Psychological Constructs in Shared Semantic Space

Hubert Plisiecki · 2026

Read Psychological Constructs in Shared Semantic Space by Hubert Plisiecki (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2605-26801.txt.

Introduction

In his 2026 paper, Plisiecki offers a way to compare psychological constructs, ideas often measured with separate tests and traditions, as directions in one shared word space. From text-outcome links, he derives a gradient for each construct and maps it onto fixed reference axes. His tests recover the valence, arousal, and dominance axes, place 27 GoEmotions groups sensibly, and map Big Five domains in a coherent way. Word spaces, he suggests, can thus support comparison across traditions that rarely share measures.

Catalog record

CREATORHubert Plisiecki
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE57327
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2605.26801

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Psychological Constructs in Shared Semantic Space Hubert Plisiecki Abstract Psychological constructs are often measured in separate instruments, datasets, and research traditions, which makes direct comparison difficult. This paper proposes a framework for making such constructs semantically commensurate by representing and comparing them as directions in a shared word-embedding space. Using Supervised Semantic Differential, we estimate construct-specific semantic gradients from text–outcome associations and project them onto theoretically motivated reference axes. As an initial test case, we use Valence, Arousal, and Dominance (VAD) as an affective coordinate system. First, we recover interpretable VAD directions from English word-level affective norms. Second, we project semantic gradients for 27 GoEmotions categories into this space and recover the expected organization of emotions, especially along valence and arousal. Third, we apply the same procedure to Big Five personality domains and facets derived from IPIP-NEO-300 item–factor associations. Domain-level placements are broadly coherent, while facet-level results are more exploratory because they rely on sparse questionnaire text. The results suggest that embedding spaces can support construct-level comparison across otherwise incommensurable psychological measurements, provided that semantic placements are assessed for stability and interpretability. 1 Introduction 1 1 1 Code repository: https://github.com/hplisiecki/construct_space Psychological science studies many phenomena that are intuitively related but empirically difficult to compare. Emotions, personality traits, attitudes, symptoms, values, and affective states are usually measured with separate instruments, developed in different research traditions, and scored on incommensurable scales. As a result, constructs that may be conceptually adjacent are often analyzed only within the boundaries of a single questionnaire, dataset, or theoretical framework. This limits our ability to ask broader questions about how psychological phenomena relate to one another: for example, whether a personality facet is semantically closer to anxiety, dominance, curiosity, or positive affect; or how constructs from different studies occupy a common space of human meaning. Distributional semantics offers a way to address this problem. Word embeddings provide a shared representational space in which words, texts, and semantic directions can be compared geometrically ( 13 ; 10 ) . Rather than treating embeddings only as predictive features, we use them here as a common semantic substrate for psychological measurement. The central idea is that constructs from different studies can be represented as directions in the same embedding space, making them jointly interpretable even when their original measurements come from different scales, corpora, or research traditions. We operationalize this idea using the Supervised Semantic Differential (SSD), a recent method inspired by psycholinguistic work on connotative meaning ( 16 ) that estimates supervised directions in embedding space from paired text representations and continuous outcome values ( 18 ) . Given document embeddings and an outcome variable, SSD fits a supervised linear model, back-projects the fitted coefficient vector into the original embedding space, and interprets the resulting direction through its nearest-neighbor structure. In the present paper, we extend SSD from single-construct interpretation to cross-construct comparison by estimating multiple construct-specific directions in the same embedding space and projecting them onto shared reference axes. As a first demonstration, we use affective meaning as the reference frame. Valence, Arousal, and Dominance (VAD) are among the best-validated dimensions of psychological meaning, with strong grounding in human ratings, affect theory, and distributional semantics ( 26 ; 24 ; 23 ) . We therefore estimate VAD directions in a fixed GloVe embedding space and use them as interpretable axes onto which other construct gradients can be projected. Importantly, the contribution is not limited to affect: VAD serves as a theoretically well-understood test case for the broader claim that embedding spaces can support shared semantic representations of psychological phenomena. We demonstrate the approach across three studies. Study 1 estimates the three affective reference directions from Warriner et al.’s English word-level VAD norms ( 26 ) , yielding unit vectors \hat{\boldsymbol{\beta}}_{V} , \hat{\boldsymbol{\beta}}_{A} , and \hat{\boldsymbol{\beta}}_{D} in GloVe space. Study 2 validates these reference directions by mapping 27 discrete emotion categories from the GoEmotions corpus ( 2 ) into the resulting VAD space and comparing the recovered organization with predictions from the circumplex model of affect ( 24 ) . Study 3 applies the same framework to personality measurement by deriving semantic gradients from item-level responses on the IPIP-NEO-300 Big Five inventory ( 5 ) and projecting all five domains and 30 facets into the affective reference space. 2 Related Work 2.1 Distributional Semantics as Shared Representational Geometry Word embeddings represent lexical meaning as points in a continuous vector space, making semantic relations accessible through distances, neighborhoods, and directions ( 13 ; 17 ) . Although developed primarily as representations for NLP systems, these spaces have also been used as analytic objects. Prior work has used embedding geometry to study semantic change ( 7 ) , historical shifts in gender and ethnic stereotypes ( 3 ) , and the relational structure of cultural concepts such as social class ( 10 ) . Related projection-based work has shown that linear directions in embedding space can recover human judgments of object features such as size, danger, and wetness ( 6 ) . These results suggest that embedding spaces can encode interpretable dimensions of social and psychological meaning. However, most existing work studies a single lexical contrast, cultural dimension, or historical trajectory. The unit of analysis is usually a word, dictionary, or predefined contrast. In this paper, the unit of analysis is a psychological construct. We ask whether constructs measured in different datasets can be represented as directions in a common embedding space and meaningfully compared within that shared geometry. This use case places different requirements on representations than standard prediction or retrieval. For construct-level measurement, the relevant properties are not only task accuracy, but whether the space supports stable linear directions, projection onto interpretable axes, and qualitative audit via nearest neighbors. This corresponds to the broader distinction between prediction-oriented and measurement-oriented meaning representations ( 19 ) . Static embeddings are useful here because they provide a fixed lexical coordinate system in which directions, projections, and local neighborhoods are directly inspectable. Contextual models may encode richer information, but their layer dependence and entanglement of semantic, syntactic, and surface-form signals make them less straightforward as substrates for the present linear measurement workflow. 2.2 Affective Meaning and the Semantic Differential The affective reference axes used in this paper are motivated by work on connotative meaning and dimensional theories of affect. The Semantic Differential represents word meaning through ratings on bipolar scales and showed that much of this variation can be summarized by a small set of dimensions, classically evaluation, potency, and activity ( 16 ) . These dimensions map onto how affect theories organize emotion and connotative meaning in terms of valence, arousal, and dominance ( 23 ; 24 ) . Valence captures the pleasant–unpleasant dimension of meaning; arousal captures activation level, ranging from calm to excited; and dominance captures perceived power or control, ranging from submissive to dominant. Large-scale affective norms provide human ratings of these dimensions for thousands of English lemmas ( 26 ) . We use Valence, Arousal, and Dominance (VAD) as reference axes because they are well validated, low-dimensional, and theoretically interpretable. The claim is not that VAD exhausts psychological meaning. Rather, VAD provides a controlled test case for the broader framework: if constructs can be represented as directions in

Read the complete text