Mathematical Modelling of Ethical AI Use in Higher Education: A Coordination Game Framework for Future-Facing Learning

Ndidi Bianca Ogbo, Zhao Song, Shatha Ghareeb, The Anh Han · 2026

Read Mathematical Modelling of Ethical AI Use in Higher Education: A Coordination Game Framework for Future-Facing Learning by Ndidi Bianca Ogbo, Zhao Song, Shatha Ghareeb, The Anh Han (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2605-27400.txt.

Introduction

Ndidi Bianca Ogbo, Zhao Song, Shatha Ghareeb, and The Anh Han model student AI use as a coordination game. Small, well-tuned shifts in reflective assessment rewards can flip a cohort toward responsible, learning-focused norms, while weak rewards let opportunistic habits persist. Modest assessment redesigns thus beat policy words alone, without surveillance or punishment.

Catalog record

CREATORNdidi Bianca Ogbo, Zhao Song, Shatha Ghareeb, The Anh Han
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE32400
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2605.27400

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Mathematical Modelling of Ethical AI Use in Higher Education: A Coordination Game Framework for Future-Facing Learning Ndidi Bianca Ogbo, Zhao Song, Shatha Ghareeb, The Anh Han Abstract The rapid uptake of generative artificial intelligence (AI) in higher education is reshaping assessment practices and intensifying concerns around academic integrity, fairness, and learning quality. While institutional responses increasingly emphasise policy guidance and ethical principles, there remains limited formal understanding of how collective norms of responsible or opportunistic AI use emerge and stabilise within student cohorts. This paper reframes student AI use in assessment as a coordination problem shaped by peer expectations and assessment design rather than individual compliance alone. We develop a coordination-based evolutionary game-theoretic framework that captures learning value, effort, perceived fairness, and transparency, with institutional AI governance modelled implicitly through reflective assessment incentives. We use analytical results and finite-population simulations to reveal threshold-driven behavioural transitions in student AI use: small, well-calibrated changes in reflective assessment incentives can trigger rapid shifts towards responsible, learning-oriented AI-use norms, whereas weak or misaligned incentives allow opportunistic practices to persist. These non-linear dynamics explain why policy statements alone often fail to change behaviour, while modest assessment redesigns can have disproportionate effects. By providing a mechanism-level account of how assessment structures shape collective AI-use practices, this work offers higher education institutions an analytically grounded tool for Future Facing Learning, supporting proportionate, pedagogy-led AI governance without reliance on surveillance or punitive enforcement. Keywords: Generative AI, Higher Education, Assessment, Academic Integrity, Ethical AI Use, Evolutionary Game Theory 1 Introduction Artificial intelligence (AI) has become an increasingly influential component of higher education, shaping teaching, learning, assessment, and institutional decision-making. Over the past decade, AI-driven systems have supported personalised learning, automated feedback, learning analytics, and administrative processes 14 ; 33 . More recently, advances in generative AI have accelerated this transformation by enabling students to produce text, code, and other artefacts with unprecedented ease 36 ; 24 . While these developments create significant pedagogical opportunities, they also raise pressing concerns regarding academic integrity, fairness, and the credibility of assessment 15 ; 2 ; 35 ; 11 . In assessment contexts, generative AI tools can support exploration, drafting, and problem solving, yet they can also be used opportunistically to minimise effort or optimise short-term performance. Institutions therefore face a central challenge: how to design assessment environments that encourage responsible, learning-oriented AI use without undermining learning quality or perceived fairness 6 ; 7 . To date, institutional responses have focused largely on policy guidance, disclosure requirements, and detection-oriented approaches 12 ; 24 . However, growing empirical evidence suggests that formal rules and enforcement mechanisms alone are insufficient to shape student behaviour in practice 34 ; 45 . A key reason for this limitation is that student decisions about AI use are socially interdependent. Choices are shaped not only by institutional guidance, but also by peer behaviour, shared expectations, and perceptions of legitimacy within a cohort 42 ; 23 . In such environments, the costs and benefits of responsible or opportunistic AI use depend critically on what others are perceived to be doing. This interdependence gives rise to a coordination problem: once a particular pattern of AI use becomes widespread, it may be individually rational for students to conform, even when alternative behaviours are pedagogically preferable. Similar dynamics have been widely documented in studies of social norms and collective behaviour 25 ; 37 . Recent scholarship highlights the role of assessment design in shaping AI-use practices, particularly through reflective and pedagogically aligned approaches that require students to articulate and critically evaluate how AI tools contributed to their work, and through task designs that emphasise higher-order thinking over surface-level outputs 21 ; 20 ; 41 . Such approaches are increasingly advocated in policy and practice, yet there remains limited formal understanding of how reflective assessment mechanisms interact with peer dynamics to shape collective AI-use norms over time. In particular, it remains unclear under what conditions responsible AI-use norms stabilise, and when opportunistic or superficially compliant behaviours persist. To address this gap, we introduce a coordination-based modelling framework for analysing how patterns of AI use emerge within higher education assessment environments. Building on evolutionary game theory 27 ; 39 , we model student–student interactions to capture norm formation driven by peer comparison, an approach widely used to study coordination and technology-adoption dynamics 46 ; 31 ; 8 . Institutional influence enters implicitly through assessment design, which shapes the payoff structure by determining which forms of AI use are rewarded or discouraged. Our analysis proceeds in two stages. First, we introduce a baseline coordination model capturing the tension between responsible, learning-oriented AI use and opportunistic, performance-driven use. We then extend this model by incorporating a reflective assessment mechanism that differentiates between meaningful and superficial engagement with AI. Using evolutionary dynamics in finite populations, we examine how these design choices influence the emergence, stability, and transition between collective AI-use norms within a student cohort. By treating assessment design as a coordination mechanism rather than a compliance tool, this work contributes to Future Facing Learning by offering scalable, pedagogy-led approaches to AI governance in higher education. More broadly, it provides an analytically grounded perspective on how modest changes in assessment design can generate non-linear shifts in collective behaviour, offering practical insights for institutions seeking to support responsible, trustworthy, and pedagogically coherent uses of generative AI. This paper makes three contributions. First, it introduces a coordination-based evolutionary game-theoretic framework for understanding how student AI-use practices are shaped by peer expectations. Second, it formalises reflective assessment design as an institutional mechanism that reshapes assessment-related incentives. Third, it provides analytical and computational insights into how responsible, superficially compliant, and opportunistic AI-use norms emerge and stabilise under different assessment designs, with implications for institutional AI governance and future-facing assessment practice. 2 Background and Related Work The rapid diffusion of artificial intelligence, and particularly generative AI tools, has intensified debate within higher education around pedagogy, assessment, and academic integrity. Recent research spans empirical studies of student and staff perceptions, institutional policy analyses, and conceptual frameworks for responsible AI use. While this literature provides important descriptive and normative insights, it offers limited analytical understanding of how collective norms of AI use emerge, stabilise, or shift within student cohorts, particularly in response to assessment design. Early work on artificial intelligence in education focused on intelligent tutoring systems, adaptive learning, and learning analytics 14 . More recent studies document the widespread uptake of generative AI tools in higher education and highlight both pedagogical opportunities and integrity-related concerns 36 ; 24 . Systematic reviews consistently emphasise that educational outcomes depend less on the technical capabilities of AI systems than on how they are embedded within teaching and assessment practices 33 . This shift has redirected attention away from technology itself toward institutional design choices that shape how AI is used in practice. At the institutional level, analyses of policy documents and guidelines reveal a move away from prohibition toward principles of responsible use, transparency, and AI literacy 12 ; 24 . However, these responses remain largely normative and aspirational, offering limited insight into how students respond strategically to assessment incentives or how shared expectations around acceptable AI use form and persist within cohorts. A growing body of

Read the complete text