Agreement and Compatibility in Wigner’s Friend Paradox
Julio C. F. Silva, B. F. Rizzuti, Cristhiano Duarte · 2026
Read Agreement and Compatibility in Wigner’s Friend Paradox by Julio C. F. Silva, B. F. Rizzuti, Cristhiano Duarte (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2605-27424.txt.
Introduction
Julio C. F. Silva, B. F. Rizzuti, and Cristhiano Duarte revisit the Wigner's Friend paradox as an inference problem. Their radically Bayesian reading finds no contradiction between Wigner and his Friend, classically or quantumly, with compatibility and agreement at the core. Extending the setup with the benefit of the doubt lets either description be driven to match the other.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Julio C. F. Silva, B. F. Rizzuti, Cristhiano Duarte |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 130385 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2605.27424
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Agreement and Compatibility in Wigner’s Friend Paradox Julio C. F. Silva, B. F. Rizzuti, Cristhiano Duarte Abstract There has been an upsurge of interest in the consequences for quantum physics of the so-called Wigner’s Friend Paradox. In its original formulation, the paradox has been turned inside out, and virtually every aspect of it has been looked into. Consequently, it is becoming widely accepted that we can find the potentially puzzling consequences of Wigner’s thought experiment only in light of its many-parties extensions. Nonetheless, this contribution returns to the source. Reframing the question as an inference problem, we advance a radically Bayesian interpretation that shows no contradiction between Wigner’s and Wigner’s Friend’s descriptions—neither classically nor quantumly. Therefore, with no paradoxical conclusion. In doing so, we flesh out and expose previously untouched aspects of Winger’s thought experiment, in particular, the fact that compatibility and agreement are fundamental to our understanding of it. Also, by conservatively extending Wigner’s original setup and incorporating what we call the ’benefit of the doubt’, we see how either Wigner’s or his Friend’s description can be driven to match one another’s—an impossibility if either agent does not keep an open mind. I Introduction Quantum theory comprises a set of rules intended to deal with actual experiments whose alternative classical descriptions fail to work as expected Jennings and Leifer 2016 . On a more practical dimension, quantum physics has several unique features that can be exploited in the run to new and disruptive technologies Preskill 2018 : no-go theorems like the no-cloning and no-broadcasting theorems have been translated into essential ingredients for the security of quantum cryptographic protocols Heinosaari et al. 2023 ; puzzling aspects of the mathematics of quantum theory, like entanglement and superposition, are now part of the canon of standard quantum information and quantum computation tasks Nielsen and Chuang 2010 ; Horodecki et al. 2009 ; and, more recently, we have also seen subtler aspects derived from the machinery of quantum theory as resources to fuel tasks with either no classical counterpart or with substantial gains in efficiency Chitambar and Gour 2019 ; Berk et al. 2023 ; Motta et al. 2020 ; Arute et al. 2019 . What is, in general, less advertised is that, notwithstanding these real-world implications, there remain open questions deeply seated in its foundations. Consider, for example, the thought experiment designed by Eugene Wigner in 1961 Wigner 1995 ; Freire Junior 2015 . According to him, there is an apparent paradoxical incompatibility in the descriptions of either agent present in the scenario Cavalcanti 2021 —we will address the Gedankenexperiment and its apparent contradiction in more detail in a minute. What is important is that even though Wigner’s original thought experiment was conceived within the debate around the mind-and-body problem, the question it advances is closely connected to the measurement problem Schlosshauer 2005 and exemplifies some fault lines still open in the foundations of quantum mechanics. Other foundational problems include the status of the wave function Leifer 2014 ; whether it is possible to give an unproblematic treatment to time as a quantum object Aharonov and Vaidman 2008 ; a rigorous definition for quantum reference frames Gour and Spekkens 2008 ; whether it makes sense to define a quantum version of classical heat Goold et al. 2016 ; the possibility of deriving quantum mechanics from informationally motivated laws Masanes and Müller 2011 ; quantum causal structures Chaves et al. 2018 and the issue of quantum-to-classical transition Duarte et al. 2017 to mention but a few. Like all the foundational questions mentioned above, it is true that Wigner’s original paradox (if any) has been turned inside out over and over again Bong et al. 2020 . It is also true that a common sense is emerging in the field: only its many-party extensions deserve attention, as only they would add genuine quantum features to the analysis Leifer and Spekkens 2014 . Nonetheless, we will use Wigner’s original formulation to naturally reframe the incompatibility of agents’ descriptions as an inference problem. This ‘inferential turn’ aligns with the research agenda advanced by refs. Leifer and Spekkens 2014 ; Leifer 2014 ; Duarte 2020 . There, the authors see quantum theory as a noncommutative generalisation of Bayesian probability theory—one in which probability measures are replaced by density operators. In (standard) Bayesian probability theory, probabilities represent an agent’s information, knowledge, or beliefs. This means that two different agents can naturally assign different probability distributions to the same random variable. Similarly, in approaches to quantum theory that view the quantum state as a representation of knowledge or belief, two agents can assign different states to the same quantum system—much like in Wigner’s Thought Experiment. This raises the question: when are such different views compatible? In this sense, compatibility among distinct state assignments might help resolve the apparent paradox in Wigner’s friend’s thought experiment. A well-defined notion of compatibility within a Bayesian approach to probability theory, one that can help understand the apparent contradiction in Wigner’s original formulation, is exactly what we will explore in this contribution. We have divided this contribution into two main parts. The first half addresses the original ‘paradox’. For completeness, we start by discussing Wigner’s formulation in Sec. II , based on more modern references, namely Cavalcanti 2021 and Lostaglio and Bowles 2021 . This Section aims to clarify that the ‘paradox’ arises only from misconceptions about what (in)compatibility and agreement truly mean. By adopting a Bayesian perspective, we propose a sound definition of compatibility in Sec. III . In that Section, we also discuss the concept of agreement, an overlooked cornerstone of the thought experiment. Sec. IV is where we elaborate on Wigner’s original formulation and apply our concept of compatibility to conclude that there is nothing paradoxical in his Gedankenexperiment . In the second half of the work, Sec. V and Appendices B , C and D , we turn to the means to achieve reconciliation between the agents’ perspectives, that is, agreement. We present different reconciliation methods to accommodate subjective and objective interpretations of probability. We also draw attention to a derived case of interest by sprinkling a bit of benefit of the doubt into the studied paradox and by including the concept of quantum-state improvement Leifer and Spekkens 2014 ; Herbut 2004 . In the aforementioned Appendices we briefly nod to two other solutions, which, in turn, are grounded in objectivist inference and the statistical pooling of quantum states Leifer and Spekkens 2014 ; Jacobs 2002 ; Brun et al. 2015 ; Jacobs 2005 . We conclude the paper by exploring further works, comparing our contribution with other approaches, and presenting a critical analysis of our own take on the subject. II Wigner’s Friend Paradox In this Section, we briefly review the original formulation of Wigner’s Friend scenario and its pretence paradox. II.1 Wigner’s Original Formulation It revolves around two agents, namely Wigner (W) and his Friend (F) 1 1 1 It may be the case that contemporary quantum information theorists may prefer the term ‘observers’ to ‘agents’. We defend that the term ‘agent’ is more appropriate because, whatever happens when one measures a quantum system, it cannot be regarded as a mere passive ‘observation’—in line with Eugene Wigner’s original