Supervised Semantic Differential for Cross-Cultural Concept Analysis: A Case Study of Human Affect
Jan Sikora, Paweł Lenartowicz, Hubert Plisiecki · 2026
Read Supervised Semantic Differential for Cross-Cultural Concept Analysis: A Case Study of Human Affect by Jan Sikora, Paweł Lenartowicz, Hubert Plisiecki (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2605-28225.txt.
Introduction
Jan Sikora, Paweł Lenartowicz, and Hubert Plisiecki compare feeling words across cultures, past word-for-word translation. Their supervised meaning-gradient method tracks affect words in Polish, English, and French embeddings. Valence looks mostly shared, while arousal and dominance show patterned contrasts, some from corpus quirks, not culture, so readings need care.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Jan Sikora, Paweł Lenartowicz, Hubert Plisiecki |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 51994 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY SA |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2605.28225
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Supervised Semantic Differential for Cross-Cultural Concept Analysis: A Case Study of Human Affect Jan Sikora, Paweł Lenartowicz, Hubert Plisiecki Abstract Cross-cultural comparison of psychological meaning requires methods that go beyond word-level translation and examine how semantic dimensions are organized across languages. We introduce a cross-lingual extension of the Supervised Semantic Differential (SSD), which estimates supervised semantic gradients in embedding space and compares them across aligned multilingual word embeddings. The method tests gradient alignment and difference using permutation procedures and bootstrap intervals, and interprets residual differences through clustering around the difference gradient. We demonstrate the approach on Polish, English, and French affective norm lexicons, modeling Valence, Arousal, and Dominance where available. Affective dimensions were significantly recoverable across languages and model settings. Cross-lingual comparisons showed broad alignment together with structured residual differences: Valence appeared mostly shared, whereas Arousal and Dominance produced more interpretable contrasts involving bodily threat, aesthetic stimulation, internal emotionality, macro-level authority, and everyday control. Several clusters also reflected corpus-specific artifacts, underscoring the need for cautious interpretation. Cross-lingual SSD offers an explainable framework for testing semantic alignment, identifying divergence, and generating hypotheses about cross-cultural differences in psychological meaning. Code to reproduce our results is available at https://github.com/przebor/Cross-Cultural-SSD . 1 Introduction Cross-cultural psychology studies how concepts vary across cultures and languages. Cultural psychology has long argued that psychological processes such as cognition, emotion, and motivation are partly organized through culturally patterned models of selfhood and social life ( 16 ) . At the same time, linguistic approaches to culture emphasize that concepts do not always map cleanly across languages, because lexical meanings are embedded in culture-specific systems of interpretation ( 28 ) . This problem is especially important for psychological constructs, where the same label may not refer to exactly the same conceptual structure across cultural contexts. Cross-cultural comparison therefore requires methods that can move beyond asking whether individual words can be translated, and instead ask how larger regions of meaning are organized across languages. NLP research offers new tools for this problem. Recent work on cross-cultural NLP argues that cultural variation is not reducible to language coverage alone: speakers may differ in common ground, communicative norms, values, and the kinds of meanings they encode in text ( 9 ) . Broader surveys of culturally aware NLP likewise emphasize the need for methods that can represent, adapt to, and evaluate culturally situated meaning ( 15 ) . Word embedding models provide one route toward this goal by representing lexical meaning geometrically, making it possible to study concepts not only as isolated words, but as directions, neighborhoods, and regions in semantic space. Early work on word embeddings showed that semantic and syntactic regularities can often be captured through vector-space relations ( 19 ) , and related work in computational cultural analysis has used such geometric structure to study cultural associations and categories ( 12 ) . Cross-lingual embedding methods extend this idea by aligning independently trained monolingual spaces into a shared multilingual space, often through orthogonal transformations ( 4 ) . These models make it possible to compare semantic structure across languages, creating an opportunity for computationally explicit cross-cultural concept analysis. In this paper, we focus on the cross-cultural analysis of affective meaning. Emotions are a particularly important test case because they have long been central to debates about universality and cultural specificity. Classic work on facial expressions argued for pan-cultural associations between facial movements and discrete emotion categories ( 6 ) . In contrast, constructionist and cultural approaches argue that emotions are shaped by learned concepts, language, bodily inference, and culturally patterned forms of social life ( 1 ; 17 ) . Empirical work with remote cultural groups has likewise challenged strong claims of universality in emotion perception, suggesting that the interpretation of emotional expressions depends on culturally available concepts and task contexts ( 8 ) . These debates make affective meaning a useful domain for testing whether multilingual semantic models can reveal both shared and language-specific conceptual structure. Affective meaning is often studied through broad dimensions rather than through discrete emotion categories alone. The semantic differential tradition proposed that connotative meaning is organized around Evaluation, Potency, and Activity ( 23 ) , and cross-cultural work suggested that these dimensions recur across diverse linguistic communities ( 22 ) . Circumplex models similarly describe affective meaning in terms of dimensions such as Valence and Arousal, with evidence that such structures are at least partially recoverable across languages, including Polish and English ( 25 ) . However, the presence of shared affective dimensions does not imply that the same words, semantic neighborhoods, or conceptual domains define those dimensions in every language. Large-scale lexical norming datasets make this question empirically tractable: 27 provide ratings of Valence, Arousal, and Dominance for 13,915 English lemmas, while 11 provide affective and psycholinguistic ratings for 4,905 Polish words and 20 provide ratings of Valence and Arousal for 1,031 French words. These resources allow affective meaning to be modeled not only as individual word-level ratings, but as systematic dimensions of semantic variation. To better understand how psychological phenomena differ across culture, we extend the Supervised Semantic Differential (SSD) for comparing affective dimensions across languages. SSD estimates a semantic gradient in an embedding space by relating word or text representations to an external psychological variable, and then interprets the resulting direction through neighboring words, clusters, or text examples ( 24 ) . Here, we focus on a specific extension of SSD which uses a partial least squares (PLS) to fit the gradient and tests the fitted gradient for significance with a corrected resampled t -test over repeated train–test splits ( 21 ; 13 ) . We start by estimating Valence, Arousal, and Dominance gradients for Polish and English and the Valence and Arousal gradients for French. We first fit these gradients in monolingual embedding spaces to test whether affective dimensions are recoverable within each language. We then fit the same gradients in a shared multilingual embedding space, allowing the resulting Polish, English and French affective directions to be pairwise compared directly with regards to whether they differ in systematic ways. Our contribution is a method for statistically testing and interpreting cross-lingual differences in semantic dimensions. Rather than comparing individual translated words, we compare whole affective gradients in a shared embedding space. We use permutation tests to determine whether gradients differ across languages more than expected by chance, and we interpret the resulting difference gradients through clustering in semantic space. This provides an explainable framework for studying how psychological dimensions of meaning are preserved, shifted, or reorganized across languages. In doing so, the paper connects cross-cultural psychology, the semantic differential tradition, and modern multilingual representation learning, providing a computational method for cross-cultural concept analysis. 2 Methodology 2.1 Problem statement Supervised Semantic Differential allows for study of the relation of an external variable to language usage, but can’t be utilized by default for cross-cultural (cross-lingual) difference analysis, as the traditional word embedding models for different languages were not trained to be aligned and thus, are not – beyond standard chance. In order to compare psychological variables across texts in different languages and cultures, we propose using multilingual word embedding models, together with permutation tests to assess the significance of the gradient difference and