Hot Jupiters’ Isolation Is Not Unique to High-Eccentricity Tidal Migration astropy ( 5 ; 3 ; 4 ) , matplotlib ( 54 ) , numpy ( 44 ) , pandas ( 101 ; 117 ) , rebound ( 131 ) , reboundx ( 7 ) , SPOCK ( 146 )
Brandon T. Radzom, Songhu Wang, Bonan Pu, Hareesh Gautham Bhaskar, Malena Rice · 2026
Read Hot Jupiters’ Isolation Is Not Unique to High-Eccentricity Tidal Migration astropy ( 5 ; 3 ; 4 ) , matplotlib ( 54 ) , numpy ( 44 ) , pandas ( 101 ; 117 ) , rebound ( 131 ) , reboundx ( 7 ) , SPOCK ( 146 ) by Brandon T. Radzom, Songhu Wang, Bonan Pu, Hareesh Gautham Bhaskar, Malena Rice (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2605-27362.txt.
Introduction
Brandon Radzom and colleagues offer a unified quiescent account of hot and warm Jupiter isolation. In their model both giants start as the lone Jovian planet in a compact multi-super-Earth system. Later dynamics leave hot Jupiter companions wider and more tilted, hence harder to spot. The model, published in 2026, also predicts close-in, mutually inclined outer companions best found by Doppler surveys.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Brandon T. Radzom, Songhu Wang, Bonan Pu, Hareesh Gautham Bhaskar, Malena Rice |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 81111 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2605.27362
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Hot Jupiters’ Isolation Is Not Unique to High-Eccentricity Tidal Migration astropy ( 5 ; 3 ; 4 ) , matplotlib ( 54 ) , numpy ( 44 ) , pandas ( 101 ; 117 ) , rebound ( 131 ) , reboundx ( 7 ) , SPOCK ( 146 ) Brandon T. Radzom, Songhu Wang, Bonan Pu, Hareesh Gautham Bhaskar, Malena Rice Abstract Conventionally, the observed isolation of hot Jupiters, marked by a paucity of nearby low-mass planetary companions, has been interpreted as evidence of high-eccentricity tidal migration for these close-in gas giants. This loneliness is in stark contrast with the compact configurations commonly observed for warm Jupiters, indicating a curious dichotomy in dynamical origins between these two classes of short-period giants. In this study, however, we adopt a unified quiescent framework for both giant populations wherein they emerge from the protoplanetary disk as the sole Jovian planet within a compact multi-super-Earth system. We use long-term numerical simulations to show that post-disk dynamical evolution will naturally result in an observed preferential isolation for hot Jupiters relative to warm Jupiters. Specifically, their companions achieve significantly larger period ratios and mutual inclinations, rendering them more difficult to detect — especially via the transit method. Additionally, we find that this paradigm is consistent with the enigmatic population of longer-period hot Jupiters hosting interior companions on coplanar orbits. Another prediction of this model, best tested through high-precision Doppler campaigns, is the existence of a population of close-in ( P ≲ 50 days P\lesssim 50\,\mathrm{days} ) but mutually inclined outer companions to hot Jupiters. I Introduction The longest-standing mystery in exoplanet astronomy pertains to the origins of short-period Jovian-class planets such as hot Jupiters (as comprehensively reviewed by 26 ). Proposed theories to explain the existence of these gas giants can be categorized as either dynamically quiescent or violent. Mechanisms labeled as “dynamically quiescent” include disk-driven migration, wherein the giant forms in the outer regions before moving inward through interactions with their disk ( 37 ; 89 ; 87 ) , and in situ formation, wherein the giant forms at or proximate to its current orbit ( 78 ; 16 ; 8 ; 6 ) . The “dynamically violent” mechanisms encompass a variety of high-eccentricity tidal migration pathways which can be triggered by planet-planet scattering ( 128 ; 153 ; 21 ) , von Zeipel-Lidov-Kozai cycling ( 86 ; 75 ; 158 ; 30 ; 110 ; 58 ) , or other secular interactions ( 159 ; 90 ; 118 ; 43 ) . Independently, these formation and evolution channels can each explain only a subset of the known observational characteristics of short-period gas giants ( 26 ) . One such property, currently challenging each origin model individually, is the observed preferential isolation of hot Jupiters ( P<10\,\mathrm{days} ) relative to their wider-orbiting ( 10\,\mathrm{days}\leq P\lesssim 300\,\mathrm{days} ) giant counterparts, known as warm Jupiters (see 143 for an exception). Specifically, the earliest population studies with the Kepler transit survey demonstrated that hot Jupiters were effectively devoid of any nearby low-mass planetary companions, with less than 1% hosting a nearby co-transiting neighbor, while more than half of warm Jupiters had such companions (e.g., 144 ; 52 ). This stark companionship dichotomy served as strong evidence of dichotomous histories for these two populations of short-period giants, with quiescent mechanisms being dominant for warm Jupiters, and violent high-eccentricity migration, which is capable of largely clearing out any close-in companions ( 109 ; 12 ) , producing most hot Jupiters. However, the latest results from the Transiting Exoplanet Survey Satellite (TESS) mission and transit timing variation (TTV) searches for nearby companions over the complete Kepler dataset firmly establish that a non-negligible fraction ( \gtrsim 7 – 12\% ) of hot Jupiters are not lonely ( 49 ; 141 ; 156 ) , and hence may have shared origins with warm Jupiters. In this work, we investigate whether a unified, dynamically quiescent framework for both hot Jupiters and warm Jupiters can explain their observed companionship dichotomy. Specifically, we use long-term N -body simulations of short-period giants in compact multi-planet systems to demonstrate that, through gravitational interactions alone, hot Jupiters naturally self-isolate relative to warm Jupiters. We detail the setup of our fiducial simulations in Section II . In Section III , we present the results of these simulations, characterizing the dichotomy that forms for the orbital spacings and mutual inclinations (Section III.1 ) as well as the observational detection efficiencies (Section III.3 ) of our companion planets, and also highlighting the key properties of our final system architectures (Section III.2 ). We then describe the dynamical evolution that drives these companionship outcomes in Section IV , and present results from simulation suites with modified properties in Section V . We discuss our adopted quiescent model in the context of in situ formation and disk migration in Section VI , and summarize our main findings and their potential implications in Section VII . II Simulation Set-up Overview. We generate 360 primordial “peas-in-a-pod” ( 154 ; 106 ; 40 ) planetary systems that resemble more compact, higher-multiplicity versions of Kepler multiple-planet systems, which are packed just wide of the boundary of Hill stability ( 123 ; 150 ) . Such a set-up is well-motivated by evidence showing that current-day Kepler multi-planet systems may have undergone significant dynamical sculpting in the past, originating from pristine systems with more planets in initially tighter configurations (e.g., 61 ; 166 ; 60 ). Each of our systems begins with twelve nearly uniformly and closely spaced super-Earths with similar masses orbiting a solar-mass star (analogous to the set-up used in 36 ). Before integration, we select one super-Earth in each system to have a wider spacing relative to its nearest neighbors and grow to become a Jupiter-mass ( 1\,\text{M}_{\mathrm{J}} ) giant, which will trigger dynamical instability in the absence of eccentricity damping from the disk ( 151 ; 21 ) . This numerical experiment is designed primarily to explore long-term dynamical evolution as a mechanism to produce a companionship dichotomy between hot and warm Jupiters under unified formation conditions. More realistic initial conditions for short-period giants in such compact, high-multiplicity systems are likely more complex (e.g., see 112 ; 113 ). Planetary Mass & Radius. We assign planetary masses according to a Gaussian distribution centered on 6\,\text{M}_{\oplus} ( 157 ; consistent with typical masses in Kepler multi-planet systems) with \sigma_{m}=20\%\times 6\,\text{M}_{\oplus}=1.2\,\text{M}_{\oplus} and within the range 1\,\text{M}_{\oplus}-10\,\text{M}_{\oplus} . We determine planetary radii from their masses using the mass-radius relation for rocky, volatile-poor bodies described in Equation 1 of 114 . We note that our results do not sensitively depend on the exact masses (nor radii) of our small planets, as they are much less massive than our giants. Spacing. To generate probable progenitors to Kepler -like peas-in-a-pod systems, we employ a prescription similar to the Equal Mutual Separation (EMS) scheme (e.g., 20 ; 164 ). We set the planet-planet spacing parameter to K=10 , which corresponds to the critical boundary for instability defined by 34 for N\geq 8 systems as well as the compact edge of the expected distribution for observed Kepler multi-planet systems ( 123 ) , and is broadly consistent with expectations from planet formation