Topological Signatures of Imperial Stress: Persistent Homology of the Eastern Mediterranean Trade Network, 0–400 CE

José de Jesús Bernal-Alvarado, David Delepine, Carlos Pinedo Guadarrama · 2026

Read Topological Signatures of Imperial Stress: Persistent Homology of the Eastern Mediterranean Trade Network, 0–400 CE by José de Jesús Bernal-Alvarado, David Delepine, Carlos Pinedo Guadarrama (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2605-27200.txt.

Introduction

Bernal and two co-authors track the Eastern Mediterranean trade network from year 0 to 400 with tools from persistent homology. They weight ORBIS road, sea, and river routes by cost, then let those weights shift each decade with plagues, wars, and reunification. The shape of the network shows three phases: steady high redundancy to year 200, a recoverable dip in the third-century crisis, and a steady decline after 290 that never recovers. The method thus picks up stress that single economic or military measures miss.

Catalog record

CREATORJosé de Jesús Bernal-Alvarado, David Delepine, Carlos Pinedo Guadarrama
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE51839
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2605.27200

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Topological Signatures of Imperial Stress: Persistent Homology of the Eastern Mediterranean Trade Network, 0–400 CE José de Jesús Bernal-Alvarado, David Delepine, Carlos Pinedo Guadarrama Abstract We apply persistent homology to the orbis Geospatial Network Model of the Roman World in order to quantify the structural resilience of the Eastern Mediterranean trade network between 0 and 400 ce . The network is represented as a weighted transport system whose edges correspond to road, maritime, and riverine routes, each carrying a base cost derived from the orbis cost model. To introduce historical dynamics into this static spatial infrastructure, we construct a differential friction model in which edge weights vary by decade and by transport mode according to documented historical perturbations, including epidemic mortality, civil war, military pressure, administrative reorganisation, and imperial reunification. For each decadal snapshot, we compute all-pairs shortest-path distances on the active sub-network and construct a Vietoris–Rips filtration using an adaptive threshold defined by the 90th percentile of finite pairwise distances. The resulting β 1 \beta_{1} persistent entropy time series identifies three structurally distinct phases in the Eastern Mediterranean network. Phase I, from 0 to 200 ce , is a stationary high-redundancy regime consistent with the commercial integration of the early imperial and Antonine periods. Phase II, from 210 to 280 ce , corresponds to recoverable stress during the Crisis of the Third Century: β 1 \beta_{1} entropy declines during the crisis but returns to the Phase I baseline following Aurelianic reunification. Phase III, from 290 to 400 ce , is qualitatively different: cycle redundancy declines monotonically and does not recover, despite the Diocletianic and Constantinian attempts at political and administrative consolidation. Chow structural break tests identify statistically significant breaks at 260 ce and 310 ce , with the latter marking the onset of an irreversible topological decline. The western sub-network available in the orbis extract produces no persistent β 1 \beta_{1} homology throughout the study period, a result interpreted as either a genuine indication of weaker western cycle redundancy or, more conservatively, a coverage limitation of the dataset. The main contribution of this study is to show that persistent homology detects a dimension of imperial stress that is not reducible to single economic, military, or political indicators. I Introduction The collapse of the Western Roman Empire remains one of the central problems in ancient history, not because the historical sequence of events is unknown, but because the causal structure behind those events remains contested. Military pressure, epidemic mortality, fiscal exhaustion, political fragmentation, climatic deterioration, and long-term economic transformation have all been proposed as explanatory mechanisms for the weakening of the imperial system Goldsworthy2009 ; Heather2006 ; Harper2017 ; Wickham2005 ; WardPerkins2005 . The difficulty lies in the fact that imperial resilience is not a scalar property. It cannot be measured only by the number of legions, the level of taxation, the frequency of civil wars, the price of grain, or the demographic impact of plague. These variables describe stressors or symptoms, but not the structure through which stress propagated. The Roman Empire was a spatially extended system held together by roads, ports, rivers, maritime corridors, military supply chains, tax redistribution, and regional exchange circuits. Its capacity to survive disruption depended not only on the severity of each perturbation, but also on whether the underlying network retained enough redundancy to reroute flows around damaged or expensive connections. A network may experience intense local stress and recover if alternative routes remain available. Conversely, a system may fail under apparently moderate stress if its connectivity has already become structurally fragile. The same military defeat, epidemic, or fiscal shock may therefore produce different historical outcomes depending on the topology of the network on which it acts. The relevant question is not only whether Roman trade was disrupted, but whether the network retained the cycle redundancy required for recovery. Persistent homology provides a natural mathematical language for this problem. In a weighted transport network, zero-dimensional homology tracks connected components, while one-dimensional homology tracks independent cycles. These cycles are not merely abstract mathematical objects: in a trade or transport system, they correspond to redundant routing structures. A persistent \beta_{1} feature indicates that an alternative circuit remains viable across a range of transport costs. A network with many persistent cycles has distributed resilience; a network with few or short-lived cycles depends on a smaller number of pathways and is more vulnerable to fragmentation Carlsson2009 ; Edelsbrunner2010 ; Ghrist2008 . The present study applies this model to the Eastern Mediterranean component of the Roman transport network between 0 and 400 ce . The spatial basis of the analysis is the orbis Geospatial Network Model of the Roman World, which encodes settlements and transport routes around Mediterranean sea Scheidel2012 ; Scheidel2014 . The companion historical problem is the asymmetry between East and West. The eastern imperial system survived the fifth-century collapse of western side of the empire and continued as Byzantine Empire. The West, by contrast, lost the political and material coherence associated with Roman empire. This divergence is explained through military pressure, fiscal weakness, political fragmentation, or economic localisation. The study is built around three research questions. The resilience question. Did the Eastern Mediterranean network maintain a stable topological regime or was its structure already declining before the third-century crisis? If the network was resilient, its persistent entropy should remain approximately stationary under ordinary fluctuations and recover after temporary perturbations. The irreversibility question. Was the Crisis of the Third Century a terminal structural break or a recoverable shock? A purely political or military narrative often treats the third century as the decisive rupture in Roman imperial history. A topological analysis can test whether the network actually lost recovery capacity during this period, or whether the irreversible decline occurred later. The topology-versus-politics question. Did political reunification restore the structural redundancy of the exchange network? If Diocletianic and Constantinian reforms repaired the system at the level of network geometry, then the \beta_{1} entropy series should stabilise or recover after administrative consolidation. If no recovery is observed, then political reunification did not imply topological restoration. To address these questions, we construct a decadal sequence of weighted networks from 0 to 400 ce . The static orbis costs are converted into time-dependent weights through a differential friction model. Transport-mode-specific multipliers to historical events are assigned: civil conflict affects roads differently from maritime routes; piracy and naval insecurity affect sea transport differently from riverine routes; military withdrawal changes the effective cost of frontier and provincial circulation. This structure is necessary because Roman transport was not homogeneous. For each decade, active nodes are selected according to their temporal availability. A weighted graph is then constructed and converted into a shortest-path distance matrix which is submitted to a Vietoris–Rips filtration. We use an adaptive threshold defined by the 90th percentile of finite distance matrix in each decadal network, such that the filtration is sensitive to the functional core of the network. From each persistence diagram we extract three quantities. The first is \beta_{1} persistent entropy, measuring the distributional diversity of cycle lifespans. High numerical values for entropy indicates multiple cycles of comparable persistence; low numerical value for entropy indicates concentration of redundancy in a smaller number of dominant cycles. The second is the normalised

Read the complete text