Looking for Condensed Gluons: A Cross-Scale Journey from the Deep Structure of Protons to High-Energy Cosmic Rays—A Mini-Review

Wei Zhu, Yu-Chen Tang, Ye-Yin Zhao, Bo Yang, Yu-Chen Xiong · 2026

Read Looking for Condensed Gluons: A Cross-Scale Journey from the Deep Structure of Protons to High-Energy Cosmic Rays—A Mini-Review by Wei Zhu, Yu-Chen Tang, Ye-Yin Zhao, Bo Yang, Yu-Chen Xiong (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2605-27018.txt.

Introduction

Zhu and four co-authors review gluon condensation as a bridge between proton structure and high-energy cosmic rays. The Zhu-Shen-Ruan equation links nonlinear evolution equations and may generate condensation. Chaotic solutions can drive gluons to pile up near a critical momentum. The resulting microstructure shows up as a broken-power-law feature in cosmic gamma-ray spectra. If confirmed, the picture offers a new window on proton structure and a fresh entry point for pion condensation research.

Catalog record

CREATORWei Zhu, Yu-Chen Tang, Ye-Yin Zhao, Bo Yang, Yu-Chen Xiong
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE59340
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2605.27018

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Looking for Condensed Gluons: A Cross-Scale Journey from the Deep Structure of Protons to High-Energy Cosmic Rays—A Mini-Review Wei Zhu, Yu-Chen Tang, Ye-Yin Zhao, Bo Yang, Yu-Chen Xiong Abstract Quark–gluon dynamics within protons and high-energy radiation phenomena in the universe are typically regarded as two entirely distinct fields. This paper aims to demonstrate that gluon condensation (GC) may serve as a direct bridge between these two fields. We review three key aspects of GC research: first, the Zhu–Shen–Ruan (ZSR) equation, as a nonlinear evolution equation based on structural symmetry, exhibits self-consistent connections with the DGLAP, BFKL and GLR-MQ-ZRS equations, providing a theoretical foundation for the generation of GC; second, the chaotic solutions and the shadowing–antishadowing synergy inherent in this equation can drive gluons to aggregate near the critical momentum, thereby forming a novel type of high-density, strongly interacting matter; third, these changes in microstructure manifest themselves as a broken-power-law feature in high-energy cosmic gamma-ray spectra, thereby offering new insights into the hadronic scenarios underlying certain astrophysical sources. Consequently, GC not only concerns the novel behaviour of quantum chromodynamics under extreme conditions but may also serve as a vital window for probing the deep structure of protons using cosmic-ray signals. With the advancement of higher-precision gamma-ray observations, hadron collision experiments and related theoretical research, the physical picture of GC and its observational criteria are expected to undergo more rigorous testing. Should this picture be confirmed, certain features in the high-energy gamma-ray spectrum (previously attributed solely to empirical fitting or lepton models) will need to be re-examined within the deeper context of hadronic dynamics; simultaneously, GC may also provide a new entry point for research into pion condensation in nuclear physics and even condensed matter physics. Consequently, the significance of the search for GC extends beyond the model itself, reaching into multiple fields of natural science. I Introduction Human understanding of nature now spans an unprecedentedly vast range, extending from the quark–gluon distribution within protons to cosmic ray signals originating from various galaxies. The search for connections between phenomena occurring at these two extreme scales presents a challenging task that bridges the fields of particle physics and astrophysics ( Torres and Anchordoqui 2004 ; Müller 2025 ) . The Quantum Chromodynamics (QCD) evolution equations are an indispensable tool for studying quark–gluon distribution functions ( Sterman 1993 ) . The existence of gluons in the proton was first established by two classic evolution equations: the Dokshitzer–Gribov–Lipatov–Altarelli–Parisi (DGLAP) ( Gribov and Lipatov 1972 ; Dokshitzer 1977 ; Altarelli and Parisi 1977 ) and Balitsky–Fadin–Kuraev–Lipatov (BFKL) ( Lipatov 1976 ; Fadin et al. 1975 ; Kuraev et al. 1976 ; Kuraev et al. 1977 ; Balitsky and Lipatov 1978 ) equations. Further insights into gluons within the proton are predicted by non-linear modifications of these two equations, namely the Gribov–Levin–Ryskin–Mueller–Qiu (GLR-MQ) ( Gribov et al. 1983 ; Mueller and Qiu 1986 ) and Balitsky–Kovchegov (BK) ( Balitsky 1996 ; Kovchegov 1999 ; Kovchegov 2000 ) equations. These emphasise that gluon splitting leads to an increase in gluon density, whereby gluons suppress their own unreasonably rapid growth through aggregation. In particular, the Jalilian-Marian–Iancu–McLerran–Weigert–Leonidov–Kovner (JIMWLK) equations ( Jalilian-Marian et al. 1997a ; Jalilian-Marian et al. 1997b ; Jalilian-Marian et al. 1998 ; Iancu and McLerran 2001 ; Weigert 2002 ) , which are a generalisation of the BK equation to the case of multiple gluon correlations, predict a saturation limit for the gluon distribution—the Color Glass Condensate (CGC) (Fig. 1 a,b) ( McLerran and Venugopalan 1994a ; McLerran and Venugopalan 1994b ; McLerran and Venugopalan 1994c ) —thereby sparking a surge of interest in the search for CGC in heavy-ion colliders ( Garcia-Montero and Schlichting 2025 ; Jalilian-Marian and Kovchegov 2006 ; Gelis et al. 2010 ) . However, CGC has yet to break free from the confines of the accelerator laboratory and venture into the distant depths of the universe, as it remains a relatively weak effect that cannot be detected through astronomical observations. Figure 1: Schematic diagrams of CGC ( a , b ) and GC ( c , d ). The GC threshold k_{c}^{2}\simeq CGC scale Q^{2}_{s} , but x_{c}\ll x_{s} . This paper sheds light on a peculiar aspect of gluon behaviour within the proton—gluon condensation (GC), which may provide a unique perspective on the aforementioned research. All QCD evolution equations describe changes in the parton distribution function under the fundamental interactions of QCD (splitting and recombination). Evolutionary kernels (evolutionary dynamics) can be linear or non-linear. Each type exhibits both positive and negative components, which is a consequence of momentum conservation. The contributions from the positive and negative non-linear terms are referred to as antishadowing (positive feedback) and shadowing (negative feedback), respectively. The shadowing effect weakens the particle distribution, whilst the partons whose intensity has been weakened in turn reduce the shadowing effect; this process continues until equilibrium and saturation are ultimately reached. The JIMWLK equation describes precisely this process. Unlike shadowing, antishadowing is a positive feedback mechanism; the stronger it is, the stronger the antishadowing becomes. Consequently, even after a very short evolution path, the number of partons tends to infinity. In practical examples, the GLR equation employs the AGK cutting rule ( Abramovsky et al. 1973 ) to generate a negative non-linear term, resulting in a net shadowing effect. In the BK equation, the non-linear term is generated by the dipole splitting mechanism, which also produces a net shadowing effect. The shadowing effects of both equations are not strong enough. (Note that the flat distribution observed in the impact parameter space does not indicate saturation!) It is only after the JIMWLK equation sums over multipole amplitudes that the strong shadowing effect produces the saturated distribution—CGC. It is well known that perturbation theory in quantum field theory requires the summation of contributions from all correlated processes of the same order; this not only eliminates infrared divergences but also preserves momentum conservation. Work ( Zhu 1999 ) utilised the Time-Ordered Perturbative Theory (TOPT) cutting rule to improve the GLR-MQ and BK equations, thereby preserving momentum conservation whilst allowing for the coexistence of shadowing and antishadowing. The resulting equations are denoted as the Zhu–Ruan–Shen (ZRS) ( Zhu and Ruan 1999 ; Zhu and Shen 2005 ) and Zhu–Shen–Ruan (ZSR) ( Zhu et al. 2016 ) equations, respectively. The ZRS equation introduces an antishadowing correction to the GLR equation; however, as shadowing continues to dominate the evolution, the significance of antishadowing has not yet received sufficient attention ( Wang et al. 2024 ; Lalung et al. 2019a ; Lalung et al. 2019b ) . It was not until the ZSR equation, where the Lipatov singularity appears in the nonlinear term, that chaos was induced; the violent oscillations resulting from this chaos, in turn, caused the distribution function at the singularity to exhibit strong antishadowing. In concert with the strong shadowing that occurs simultaneously, the saturated gluons are further compressed into a novel class of condensate—GC (Fig. 1 c,d). Owing to the highly distinctive behaviour of the condensed gluons, we can use cosmic-ray signals at energies far exceeding those of existing accelerators to peer into the deep structure of the proton; conversely, this pathway also opens a new window for us to understand the origin of

Read the complete text