Explanations as Dialogues: Toward Human-Centered Conversational Explainable AI Conference: ACM Conversational User Interfaces 2026; July 21–24, 2026; Bremen, Germany ACM Conversational User Interfaces 2026 (CUI ’26), July 21–24, 2026, Bremen, Germany DOI: 10.1145/3816046.3816314 ISBN: 979-8-4007-2741-2/2026/07 CCS: Human-centered computing Interaction techniques

Niharika Mathur, Smit Desai · 2026

Read Explanations as Dialogues: Toward Human-Centered Conversational Explainable AI Conference: ACM Conversational User Interfaces 2026; July 21–24, 2026; Bremen, Germany ACM Conversational User Interfaces 2026 (CUI ’26), July 21–24, 2026, Bremen, Germany DOI: 10.1145/3816046.3816314 ISBN: 979-8-4007-2741-2/2026/07 CCS: Human-centered computing Interaction techniques by Niharika Mathur, Smit Desai (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2605-27666.txt.

Introduction

Niharika Mathur and Smit Desai argue that AI explanations should be studied as dialogues, not static artifacts. The conversational layer around an explanation, shaped by timing, tone, persona, and history, drives how well it works. Drawing on three cases, they invite research into interactive conversational exchanges and present a vision for human-centered conversational explainable AI.

Catalog record

CREATORNiharika Mathur, Smit Desai
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE27095
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2605.27666

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Explanations as Dialogues: Toward Human-Centered Conversational Explainable AI Conference: ACM Conversational User Interfaces 2026; July 21–24, 2026; Bremen, Germany ACM Conversational User Interfaces 2026 (CUI ’26), July 21–24, 2026, Bremen, Germany DOI: 10.1145/3816046.3816314 ISBN: 979-8-4007-2741-2/2026/07 CCS: Human-centered computing Interaction techniques Niharika Mathur, Smit Desai Abstract . As AI systems become increasingly conversational, a gap emerges wherein explanations are studied as static artifacts, yet in practice, are experienced as dialogue. In this provocation, we argue that the conversational layer around an explanation is not incidental to its effectiveness, but a critical constituent. Drawing on three illustrative scenarios, we invite the CUI community to study explanations as interactive, conversational exchanges shaped by timing, tone, persona and conversational history, and introduce our vision for Human-Centered Conversational XAI (HC2XAI). † † cc-license: by 1. Introduction Over the past decade, Explainable AI (XAI) has emerged as a significant area of research, driven by growing concerns around algorithmic accountability ( 6 ) , regulatory pressure ( 27 ) , and user trust ( 55 ; 50 ) . The field has developed a diverse toolkit, from saliency maps, counterfactual explanations, feature importance scores, attention visualizations, to natural language summaries. In theory, AI explanations are system outputs that reveal the inner mechanisms of AI systems in order to provide reasoning or justification for their responses. Significant technical algorithms such as LIME ( 33 ) and SHAP ( 31 ) have given AI practitioners accessible methods for opening the “black-box” of complex AI models. More recently, large language models (LLMs) have enabled generating fluent natural-language explanations of AI behavior. Today, an AI system can articulate the reasoning behind a decision in grammatically sound prose in various languages and conversational personalities ( 46 ; 23 ) . Despite these strides, the implicit assumption underlying much of explanatory progress, however, has remained stable: that a “good” explanation is an inherent property of content and faithfulness ( 43 ; 44 ) . As illustrated in Figure 1, a technically faithful explanation can be simultaneously conversationally inert and unable to adapt or invite follow-up from a user and their needs. The drill has been to obtain the correct information from the model, translate it into a legible modality and assume that user understanding will follow. Under this view, explanations act like artifacts that are produced, delivered and received. However, in recent years, something fundamental has shifted about the context in which that delivery happens. The AI systems that people interact with today are not dashboards or reports appended to a model output. They are conversational . People can (1) ask why a system recommended one option over another, (2) interrupt a response mid-stream to request clarification, and (3) return days later, expecting it to remember everything said before. In each of these cases, the explanation does not by itself exist in isolation. It exists in the interaction through a voice, a conversational tone or a turn in an ongoing dialogue. It lands differently depending on who is asking for it, how they asked, what was asked before, their emotional state at the time of interaction, and what is at stake for them in this moment ( 41 ; 19 ) . HCI has made important strides in reorienting XAI towards centering user needs through emergence of Human-Centered XAI (HCXAI) ( 18 ; 36 ) . HCXAI has provided a counterargument for the assumption that technical fidelity alone is sufficient for AI explanations, instead insisting that explanations must be grounded in user goals, mental models and real-world decision contexts ( 32 ) . While this disruption has been undeniably productive, even within HCXAI, the dominant mode of explanation under study remains largely visual and static: charts, highlight overlays, summary panels, structured templates, etc. ( 32 ; 21 ; 28 ) . Explanation is still an artifact that is shown to users rather than something that is said, and not something that is co-constructed in real time between a user and an AI system through conversational interaction. Recent work has begun to explore conversational approaches to XAI, including dialogue-based explanation systems and conversational interfaces for navigating AI outputs ( 62 ; 30 ; 53 ) . However, much of this work still treats conversation primarily as a delivery mechanism for explanations. In contrast, we argue that the conversational layer itself, including timing, tone, repair, persona, pacing and interactional history, fundamentally shapes how explanations are interpreted and negotiated in practice, and necessitates a human-centered inquiry ( 29 ) . Figure 1. A hospital readmission risk score rendered as a static SHAP-style feature importance chart (Fig. 1A) versus as a conversational exchange (Fig. 1B). This figure presents a case when a technically correct explanation may feel conversationally inert using the example of an AI-assisted hospital readmission risk score assessment. In Fig. 1A, the AI presents percent confidence scores for each feature that contributes to the final readmission risk assesment, while Fig. 1B shows the same information but in a conversational form with options for the user to ask follows up. In this provocation, here lies the gap that we want to highlight. As conversational AI becomes a primary interface through which many users encounter AI systems and, therefore, the primary medium through which these systems explain themselves, the field needs a framework or a starting point that takes the “conversational” seriously, not just a presentation layer but a site of conversational sensemaking. Addressing this gap will likely require closer alignment between communities that have largely progressed in parallel, particularly those working on conversational user interfaces (CUIs) and those advancing explainability, to collectively explore what explanation-as-dialog might entail in practice. We refer to this emerging space as Human-Centered Conversational XAI, or HC2XAI, and offer this provocation as an opening vision towards articulating what it might involve. Figure 2. Scenario A: An Older Adult Interacting with an AI-enabled Health Management App. A three-panel storyboard depicts an older woman named Margaret interacting with an AI-enabled health application. In the first panel, Margaret receives a notification asking her to discuss a health concern with her physician. In the second panel, the application presents technical data such as fatigue frequency, blood pressure readings, and medication adherence scores, leaving her visibly confused and uncertain. In the final panel, Margaret attends a medical appointment but remains silent, illustrating how clinically framed explanations may fail to encourage understanding or action despite being technically accurate. 2. Background: Where HCXAI Has Brought Us Before laying out the vision for HC2XAI, it is important to examine what HCXAI has accomplished. The shift from technical XAI to human-centered XAI marked a significant disciplinary move, reframing the central question from “is this explanation faithful to the model?” to “is this explanation useful to a person?” Research has shown that explanations performing well on fidelity benchmarks often fail to support effective human decision-making ( 34 ; 22 ) , giving rise to questions of “explainability for whom” ( 24 ) . In parallel, attention to lay users, non-expert populations, and marginalized communities has foregrounded concerns around accessibility and equity ( 42 ) , including how explanations designed for expert audiences may exclude users with lower AI literacy ( 37 ) , and how dominant formats assume familiarity with computational systems

Read the complete text