Relating forcing relations
Michel Viana Smykalla, Hugo Luiz Mariano · 2026
Read Relating forcing relations by Michel Viana Smykalla, Hugo Luiz Mariano (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2605-26896.txt.
Introduction
Smykalla and Mariano relate three versions of forcing, the technique Cohen introduced for independence proofs: model theory, Boolean-valued models, and topos theory. Folklore holds the three equivalent in mathematical content, but the literature lacks explicit links. They present new results toward establishing those links, moving the equivalence claim from folklore toward proof.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Michel Viana Smykalla, Hugo Luiz Mariano |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 67917 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2605.26896
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Relating forcing relations Michel Viana Smykalla, Hugo Luiz Mariano Abstract Forcing was first introduced by Paul J. Cohen in his work on the independence of the Continuum Hypothesis. Other formulations of forcing appeared using Model Theory, Boolean-valued Models, and Topos Theory. There is a folkloric claim that these three approaches are equivalent, at least at the level of their mathematical content. In this work, we present some results not found in the literature toward establishing connections between these versions of forcing. Keywords: forcing, Boolean-valued models, sheaves, topos theory Introduction To complete the proof of the independence of the Continuum Hypothesis ( CH ) from the axioms of Zermelo-Fraenkel Set Theory including the Axiom of Choice ( ZFC ), Paul J. Cohen developed a technique called forcing, which allows us to extend models of ZFC and, in particular, to present an extension where the CH fails, see [ 6 ] and [ 7 ] . For the first time in the history of Mathematics, one mathematical statement was proven to be undecidable inside the theory, and it started the era of independent results. Other formulations of forcing appeared almost at the same time in the 1960s, given the fact that the use of constructable sets could be replaced by constructing a Boolean-valued Model, done by the hands of Dana Scott and Solovay [ 15 ] . A decade later, formulations in Topos Theory appeared (Mitchell-Bénabou language, Kripke Joyal semantics, see [ 12 ] Chapter VI). Forcing ideas were also introduced in Model Theory in the 1970s by Shoenfield [ 16 ] . There is a well-known claim that these three approaches of forcing in Set-theory are the same, at least at the level of their mathematical content: “Nevertheless, it is our clear understanding that the ultimate mathematical content of all these methods (generic sets, Boolean-valued models, and double-negation sheaves) is essentially the same. Indeed, a reading of the original paper by Paul Cohen clearly reveals the role there of double-negation. And sheafification has a wraith-like presence in Cohen’s paper. Perhaps a full understanding makes use of all three approaches — generic sets, sheaves, Boolean-valued Models!” Saunders Mac Lane and Ieke Moerdijk [ 12 ] However, to the best of our knowledge, there is no published paper containing a precise/complete description of these equivalences. The aim of this paper is to shed some light on this, building on the results presented in the first author’s Master’s Thesis, [ 18 ] . Outline of the paper: We begin by presenting the basic definitions in forcing in Section 1 , to establish the notation. Section 2 is devoted to present a comparison between forcing notions between posets that we can find in the literature, under the existence of a particular poset morphism called dense morphism. In Section 3 , we propose a point of view of where forcing with posets and forcing semantics in Boolean-valued models are the same. The key step here is to unify the definitions of name and forcing relation. Section 4 is devoted to compare Boolean-valued models and topos of sheaves over complete Boolean algebras and to establish a generalization of a well-known result connecting notions of forcing using sheaf theory, thanks to a generalization of the so called Comparison Lemma in Topos Theory. We finish this work in Section 5 , showing directions of future research concerning categorical and semantical questions. From now on, we assume that the definitions refer to sets inside a fixed countable transitive model M , pointing out when it is not the case. 1 Basic forcing notation Before we go to the comparison between the methods, first we introduce the basic definitions of forcing with posets and generic filters, and forcing through Boolean-valued models. For a complete presentation of each version, see [ 10 ] and [ 11 ] , respectively. Definition 1.1 . Let \mathbb{P} be a non-empty set, \mathbbm{1}\in\mathbb{P} and \leq a relation on \mathbb{P} . We say that the triple (\mathbb{P},\leq,\mathbbm{1}) is a forcing poset if the relation \leq is a pre-order and for all p\in\mathbb{P} , p\leq\mathbbm{1} . Example 1.2 . Let \omega be the set of natural numbers with the reverse inequality \succcurlyeq , i.e., for all x,y\in\omega x\succcurlyeq y\text{ iff }y\leq x. Then (\omega,\succcurlyeq,0) is a forcing poset. Example 1.3 . Fix a cardinal \kappa>\aleph_{1} and consider the following set: \mathbb{P}_{\kappa}=\{f\in 2^{\omega\times\kappa}:|f|<\aleph_{0}\}. That is, \mathbb{P}_{\kappa} is the set of all finite functions from \omega\times\kappa to 2 . For all f,g\in\mathbb{P}_{\kappa} , f\leq g if g\subseteq f as a function. With this order, \mathbb{P}_{\kappa} is a forcing poset, which we call by Cohen forcing . Definition 1.4 . Let \mathbb{P} be a forcing poset and D\subseteq\mathbb{P} . Then D is dense in \mathbb{P} if for all p\in\mathbb{P} , there exists d\in D such that d\leq p . Definition 1.5 . Let \mathbb{P} be a poset. A subset D\subseteq\mathbb{P} is predense if for all p\in\mathbb{P} , there exists d\in D such that p and d are compatible, that is, there exists r\in\mathbb{P} such that r\leq p,d . Definition 1.6 . Let \mathbb{P} be a forcing poset and D\subseteq\mathbb{P} . Given p\in\mathbb{P} , we say that D is dense below p if for all q\in\mathbb{P} such that q\leq p , there exists d\in D so that d\leq q . Definition 1.7 . Let \mathbb{P} be a forcing poset and G\subseteq\mathbb{P} . Then G is a filter on \mathbb{P} if 1. \mathbbm{1}\in G . 2. For all p,q\in G , there exists r\in G such that r\leq p,q. 3. For all p,q\in\mathbb{P} , if q\in G and q\leq p , then p\in G. Definition 1.8 . Let \mathbb{P} be a forcing poset, and G be a filter on \mathbb{P} . Then G is \mathbb{P}- generic (over M ) if for all dense subset D\subseteq\mathbb{P} such that D\in M , G\cap D\neq\emptyset . Definition 1.9 . Let \mathbb{P} be a forcing poset. Then a set \overset{.}{x} is a ( \mathbb{P}-) name if \overset{.}{x} is a relation and the elements of \overset{.}{x} are of the form (\overset{.}{y},p) , where \overset{.}{y} is a (\mathbb{P}-) name and p\in\mathbb{P} . We denote by M^{\mathbb{P}} the class of all \mathbb{P}- names. Definition 1.10 . Let \mathbb{P} be a forcing poset and G a filter on \mathbb{P} . Given \overset{.}{x} a name, we define \overset{.}{x}_{G}=\{\overset{.}{y}_{G}:\exists p\in G((\overset{.}{y},p)\in\overset{.}{x})\}. Definition 1.11 . Let \mathbb{P} be a forcing poset. Then M[G]=\{\overset{.}{x}_{G}\penalty\ |\penalty\ \overset{.}{x}\in M^{\mathbb{P}}\}. Definition 1.12 . Let \mathbb{P} be a forcing poset and \overset{.}{x} and \overset{.}{y} be \mathbb{P}- names. We define recursively the forcing relation \Vdash^{*} as follows: For all p\in\mathbb{P} , 1. p \Vdash^{*} \overset{.}{x}=\overset{.}{y} iff for all \overset{.}{z}\in dom(\overset{.}{x})\cup dom(\overset{.}{y}) and for all q\leq p(q\Vdash^{*}\overset{.}{z}\in\overset{.}{x} iff q\Vdash^{*}\overset{.}{z}\in\overset{.}{y}) . 2. p\Vdash^{*}\overset{.}{x}\in\overset{.}{y} iff the set \{q\leq p:\exists(\overset{.}{z},r)\in\overset{.}{y} which q\leq r and q\Vdash^{*}\overset{.}{x}=\overset{.}{z}\} is dense below p . Let \phi and \psi be sentences of language of forcing. Then: 3. p\Vdash^{*}\phi\land\psi iff p\Vdash^{*}\phi and p\Vdash^{*}\psi . 4. p\Vdash^{*}\neg\phi iff there is no q\leq p such that q\Vdash^{*}\phi . 5. p\Vdash^{*}\phi\to\psi iff there is no q\leq p such that q\Vdash^{*}\phi\land\neg\psi 6. p\Vdash^{*}\phi\lor\psi iff \{q:q\Vdash^{*}\phi or q\Vdash^{*}\psi\} is dense below p. 7. p\Vdash^{*}\phi\leftrightarrow\psi iff there are no q\leq p such that q\Vdash^{*}\phi\land\neg\psi and no r\leq p such that r\Vdash^{*}\neg\phi\land\psi . 8. p\Vdash^{*}\forall x\phi(x) iff