Practical Entanglement Distillation Protocols with Quadratic Error Suppression

Elisa Bäumer Marty · 2026

Read Practical Entanglement Distillation Protocols with Quadratic Error Suppression by Elisa Bäumer Marty (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2605-26757.txt.

Introduction

Bäumer Marty's 2026 protocols distill entanglement for modular quantum computers, where links between modules are far noisier than operations inside a module. The main protocol needs only two qubits per module yet suppresses inter-module errors quadratically, meaning errors shrink with the square of the raw rate, assuming clean local operations. Simulations and tests on superconducting processors show it beats existing small-scale protocols in both space and time overhead.

Catalog record

CREATORElisa Bäumer Marty
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE35886
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2605.26757

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Practical Entanglement Distillation Protocols with Quadratic Error Suppression Elisa Bäumer Marty Abstract Near-term and early fault-tolerant quantum computing architectures are expected to exhibit highly non-uniform error rates. In particular, local operations within a chip can be substantially more reliable than operations connecting different chips or dilution refrigerators. Such inter-module operations can therefore become a dominant bottleneck, even when quantum error correction is applied. Entanglement distillation provides a natural way to trade additional operations and qubits for higher-fidelity entanglement. Standard distillation protocols, however, are usually formulated in an LOCC resource model, in which several noisy Bell pairs are generated initially and all subsequent processing consists only of local operations and classical communication. Here, we consider a generalized model tailored to modular quantum computing hardware, in which the two modules have access to high-fidelity local operations and to repeated uses of the same noisy inter-module entangling operation during the protocol. We develop practical small-scale entanglement distillation protocols designed to minimize both space and time overhead. Remarkably, our main protocol requires only two qubits per module, yet achieves quadratic error suppression of inter-module errors, assuming local operations are much cleaner. Compared with existing small-scale protocols, our space-optimal protocol provides more space- and time-efficient quadratic error suppression and achieves the best performance in our simulations and experiments on noisy links of current superconducting quantum processors. These results suggest that inter-module-gate-assisted entanglement distillation can be a practical primitive for overcoming noisy links in modular quantum computing architectures. I Introduction Over the past decade, substantial progress has been made toward scalable quantum computers, with increasing qubit numbers and physical error rates reduced by orders of magnitude. These advances have enabled demonstrations of quantum utility Kim et al. 2023 and motivated quantum-centric supercomputing architectures Robledo-Moreno et al. 2025 . However, error rates can vary substantially across different operations due to differences in coherence times, readout errors and gate fidelities. It becomes especially important in modular architectures with a limited number of qubits per dilution refrigerator, where operations connecting different chips or fridges are required. Such inter-module operations are expected to be significantly noisier than local operations, as is typical in modular or networked quantum computing proposals Nickerson et al. 2013 . Similar heterogeneity can also arise at the logical level. For example, QEC schemes that connect smaller code blocks may require inter-module measurements whose error rates are orders of magnitude larger than those of in-module measurements, as in proposals based on the Gross code Yoder et al. 2025 . More generally, connecting error-corrected qubits through noisy links is a central challenge for fault-tolerant interconnect schemes Ramette et al. 2024 . Entanglement distillation provides a natural way to address this bottleneck. The concept was introduced already 30 years ago Bennett et al. 1996a as a method for converting multiple noisy Bell pairs into fewer ones of higher fidelity. Entanglement distillation is closely related to quantum error correction Bennett et al. 1996b and is a key component of quantum repeater architectures for long-distance quantum communication Briegel et al. 1998 ; Dür et al. 1999 . However, the original protocol was primarily a proof-of-principle and thus not very efficient and more recent work has mostly focused on large-scale protocols that aim at optimizing asymptotic behavior Bennett et al. 1996b ; Devetak and Winter 2005 ; Pattison et al. 2024 ; Shi et al. 2025 , rather than practically-relevant small-scale protocols. In particular, most protocols would perform poorly in regimes where input error rates are already small, or require large space or time overheads, especially since the resources that were optimized were typically not space and time, but the number of input Bell pairs. These objectives are different from the requirements of near-term and early fault-tolerant quantum computing hardware, where the relevant resources are typically qubit count, circuit depth and wall-clock time. Here, we use a generalized resource model motivated by modular quantum computing hardware. Standard entanglement distillation protocols are usually formulated as LOCC protocols, in which several noisy Bell pairs are first distributed between two parties and the subsequent processing uses only local quantum operations, measurements and classical communication. In modular quantum processors, however, the same operation that creates a raw Bell pair may also be available as a noisy inter-module entangling gate during the protocol. We therefore allow repeated uses of this noisy inter-module operation, in addition to high-fidelity local operations, measurements and classical communication. While this setting differs from standard LOCC distillation, it captures the relevant cost tradeoff for architectures in which inter-module operations are expensive and noisy, while local operations are comparatively cheap and reliable. Within this setting, we introduce practical entanglement distillation protocols that minimize qubit overhead and are among the fastest protocols with quadratic suppression of inter-module errors, meaning that the leading-order contribution of the output error scales as \mathcal{O}(\varepsilon_{inter}^{2}) . Our main protocol requires as little as two qubits per module, which makes it space-optimal in the sense that no protocol producing a purified Bell pair while detecting inter-module faults can use fewer than two qubits per module: one qubit per module is needed to hold the output Bell pair, and an additional qubit per module is needed to extract error information. We refer to the noisier operations, such as noisy links within a chip, or long-range gates connecting multiple chips, as inter-module operations, and to the higher-fidelity operations as local operations. When inter-module error rates are orders of magnitude larger than local error rates, the proposed protocols can reduce the corresponding bottleneck and thus be advantageous for both near-term devices and fault-tolerant architectures. The key idea of our improved protocols is that inter-module operations can be used as active components for the distillation circuit, rather than only for preparing initial noisy Bell pairs. We start by introducing the noise model in Section II.1 , followed by an overview of existing protocols in Section II.2 . We then present our new protocols in Section II.3 and compare their error suppression rates, qubit numbers, and duration in Section II.4 . In Section III , we demonstrate their efficiency both with simulations for varying input errors as well as with experiments on noisy links on current devices. Finally, we conclude in Section IV . II Distillation Protocols and Analytical Comparison II.1 Noise model Arbitrary noise during an entangling gate can be described by a general CPTP map: \mathcal{E}(\rho)=\sum_{k}E_{k}\rho E_{k}^{\dagger} , where E_{k} are Kraus operators acting on two qubits. By applying Pauli twirling through randomized compiling Wallman and Emerson 2016 , the ensemble-averaged effective noise channel is transformed into a stochastic Pauli channel Dankert et al. 2009 , such that in the Pauli-basis representation the off-diagonal terms associated with coherent noise are averaged away, leaving only diagonal Pauli-error terms: \displaystyle\tilde{\mathcal{E}}(\rho)=\sum_{P\in\{I,X,Y,Z\}^{\otimes 2}}\varepsilon_{P}P\rho P\,, (1) with \sum_{P}\varepsilon_{P}=1 . This has 15 independent parameters, but for compact analytic expressions, we also consider a two-parameter weight-based Pauli error model in which all six single-qubit errors occur with probability \frac{\varepsilon_{1}}{6} , and all nine two-qubit correlated Pauli errors occur with probability \frac{\varepsilon_{2}}{9} . This simplification does not capture the full structure of general noise, but it can still be used to obtain conservative upper bounds by assigning all single-qubit (two-qubit) Pauli errors the maximal probability within their class. Denoting the maximum

Read the complete text