Azimuthal asymmetry in exclusive quasi-elastic neutrino-nucleus interactions Preprint: APS/123-QED
Marco Vanderpoorten, Ashish Kumar Jha, Mathias El Baz, Kajetan Niewczas, Federico Sánchez, Natalie Jachowicz · 2026
Read Azimuthal asymmetry in exclusive quasi-elastic neutrino-nucleus interactions Preprint: APS/123-QED by Marco Vanderpoorten, Ashish Kumar Jha, Mathias El Baz, Kajetan Niewczas, Federico Sánchez, Natalie Jachowicz (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2605-26877.txt.
Introduction
Vanderpoorten and five co-authors derive the general angle pattern for quasi-elastic neutrino-nucleus scattering, a link long missed. The outgoing nucleon tends to fly out of the lepton scattering plane, a lopsided pattern they trace to parity breaking in the weak force. The pattern shifts with nuclear models and shell structure, giving a new clue for rebuilding neutrino energy. Tests suggest it shows up with about 10,000 events at 99 percent confidence on carbon-12.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Marco Vanderpoorten, Ashish Kumar Jha, Mathias El Baz, Kajetan Niewczas, Federico Sánchez, Natalie Jachowicz |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 65029 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/publicdomain/zero/1.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC0 |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2605.26877
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Azimuthal asymmetry in exclusive quasi-elastic neutrino-nucleus interactions Preprint: APS/123-QED Marco Vanderpoorten, Ashish Kumar Jha, Mathias El Baz, Kajetan Niewczas, Federico Sánchez, Natalie Jachowicz Abstract In neutrino oscillation experiments, exclusive measurements of neutrino–nucleus interactions play a critical role, by providing the theoretical and experimental input needed for a reliable estimation of the neutrino energy. In this paper, we derive the general form of the azimuthal angle distribution for quasi-elastic scattering, focusing on a dependency that has been routinely overlooked. We demonstrate that the outgoing nucleon exhibits a preference for emission outside the lepton scattering plane, with an asymmetric azimuthal distribution. In the context of neutrino–nucleus scattering, we argue that this asymmetry is caused by parity violation in the weak interaction. Furthermore, we show that in cross section calculations the asymmetry is sensitive to nuclear modeling choices and to the shell structure of the initial nucleus, thus providing a novel source of information for energy reconstruction in neutrino experiments. We study the experimental feasibility of observing this effect by applying a realistic momentum detection threshold and an intranuclear cascade. We estimate that the asymmetry is observable with 𝒪 ( 10 4 ) \mathcal{O}(10^{4}) events at the 99 % 99\% confidence level for neutrino interactions on 12 C, suggesting that the effect is within reach of the current generation of neutrino detectors. I Introduction Neutrino oscillation experiments have increasingly entered what may be called the ‘exclusive era’. Among others, T2K Abe et al. 2018a ; Abe et al. 2018b , NINJA Hiramoto et al. 2020 , MINER \nu A Cai et al. 2023 ; Cai et al. 2020 ; Lu et al. 2018 ; Walton et al. 2015 , SBND Acciarri et al. 2015a , ArgoNeuT Acciarri et al. 2014 and MicroBooNE Abratenko et al. 2025 ; Abratenko et al. 2022 detectors have proven the capability to detect the final-state lepton ( \mu^{\pm},e^{\pm} ) in coincidence with other charged particles ( p^{+},\pi^{\pm},... ). The hadron kinematic variables, often referred to as exclusive variables, provide additional information on the final-state particles, help constrain the neutrino energy reconstruction González-Jiménez et al. 2022 ; Douqa et al. 2024 , and even improve our understanding of the neutrino beam Karpova et al. 2025 . In the reconstruction of the neutrino energy, precise neutrino-nucleus interaction cross sections are pivotal. Typically, Monte Carlo event generators are tuned to match data from near detectors, and the results are extrapolated to the far detector. However, recent studies have shown that this procedure is insufficient in reducing the systematic uncertainties in the determination of physical parameters Coyle et al. 2025 ; Coyle et al. 2022 ; Abud et al. 2023 . A novel approach for studying the relationship between the detector’s observable energy deposits and the true energy of the interacting neutrino is the Precision Reaction Independent Spectrum Measurement (PRISM) Abbaslu et al. 2025 system, which will be implemented in DUNE Acciarri et al. 2016a ; Acciarri et al. 2015b ; Strait et al. 2016 ; Acciarri et al. 2016b , or the Intermediate Water Cherenkov Detector (IWCD) Scott 2016 that will be part of the Hyper-K Abe et al. 2026 experiment. By positioning the near detector at different off-axis angles relative to the beam, PRISM and IWCD enable measurements of varied neutrino spectra Abud et al. 2021 ; Zhu 2023 . While experimental strategies such as PRISM and IWCD can help constrain the relation between detector observables and neutrino energy, theoretical modeling remains indispensable for describing and understanding the complex nuclear dynamics involved in neutrino-nucleus interactions. To provide the theoretical and experimental input needed for reliable energy reconstruction, exclusive measurements of neutrino–nucleus interactions play a central role. In such measurements, the outgoing charged lepton is reconstructed in coincidence with at least one other particle from the interaction. A particularly important example is the Charged-Current Quasi-Elastic (CCQE) process. These are interactions of the form: \nu_{l}+^{A}_{Z}X\to l^{-}+^{A-1}_{Z}X+p^{+} or \overline{\nu}_{l}+^{A}_{Z}X\to l^{+}+^{A-1}_{Z-1}Y+n^{0} , with l any charged lepton (e, \mu or \tau ). These interactions account for a significant part of the total cross section in most current (T2K Abe et al. 2011 , MicroBooNE Acciarri et al. 2017 , MINER \nu A Aliaga et al. 2014 ) and future (Hyper-Kamiokande, DUNE, ESS \nu SB Alekou et al. 2023 ) accelerator-based neutrino detectors. In such processes, five independent variables can be considered: two lepton kinematic variables and three hadron kinematic variables. The former are detected in inclusive measurements, while the latter constitute the hadronic exclusive observables. These are the hadron kinetic energy, polar and azimuthal angle. In this work, we investigate how hadron observables can improve our understanding of neutrino-nucleus interactions. In particular, we focus on the final-state hadron’s azimuthal angle and how the dependence of the cross section on this quantity varies with nuclear shell structure differences and modeling choices. As the carbon-to-oxygen cross section ratio is vital for water-based experiments (e.g., Hyper-K, Super-K Abe et al. 2020 ), studying the azimuthal angle distribution can significantly enhance carbon-to-oxygen migration models. The paper is organized as follows. In Sect. II , the kinematics of quasi-elastic neutrino–nucleus scattering is reviewed and the general dependence of the cross section on the azimuthal angle of the outgoing nucleon is analyzed. In Sect. III , the nuclear models employed in this work are discussed, and their respective azimuthal angle dependencies are examined. The results of the present study and their implications for the validation of nuclear models are presented in Sect. IV . The feasibility of observing the predicted effects in current long-baseline neutrino experiments is assessed in Sect. V . Our conclusions are summarized in the final Sect. VI . II Theory II.1 Kinematics and cross section The kinematics used in our description of charged-current quasi-elastic neutrino-induced single-nucleon knockout off nuclei is shown in Fig. 1 . The definitions of the kinematic variables used in the following are the same as in Ref. Moreno et al. 2014 . An incoming neutrino with four-momentum k_{i}^{\mu}=(E_{i},\vec{k}_{i}) in the xz-plane scatters off a nucleus by exchanging a W^{\pm} boson along the z-axis with four-momentum Q^{\mu}=(\omega,\vec{q})=(\omega,0,0,q) . The four-momentum of the outgoing lepton is denoted by k_{f}^{\mu}=(E_{f},\vec{k}_{f}) . The momentum transfer \vec{q} is defined as \vec{q}=\vec{k}_{i}-\vec{k}_{f} . In exclusive CCQE scattering reactions, the interaction with the nucleus results in one detected emitted nucleon with four-momentum \displaystyle P_{N}^{\mu}=( \displaystyle E_{N},\vec{p}_{N}) \displaystyle=( \displaystyle E_{N},p_{N}\sin\theta_{N}\cos\phi_{N}, \displaystyle p_{N}\sin\theta_{N}\sin\phi_{N},p_{N}\cos\theta_{N}), (1) with \theta_{N} the angle of the outgoing nucleon’s momentum with the z-axis and \phi_{N} the angle between the scattering and reaction plane. The residual nucleus then has a four-momentum \displaystyle P_{A-1}^{\mu}=( \displaystyle E_{A-1},P_{A-1}\sin\theta_{A-1}\cos\phi_{A-1}, \displaystyle P_{A-1}\sin\theta_{A-1}\sin\phi_{A-1},P_{A-1}\cos\theta_{A-1}) (2) and is in general in an excited state. In the following, the laboratory frame is used as the frame of reference. In this frame, the initial nuclear complex is at rest, with four-momentum P_{A}^{\mu}=(M_{A},\vec{0}) in natural units, where M_{A} denotes the rest mass of the nucleus. Figure 1: Overview of the kinematics of quasi-elastic lepton-induced single-nucleon knockout from nuclei in the laboratory frame. In the Born approximation, the cross section can be written as a contraction of the lepton and hadron tensors. The lepton tensor is given by: \displaystyle L_{\mu\nu} \displaystyle=\overline{\sum_{i,f}}\big(\mathcal{J}_{\mu}^{lep}(q)\big)^{\dagger}\mathcal{J}_{\nu}^{lep}(q), (3) while the hadron tensor is defined as: \displaystyle W^{\mu\nu}(q)=\overline{\sum_{i,f}}\big(\mathcal{J}^{\mu}_{had}(q)\big)^{\dagger}\mathcal{J}^{\nu}_{had}(q). (4) In both formulas, \overline{\sum}_{i,f} denotes the sum and