Can Quantum Federated Learning Withstand Circuit-Level Backdoors?
Aakar Mathur, Mohammed Ruknuddin, Ashish Gupta · 2026
Read Can Quantum Federated Learning Withstand Circuit-Level Backdoors? by Aakar Mathur, Mohammed Ruknuddin, Ashish Gupta (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2605-27416.txt.
Introduction
Aakar Mathur, Mohammed Ruknuddin, and Ashish Gupta test whether quantum federated learning survives circuit-level backdoors. Their CULT model formalizes four stealthy attacks using Grover, Pauli, bit-flip, and sign-flip tricks. Even one malicious client badly degrades accuracy under FedAvg, and standard defenses fail to remove worst-case failures where accuracy falls by half.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Aakar Mathur, Mohammed Ruknuddin, Ashish Gupta |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 34610 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2605.27416
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Can Quantum Federated Learning Withstand Circuit-Level Backdoors? Aakar Mathur, Mohammed Ruknuddin, Ashish Gupta Abstract Quantum Federated Learning (QFL) inherits the core vulnerability of federated optimization to malicious clients, while also introducing an attack surface from variational circuit training and measurement-driven gradients. This work proposes a novel CircUit-Level backdoor Threat (CULT) model that formalizes four stealthy attacks by exploiting quantum-aware mechanisms, including Grover, Pauli, Bit-flip, and Sign-flip. By enabling malicious clients on both in-training and post-training surfaces, these attacks can critically undermine the learning process. We establish a rigorous theoretical foundation to demonstrate attack stealthiness under standard smoothness assumptions. Experiments on the MNIST and CIFAR-10 datasets with non-IID splits and varying fractions of malicious clients show that even a single malicious client can induce severe accuracy degradation under FedAvg aggregation. While popular defenses, including Krum, Multi-Krum, FoolsGold, FLGuardian, and Mud-HoG, reduce degradation in many regimes, they fail to eliminate worst-case failure cases, where accuracy drops up to 50%. The experimental analysis further reveals that under the CULT model, malicious updates effectively mask their presence by staying close to benign norms, thereby helping attackers evade detection. 1 Introduction † † footnotetext: Appendix: https://github.com/AakarM1/CULT-CircUit-Level-backdoor-Threat Federated learning (FL) enables a set of clients to jointly train a shared model while keeping raw data local 16 ; 10 . This decentralization preserves privacy but also exposes the training process to malicious participants who can inject carefully crafted triggers, resulting in targeted misclassification, commonly referred to as a backdoor attack 2 . Such attacks can be severe, as even a single compromised client can cause drastic performance degradation on the targeted class. Quantum Computing (QC) is another rapidly growing field that leverages the unique principles of quantum physics, such as superposition and entanglement, to process information in novel ways, thereby solving certain tasks more efficiently than classical methods 15 ; 20 . Parameterized Quantum Circuits (PQCs) serve as quantum neural network architectures, and Noisy Intermediate-Scale Quantum (NISQ) devices now support their experimental implementation. Recent advances demonstrate the potential of PQCs in classification and optimization, even under realistic hardware constraints 13 . Quantum federated learning (QFL) combines these paradigms by distributing hybrid quantum models training across multiple clients, each operating on their local data 22 ; 9 . Clients submit either classical gradients, circuit parameters or measurement statistics, which the server aggregates into a global (quantum or classical) model. A recent study 15 presented a novel taxonomy of the QFL literature, highlighting gains in expressivity, error mitigation, challenges, and opportunities for future research. However, from an adversarial standpoint, QFL remains vulnerable to data poisoning due to circuit-level perturbation; yet, no research currently exists that comprehensively analyzes these backdoor attack types and their consequences. This omission raises a critical question: Can QFL withstand circuit-level backdoor attack posed by a malicious client? Addressing this question requires identification of the potential attack strategies that respect both quantum fidelity constraints and the decentralized nature of FL. \bullet Contributions. The key contributions of this paper are: • We propose a novel C ir C uit- L evel backdoor T hreat (CULT) model for QFL, where a fraction of clients inject a quantum-layer attack on local optimization steps. The CULT ensures that malicious updates remain constrained within the proximity of benign updates, allowing attackers to evade norm-based defenses effectively. • Under the CULT model, this work introduces four stealthy attacks that target the internal circuitry of the PQC , namely: (i) Grover phase-oracle attack, (ii) Pauli-rotation attack, (iii) Bit-flip attack, and (iv) Phase-kickback sign-flip attack. By exploiting both in-training and post-training surfaces, these attacks are sufficiently potent to severely degrade the global model accuracy. • We provide a rigorous theoretical analysis and comprehensive empirical evaluations using the MNIST and CIFAR-10 datasets to validate the efficacy of the CULT model in both no-defense and with-defense scenarios. The paper is organized as follows. The next section discusses related work, and Section 3 provides preliminaries and the QFL setup. Section 4 proposes the threat model, CULT, along with four backdoor attacks, and Section 5 gives its theoretical analysis. Experimental results are reported in Section 6 and finally, Section 7 concludes the paper. 2 Related Work FL’s decentralized nature invites subtle poisoning attacks. Research shows that a single malicious client can scale its gradient to implant a backdoor while preserving global accuracy 2 ; 5 ; 23 . Subsequent defenses, such as norm clipping and median aggregation, mitigate basic attacks but fail when adversaries split their poison across many rounds or use sybil clients 25 ; 4 . FoolsGold 7 adapted reputation scoring to detect sybils; however, it assumes real-valued updates and does not address quantum-specific constraints. FLAME (Federated Learning Adaptive Model Limitation) 19 is another robust aggregation method that mitigates backdoor attacks while preserving model utility. Recently, FedDLAD 5 investigated two-phase backdoor detection to improve robustness. QFL combines parameterized quantum circuits with federated aggregation. The research by 22 introduced distributing variational circuits across clients to exploit entanglement for classification tasks. Highlighting practical challenges on NISQ hardware, the work in 9 analyzed QFL’s error mitigation and communication overhead. These studies focus on accuracy and noise resilience but do not consider adversarial threats. Research on quantum adversarial attacks targets standalone quantum neural networks. Analogous to classical adversarial examples, the authors 14 introduced minimal-fidelity perturbations that cause specific misclassifications in quantum circuits. An optimized QFL architecture introduced by 24 to mitigate the impact of adversarial interference for intelligent transportation systems. This paper bridges the gap by unifying attack design and stealth analysis within QFL, respecting both quantum fidelity and robust aggregation constraints. 3 Preliminaries and QFL Setup This section introduces notations required to understand the proposed attacks and the QFL setup with the quantum model. Quantum states and measurements. Let \mathcal{H} denote a 2^{n} -dimensional Hilbert space for an n -qubit register. A pure state \ket{\psi}\in\mathcal{H} induces a density matrix \varrho=\ket{\psi}\!\bra{\psi} , while mixed states use a positive semidefinite \varrho with \mathrm{Tr}(\varrho)=1 . For an observable M , the measurement expectation equals \langle M\rangle=\mathrm{Tr}(M\varrho) . Parameterized quantum circuits. A PQC applies a unitary U(x;\theta) composed of data-dependent encoders and trainable blocks. The model extracts measurement features z(x;\theta) by repeating circuit executions and estimating \langle M_{j}\rangle for a set of observables \{M_{j}\} . A classical head h_{\phi}(\cdot) then produces logits and class predictions. FL setting. Client k holds a dataset D_{k} and minimizes \ell_{k}(\theta) . The server optimizes the population objective F(\theta):=\sum_{k=1}^{K}w_{k}\ell_{k}(\theta) , with \sum_{k=1}^{K}w_{k}=1 . Let K clients participate in synchronous rounds t\in\{0,\dots,T-1\} . Client k receives the global parameters \theta^{t} . Each client performs E local epochs with step size \eta , producing \theta_{k}^{t+1} and an update \Delta\theta_{k}^{t}:=\theta_{k}^{t+1}-\theta^{t} . The server aggregates updates using an aggregation rule ( AR ) and applies a server learning rate \beta as \theta^{t+1}\;=\;\theta^{t}+\beta\,AR\bigl(\{\Delta\theta_{k}^{t}\}_{k=1}^{K}\bigr) . In the experiments, AR includes FedAvg 17 , MUD-HoG 8 , Krum 4 , MKrum 4 , FLGuardian 26 , and FoolsGold 6 . Quantum model. Each client uses a PQC U(x;\theta) to encode an input x and produce an output via measurements of an observable M . The expectation follows the standard rule \langle M\rangle_{x,\theta}=\mathrm{Tr}\!\left(M\,\varrho(x;\theta)\right),\;\text{where}\;\varrho(x;\theta)=U(x;\theta)\,\varrho_{0}\,U(x;\theta)^{\dagger}, with an initial state \rho_{0} . A classical head maps measurement features to logits, and the local objective minimizes empirical loss \ell_{k}(\theta)