Absence of a Superradiant Phase Transition in Dirac Landau Polaritons

Elsa Jöchl, Felix Helmrich, Frieder Lindel, Lucy Hale, Lorenzo Graziotto, Mona Jarrahi, Tobia F. Nova, Jérôme Faist, Giacomo Scalari · 2026

Read Absence of a Superradiant Phase Transition in Dirac Landau Polaritons by Elsa Jöchl, Felix Helmrich, Frieder Lindel, Lucy Hale, Lorenzo Graziotto, Mona Jarrahi, Tobia F. Nova, Jérôme Faist, Giacomo Scalari (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2605-27319.txt.

Introduction

Elsa Jochl and colleagues test whether graphene Landau polaritons in a terahertz cavity undergo a superradiant phase transition. Tuning carrier density drives coupling to about 40 percent, near the critical point, yet the expected polariton softening never appears. A Hopfield model with a near-field cavity account reproduces the full dispersion instead.

Catalog record

CREATORElsa Jöchl, Felix Helmrich, Frieder Lindel, Lucy Hale, Lorenzo Graziotto, Mona Jarrahi, Tobia F. Nova, Jérôme Faist, Giacomo Scalari
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE30476
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2605.27319

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Absence of a Superradiant Phase Transition in Dirac Landau Polaritons Elsa Jöchl, Felix Helmrich, Frieder Lindel, Lucy Hale, Lorenzo Graziotto, Mona Jarrahi, Tobia F. Nova, Jérôme Faist, Giacomo Scalari Abstract The condensation of photons into a macroscopically populated ground state, a superradiant phase transition (SRPT), is one of the most striking predictions of cavity quantum electrodynamics (cQED) 16 ; 39 , yet has resisted experimental realization in equilibrium for over fifty years. Whether such a transition can survive at all in light-matter coupled systems is still debated, with a widely established No-Go theorem ruling it out across several models 32 ; 24 ; 10 . Graphene cyclotron transitions ultrastrongly coupled to terahertz (THz) cavities have been at the heart of this debate 13 ; 5 . At leading order, the linear Dirac dispersion of electrons does not generate the diamagnetic A → 2 \vec{A}^{2} term that enforces the theorem, making graphene the cleanest candidate for a No-Go-evading phase transition. Here, we present the first THz spectroscopic measurements of an encapsulated monolayer graphene flake ultrastrongly coupled to a single complementary split-ring resonator. By tuning the carrier density we sweep the system from weak coupling into the ultrastrong regime, reaching a normalized coupling Ω R / ω cav ≈ 0.4 \Omega_{\text{R}}/\omega_{\text{cav}}\approx 0.4 . This is well into the range where a second order SRPT would manifest by a softening of the lower polariton branch, which we do not observe. The full polariton dispersion is instead quantitatively reproduced by a Hopfield Hamiltonian derived from first principles using a near-field model that accounts for the sub-wavelength character of the cavity. Our results establish an experimental baseline for predictions of cavity-driven phase transitions in two-dimensional Dirac systems, and rule out a No-Go-evading SRPT in graphene Landau polaritons up to the strongest couplings accessible today, with direct implications for proposals invoking vacuum-induced order in solid-state cQED. Figure 1: Probing SRPTs in monolayer graphene. a) Dispersion of the lower and upper polariton branches as a function of density n (coupling \eta ) at resonance in the Dicke (grey dashed lines) and Hopfield models (purple lines). While the Dicke prediction exhibits criticality with softening to zero frequency of the lower branch, the Hopfield model does not. The density range where a superradiant phase (SRP) is predicted in the Dicke model is indicated by the grey background. b) Top view of the sample before (left) and after (right) the deposition of the cSRR. c) Schematic view of the experimental setup. The sample consisting of the graphene flake and the cSRR is mounted between silicon immersion lenses. A linearly polarized THz pulse E_{\text{THz}} (orange) is incident on the sample. A static magnetic field (purple) orthogonal to the graphene plane quantizes the electron motion in graphene to Landau levels. d) Precise stack-up of the sample. The graphene flake is encapsulated by hBN flakes and connected electrically using etch contacts. A thin metallic Cr/Pt layer acts as an electrostatic gate by applying a static voltage V_{\text{BG}} with respect to graphene. The cSRR is fabricated from Au on top of the graphene heterostructure and is electrically insulated from the latter using alumina (Al 2 O 3 ) dielectric. The distribution of the in-plane electric field obtained by finite-element simulations. The substrate consists of Si with a 285 nm oxide layer. I Introduction The term superradiance was first introduced by R.H. Dicke to explain the coherent emission of light by N two-level atoms placed in the same electromagnetic environment 8 . If the two-level systems are placed at distances a fraction of the electromagnetic wavelength and display identical coupling to the photon field 11 , both the emission amplitude and decay rate will scale with N , giving rise to a superradiant intensity burst proportional to N^{2} . This finding, based on the Dicke Hamiltonian, made way for Hepp and Lieb to propose criticality in the ground-state of a cavity mode interacting with an ensemble of atoms in the thermodynamic limit 16 . Shortly thereafter also studied in a paper by Hioe and Wang, the superradiant phase transition (SRPT) would become a long sought-after experimental challenge 39 . A SRPT is a continuous phase transition, characterized by the buildup of a macroscopically populated, coherent photonic ground state above a critical coupling strength \eta_{c} 16 ; 39 ; 23 ; 34 . Spectrally, this translates to a softening of the lower polariton branch of the coupled system, as shown in Figure 1 a. Various dissipative-driven systems (such as thermal atomic vapors and Bose-Einstein condensates) have since been experimentally shown to exhibit non-equilibrium SRPTs, with external pumping necessary to induce the phase transition 4 ; 2 ; 43 . In the last 15 years, special attention has been devoted to solid-state and semiconductor systems 6 , where the presence of large carrier densities and subwavelength cavities allows the exploration of ultrastrong light-matter coupling regimes. While an equilibrium magnon-spin SRPT-analogue has been reported in 21 , the experimental realization of a photonic equilibrium SRPT remains elusive. The occurrence of second-order SRPTs in cavity quantum electrodynamic (cQED) systems has been disputed with the postulation of the so-called No-Go theorem 32 ; 24 ; 10 . Allowing for the criticality of the Dicke Hamiltonian is the truncation of interaction terms \mathcal{O}(\vec{A}^{2}) (with the electromagnetic vector potential \vec{A} ). However, with higher coupling strengths this truncation is no longer a valid approximation. The diamagnetic contribution (given by the \vec{A}^{2} -term) of the strongly interacting electric field needs to be accounted for, ensuring the preservation of the f-sum rule, as well as gauge invariance 32 ; 24 ; 10 ; 28 ; 33 ; 31 . The inclusion of this term exactly counteracts the emergence of the SRPT, and leads to the well known Hopfield Hamiltonian which has been shown to accurately describe ultrastrongly coupled light-matter systems 17 ; 25 ; 9 . An exception is constituted by Landau polaritons in non-parabolic SiGe quantum wells where a LP softening has been observed 20 . Still in search of a novel phase transition, this has inspired many theoretical predictions and counter-arguments about systems in which the No-Go theorem could be circumvented 28 ; 37 ; 12 ; 18 ; 1 ; 35 . The ultrastrong interaction of graphene cyclotron transitions with a Terahertz (THz) cavity mode became a platform of discussion for exactly such a debate 13 ; 5 . Owing to the linear dispersion of graphene carriers, the diamagnetic term does not arise directly in a minimal coupling approach 13 , but is only generated when considering interband transitions 5 . To investigate the behavior of such graphene Landau polaritons in the ultrastrongly coupled regime, THz transmission spectroscopy has to be performed under the influence of a magnetic field. While far field spectroscopy of large-scale graphene flakes can be performed in the THz range 36 ; 30 ; 40 , these chemically deposited 2D materials usually suffer from poor carrier mobility and are therefore not suitable for studying phenomena such as cyclotron transitions 7 . The limiting factor in optically probing exfoliated 2D materials with high mobility in the THz range is the size in which the flakes can be extracted, which is typically in the range of \approx 10\,\mu m

Read the complete text