Quantum fluctuations and chaos in fully connected spin models

Aleksandra A. Ziolkowska, Aleksandr N. Mikheev · 2026

Read Quantum fluctuations and chaos in fully connected spin models by Aleksandra A. Ziolkowska, Aleksandr N. Mikheev (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2605-27199.txt.

Introduction

Ziolkowska and Mikheev study chaos and quantum fluctuations in a fully connected spin-exchange model with three-state spins. Going beyond mean-field theory with a two-particle irreducible effective action, they derive equations that track higher-order correlations built up by interactions. Their results show that quantum fluctuations can tame chaotic motion seen in large-scale observables. Treating those fluctuations with care is thus essential for large-scale dynamics, and the method links microscopic correlations to non-equilibrium behavior.

Catalog record

CREATORAleksandra A. Ziolkowska, Aleksandr N. Mikheev
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE68693
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2605.27199

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Quantum fluctuations and chaos in fully connected spin models Aleksandra A. Ziolkowska, Aleksandr N. Mikheev Abstract We investigate beyond-mean-field dynamics in a fully connected SU ⁡ ( 3 ) \mathrm{SU}(3) spin-exchange model, focusing on the interplay between chaotic dynamics and quantum fluctuations. Using the two-particle irreducible (2PI) effective action formalism, we derive equations of motion that systematically account for higher-order correlations generated by interactions, and demonstrate how quantum fluctuations can regularize chaotic dynamics displayed by macroscopic observables. Our results show that an accurate treatment of fluctuations is essential for describing macroscopic dynamics in quantum many-body systems and promote 2PI as a robust framework for connecting microscopic correlations to macroscopic nonequilibrium phenomena. I Introduction Fully connected models are one of the paradigmatic platforms for exploring nonequilibrium many-body physics 28 ; 9 ; 27 ; 53 ; 51 . These models naturally arise in quantum simulation platforms such as cavity-QED setups 47 or trapped-ion systems 38 ; 15 , where programmable spin-spin interactions can interpolate between short-range and nearly infinite-range limits. In the thermodynamic limit, their dynamics is often captured by a small set of macroscopic variables, yet can still display nontrivial phenomena characteristic of strongly interacting systems. The success of mean-field theory in such models relies on the suppression of correlations with larger system size. However, modern quantum simulators increasingly operate in regimes where strong correlations can become important and probe observables that are explicitly sensitive to fluctuations, including two-time correlation functions, noise spectra, and response functions 60 ; 32 ; 18 ; 56 ; 23 . Understanding the effect of fluctuations is therefore essential for characterizing nonequilibrium phases realized in experiments and for assessing the robustness of phenomena such as superradiance 7 , synchronization 59 , and time-crystalline order 21 . Their role becomes especially important near dynamical instabilities, soft-mode regimes, and phase boundaries 40 ; 29 ; 8 , where quantum fluctuations are not merely quantitative corrections but can qualitatively reshape phase diagrams and dynamical responses. Figure 1: A sketch of the dynamical phase diagram for the \mathrm{SU}(3) spin-exchange Hamiltonian initialized in a chaotic state for fixed h=g_{-}=1 . All parameters refer to Eq. ( II ) in the main text. Phase (I) represents regular dynamics, phase (II) chaotic dynamics as indicated by the second-order cumulant expansion, and phase (III) designates chaotic dynamics as shown by the 2PI computations with next-to-leading order corrections. The upper limit of the graph with an infinite system size corresponds to the mean-field limit, which is the same in both approaches. The dashed line corresponds to the ratio g_{+}/g_{-}=0.2 analyzed in Fig. 4 . See Sec. IV for the detailed discussion of the phase diagram. A common approach to incorporating beyond-mean-field effects is the cumulant expansion, in which the hierarchy of operator moments is truncated by neglecting higher-order correlations 31 ; 55 ; 17 . It provides a flexible and transparent approximation scheme that, even in its simplest form, can often show good agreement with exact dynamics across a broad range of settings 26 ; 42 . At the same time, it is known that fixed-order cumulant truncations are generally uncontrolled and can exhibit secular behavior or poor convergence when strong correlations quickly build up 45 ; 50 ; 41 ; 49 ; 16 ; 24 . While several extensions of the cumulant framework have been designed to alleviate these issues 46 ; 25 ; 6 ; 48 ; 52 , they usually introduce additional technical complexity and often require problem-specific choices, motivating complementary frameworks that organize correlation effects in a systematic and self-consistent manner. In this work, we adopt the two-particle irreducible (2PI) effective action formalism, highlighting its potential as a systematic and self-consistent approach to beyond-mean-field dynamics. This functional path-integral approach is based on selective resummations of interaction effects, yielding self-consistent equations for nonequilibrium Green’s functions that incorporate the feedback of higher-order correlations 13 ; 5 . It is therefore especially well suited to far-from-equilibrium problems in which higher-order correlations quickly build up dynamically. To showcase the utility of the 2PI framework, we investigate how fluctuations modify, suppress, and reshape chaotic macroscopic dynamics in a fully connected \mathrm{SU}(3) spin-exchange model. As illustrated in Fig. 1 , the chaotic dynamics of the macroscopic spins is regularized by strong fluctuations, which arise either at strong interaction strengths, corresponding to the right side of the diagram, or at small system sizes, corresponding to the lower part of the diagram. In addition, the phase diagram contains a regular region near its center, associated with the vicinity of an integrable point where the dynamics effectively reduces to \mathrm{SU}(2) . While the 2PI framework captures these fluctuation-induced regularization effects through self-consistently dressed two-point functions, the corresponding low-order cumulant truncation misses correlation feedback in the strong-interaction regime. A detailed discussion of the phase diagram and the underlying mechanisms is given in the main text. The paper is organized as follows. We begin in Sec. II by introducing the model under consideration. In Sec. III , we discuss the evolution equations governing the dynamics of the system’s observables. Starting from the conventional low-order cumulant expansion, we discuss the role of higher-order correlations that emerge dynamically during the evolution and the importance of treating them self-consistently. This motivates the use of the two-particle-irreducible (2PI) formalism, which we briefly review before presenting the 1/L expansion for fully connected systems. In Sec. IV , we use these methods to study how fluctuations affect the chaotic dynamics of macroscopic observables. We summarize and draw our conclusions in Sec. V . II Model We consider a fully connected spin-exchange model of \mathrm{SU}(N) spins. As discussed in the introduction, such models naturally emerge as effective descriptions of N -level systems uniformly coupled to a common bosonic mediator, such as a cavity photon mode in optical or circuit QED 39 ; 33 ; 54 or collective phonon modes in trapped-ion systems 44 ; 30 . In the far-detuned regime, the mediator can be adiabatically eliminated, resulting in virtual exchange interactions between all pairs of spins. The simplest case N=2 recovers conventional collective \mathrm{SU}(2) spin models, with the Lipkin–Meshkov–Glick Hamiltonian 34 ; 37 ; 19 serving as a paradigmatic example. This class of models is known to exhibit only regular dynamical responses, such as relaxation and persistent oscillations 54 . The absence of complex, irregular dynamical regimes in the \mathrm{SU}(2) case can be traced to the limited number of degrees of freedom, n=3 , in the effective collective-spin description. Combined with energy and spin conservation, this strongly restricts the possible range of dynamical responses. The minimal fully connected spin-exchange model capable of chaotic dynamics is consequently realized by \mathrm{SU}(3) spins. In this work, we consider a bosonic realization of such a fully connected spin model described by the Hamiltonian \displaystyle\hat{H} \displaystyle=h\sum_{j=1}^{L}\left(\hat{T}_{j,11}-\hat{T}_{j,33}\right) \displaystyle-\frac{1}{L}\sum_{i,j=1}^{L}\left(g_{+}\hat{T}_{i,12}+g_{-}\hat{T}_{i,23}\right)\left(g_{+}\hat{T}_{j,21}+g_{-}\hat{T}_{j,32}\right), (1) where h is a homogeneous magnetic field and g_{\pm} are the hopping rates corresponding to each of the allowed transitions between levels \alpha\in\{1,2,3\} . The operators \hat{T}_{j,\alpha\beta}=b^{\dagger}_{j,\alpha}b_{j,\beta} , defined as bosonic bilinears, form effective \mathrm{SU}(3) spin operators, satisfying the algebra \big[\hat{T}_{i,\alpha\beta},\hat{T}_{j,\gamma\delta}\big]=\delta_{ij}\left(\delta_{\beta\gamma}\hat{T}_{j,\alpha\delta}-\delta_{\delta\alpha}\hat{T}_{j,\gamma\beta}\right)\equiv\mathrm{i}\delta_{ij}f_{\alpha\beta;\gamma\delta;\epsilon\eta}\hat{T}_{j,\epsilon\eta}. (2) Here and in the following, the standard Einstein summation convention over repeated indices is implied. The above model may be viewed as a 3-level generalization of the Tavis–Cummings model with an adiabatically eliminated

Read the complete text