section 4 introduces a comparative example of

Read the complete text