Lack of Gevrey solvability for a model operator
Enrico Bernardi · 2026
Read Lack of Gevrey solvability for a model operator by Enrico Bernardi (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2605-27054.txt.
Introduction
Bernardi proves the Cauchy problem for a model hyperbolic operator in four-dimensional space is not locally solvable at the origin in the Gevrey class when the Gevrey index exceeds 6. The operator combines second time derivatives with mixed and spatial terms, including cubic coefficients in the spatial variables. The result draws a sharp line for solvability of this model: above index 6, no local Gevrey solution exists at the origin.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Enrico Bernardi |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 88039 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2605.27054
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Lack of Gevrey solvability for a model operator Enrico Bernardi Abstract We prove that the Cauchy problem for the model hyperbolic operator in ℝ 4 \mathbb{R}^{4} Q = − D t 2 + 2 x D t D y + D x 2 + x 3 D y 2 + D z 2 + z 2 D y 2 Q=-D_{t}^{2}+2xD_{t}D_{y}+D_{x}^{2}+x^{3}D_{y}^{2}+D_{z}^{2}+z^{2}D_{y}^{2} is not locally solvable at the origin, in the Gevrey s s class if s > 6 s>6 . Keywords: Cauchy Problem, Hyperbolic Operators, Gevrey classes, Hamilton systems, Analysis of ODEs. 1 Introduction and main theorem Dating back to the foundational papers [ 7 , 10 ] , the theory of well-posedness for the Cauchy problem of linear hyperbolic operators with double characteristics in the C^{\infty} category has progressed towards an ever more complete understanding of the subtle interplay between the symplectic invariants of the double set and the functional analytic features of the problem. In [ 11 ] , to which we refer for all the standard notations and terminology, one finds a comprehensive account of the state of the art in the case of non-effectively hyperbolic operators. These are identified as those operators whose symbol at a double point has its fundamental matrix—i.e. its Hessian read via \sigma=d\xi\wedge dx , the symplectic 2-form in the cotangent of \mathbb{R}^{n+1} —without real eigenvalues. When the principal symbol’s spectral behavior never changes, thus avoiding transition cases, the general picture is today fairly clear. For some recent work on the transition cases see however [ 2 ] and [ 3 ] . The only situation not yet fully understood in the domain where the spectral type of the fundamental matrix never varies, is when two phenomena occur simultaneously: there exists a null bicharacteristic tangent to the double manifold, and the positive trace \mathrm{Tr}^{+}F_{p} of the principal symbol — the sum of positive imaginary eigenvalues of the fundamental matrix — is strictly positive. On the other hand it is known that the existence of a null tangent bicharacteristic, as shown e.g. in [ 1 ] or proven again in [ 11 ] , modifies the natural Gevrey threshold (which is 2 for general operators with double characteristics, see [ 4 ] for the case of operators with any multiplicity) beyond which the Cauchy problem well-posedness may cease to exist. Furthermore this type of unstable Hamilton system may happen in only one of the symplectic types in which the algebraic structure of the non-effectively hyperbolic symbols can be classified: the complete list of these cases can be found for example in [ 8 ] . In this regard we recall a simple example, where the positive trace is 0 and the necessary Ivriĭ–Petkov–Hörmander conditions on the lower order terms are verified, and yet the Cauchy problem at the origin for P=-D_{t}^{2}+2xD_{t}D_{y}+D_{x}^{2}+x^{3}D_{y}^{2}, (1.1) fails to be locally solvable in \gamma^{(s)} (see below Definition 1.2 for the definition of the Gevrey spaces \gamma^{(s)} ) for s>5 , with the convention D_{j}=\frac{1}{i}\partial_{x_{j}} for derivatives. This is essentially due to the existence of a simple null bicharacteristic x=-t^{2}/4,\ y=t^{5}/8,\ \tau=0,\ \xi=t^{3}/8,\ \eta=1, (1.2) parametrized by t and landing tangentially onto \Sigma=\{\tau=x=\xi=0,\,\eta\neq 0\} . Moreover this phenomenon happens even in some transition cases, i.e. when the spectral type of the principal symbol of the operator varies along the double manifold, see the recent result [ 3 ] . As explained in [ 11 , p. 141] , after renaming the variables, one model in this yet undecided category where the positive trace \mathrm{Tr}^{+}F_{p}>0 and admitting a null tangent bicharacteristic, with (t,x,y,z)\in\mathbb{R}^{4} , is given by Q=-D_{t}^{2}+2xD_{t}D_{y}+D_{x}^{2}+x^{3}D_{y}^{2}+D_{z}^{2}+z^{2}D_{y}^{2}. (1.3) This model, which can be easily characterized in a symplectically invariant way, has analytic coefficients, verifies the necessary Ivriĭ–Petkov–Hörmander conditions on the lower-order terms, its subprincipal symbol being 0 like in ( 1.1 ), and comes with a null tangent bicharacteristic to its double manifold \Sigma=\{\tau=x=z=\zeta=\xi=0,\,\eta\neq 0\} . However the presence of the added harmonic oscillator in the z variable is enough to completely disrupt the technique to show lack of Gevrey s solvability when s>5 , which was used in [ 11 ] and was based on a fine study of the zeros of the Stokes coefficients (see e.g. [ 13 ] for some of their general properties) of a second order ODE attached to ( 1.1 ). As noted in [ 11 , p. 141] , until now it was only known that the Cauchy problem for Q is \gamma^{(6)} -well-posed. The purpose of this paper is to prove the following result. (See Definition 1.2 below for the Gevrey space \gamma^{(s)} ). Theorem 1.1 . Let s>6 . The Cauchy problem for Q at the origin is not locally solvable, in the sense of Definition 1.3 , in the (Roumieu) Gevrey class \gamma^{(s)} . Theorem 1.1 thus shows that s=6 is the precise Gevrey threshold for the local solvability problem for Q , just as s=5 was the precise Gevrey threshold for the local solvability problem for P . The proof of Theorem 1.1 follows the usual closed graph and contradiction strategy utilized in [ 1 ] and [ 11 ] in the study of tangent bicharacteristics, but the model considered here requires a different scaling and a different one-dimensional reduction. We construct a family of exact analytic null solutions depending on a large real parameter \lambda : V_{\lambda}(t,x,y,z)=e^{i\tau_{\lambda}t}e^{i\lambda^{6}y}\psi_{\lambda}(z)W_{\lambda}(\lambda^{2}x),\qquad\tau_{\lambda}=\sigma\lambda^{2}-i\gamma\lambda, where \sigma>0 , \gamma>0 , and \psi_{\lambda} is the ground state of the harmonic oscillator in the z -variable at frequency \lambda^{6} . The function W_{\lambda} is the recessive solution at +\infty of the reduced ordinary differential equation \left[-\partial_{X}^{2}+\lambda^{2}q_{\lambda}(X)\right]W_{\lambda}(X)=0,\qquad X=\lambda^{2}x, chosen with its natural WKB or Liouville–Green normalization on the right. More precisely, the branch of q_{\lambda}^{1/2} is fixed by q_{\lambda}(0)^{1/2}=1+O(\lambda^{-2}), and the normalization is chosen so that, for X\geq 0 , W_{\lambda}(X)=q_{\lambda}(X)^{-1/4}\exp\left(-\lambda\int_{0}^{X}q_{\lambda}(r)^{1/2}\,dr\right)\left(1+O(\lambda^{-1})\right). In particular, W_{\lambda}(0)=q_{\lambda}(0)^{-1/4}\left(1+O(\lambda^{-1})\right)=1+O(\lambda^{-1}), so no additional normalization at X=0 is needed. This gives a uniform lower bound for the cutoff test function near the origin |W_{\lambda}(\lambda^{2}x)|\geq c,\qquad|x|\leq c_{0}\lambda^{-3}. The reduced equation has a polynomial potential with a single simple complex turning point X_{\lambda} , at O(\lambda^{-1}) distance to the unique real negative solution X_{\ast} of q_{\infty}(X)=0 , see Figure 2 . We use the standard Liouville–Green (in the sequel shorthanded by LG) and Airy connection machinery near X_{\lambda} to continue the subdominant solution at +\infty across the turning point region and into the relevant negative real region. In fact the connection relation among the solutions tells us that continuing the recessive branch through the Airy neighborhood does not create an exponentially large coefficient. This eventually yields the upper bounds \left|\partial_{x}^{k}W_{\lambda}(\lambda^{2}x)\right|\leq C^{k+1}k!\lambda^{M+6k}\exp\left(A_{\sigma}\lambda+C(\sigma)\gamma\sqrt{\delta}\,\lambda\right),\qquad|x|\leq\delta, where A_{\sigma}=\int_{X_{\ast}}^{0}\sqrt{V_{\sigma}(r)}\,dr. The factor e^{A_{\sigma}\lambda} arises when continuing the subdominant LG solution from X=0 leftward toward the turning point, while the e^{C(\sigma)\gamma\sqrt{\delta}} factor is due to the lower order perturbations in \lambda^{-1} in q_{\lambda}(X) . We no longer need to use fine information about the zeros of Stokes coefficients for this particular ODE: the continuation is controlled throughout by the dominant LG mode, whose modulus is insensitive to the Stokes constant relating the two sides of the turning point (see Proposition 5.5 ). This is the real reason the method survives the addition of the harmonic oscillator. The tangential frequency is \lambda^{6}