From supernovae to neutron stars: crust formation time

Yudai Suwa, Ken’ichiro Nakazato · 2026

Read From supernovae to neutron stars: crust formation time by Yudai Suwa, Ken’ichiro Nakazato (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2605-26692.txt.

Introduction

Yudai Suwa and Ken'ichiro Nakazato estimate when a newborn neutron star first grows a solid crust. A hot, lepton-rich protoneutron star cools by shedding neutrinos until heavy ions in its outer layers freeze. The pair use neutrino diffusion, entropy tracks, and a near-isentropic interior. They find when surface temperature first drops below the Coulomb freezing threshold at surface density. For standard physics the first solid appears roughly 100 to 500 seconds after birth, giving a handy late-time benchmark for crust onset.

Catalog record

CREATORYudai Suwa, Ken’ichiro Nakazato
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE24758
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2605.26692

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

From supernovae to neutron stars: crust formation time Yudai Suwa, Ken’ichiro Nakazato Abstract A neutron star is born as a hot, lepton-rich protoneutron star (PNS) and cools via neutrino emission, eventually allowing heavy ions in the outer layers to crystallize into a solid crust. We develop a simple analytic estimate for the onset time of this crust formation during the late, post-convective PNS cooling phase. Using a diffusion-based neutrino luminosity and the resulting entropy evolution together with an approximately isentropic interior structure, we obtain the time-dependent density and temperature at the neutrinosphere. We then impose the Coulomb crystallization condition for heavy nuclei, expressed through the Coulomb coupling parameter, and determine when the neutrinosphere temperature first falls below the crystallization threshold evaluated at the neutrinosphere density. This procedure yields closed expressions for the entropy at crystallization and the corresponding crust-formation time, with explicit dependence on the PNS mass and radius, an effective diffusion/cooling normalization, and composition parameters such as the ionic charge Z Z and heavy-nuclei mass fraction. For canonical microphysics, we find that the first solid phase typically appears at t crust ∼ 100 t_{\mathrm{crust}}\sim 100 – 500 ​ s 500\,\mathrm{s} . These closed-form scalings provide a useful late-time analytic benchmark for the onset of crust formation and clarify its dependence on PNS and composition parameters. 2026 \Received \Accepted \KeyWords dense matter — neutrinos — stars: neutron 1 Introduction Neutron stars (NSs) are born in core-collapse supernovae as hot, lepton-rich protoneutron stars (PNSs). In the first seconds after bounce, a PNS has temperatures of \sim 10^{10} – 10^{11}\ \mathrm{K} and cools predominantly by emitting neutrinos, which carry away a substantial fraction of the gravitational binding energy ( \sim 10^{53}\ \mathrm{erg} ) on a timescale of \sim 10 – 100\ \mathrm{s} ( Burrows & Lattimer 1986 ; Pons et al. 1999 ; Janka 2012 ; Nakazato et al. 2013 ; Suwa et al. 2019 ) . This early cooling and deleptonization phase sets the initial thermodynamic structure of the nascent NS and provides the physical conditions for the emergence of a solid crust. The formation of the crust is a key milestone in the transition from a fluid PNS to a “cold” NS. At sufficiently high temperature, ions behave as a strongly coupled plasma, and the stellar matter is effectively fluid-like in the sense that it cannot sustain elastic shear stresses. As the star cools, Coulomb interactions between ions eventually dominate over thermal agitation and drive crystallization into a Coulomb lattice ( Shapiro & Teukolsky 1983 ; Haensel et al. 2007 ; Chamel & Haensel 2008 ) . Once an elastic crust forms, it qualitatively changes several aspects of NS physics: it enables the storage of elastic strain, affects the coupling between the superfluid/superconducting interior and the magnetized exterior, and influences the subsequent evolution of the magnetic field and rotation (see Pons & Viganò 2019 for a review). For newborn NSs, the emergence of a solid crust may also provide a useful transition time for later magnetic-field evolution. Despite its importance, the crust-formation time is not a single universal value. It depends on the cooling history (governed mainly by neutrino transport and the PNS radius/mass evolution), and on the microphysics that determines the melting temperature of the ionic component (composition, charge number Z , and the Coulomb coupling at melting) ( Pons et al. 1999 ; Haensel et al. 2007 ; Chamel & Haensel 2008 ) . Fully self-consistent numerical simulations with neutrino radiation transport can follow the PNS evolution in detail ( Pons et al. 1999 ; Fischer et al. 2010 ; Hüdepohl et al. 2010 ; Suwa 2014 ; Nakazato et al. 2018 ) , but they are computationally expensive and not always suited for scanning broad parameter dependencies. For many applications, an analytic or semi-analytic estimate with explicit scaling relations is valuable: it clarifies which macroscopic parameters control the result and allows rapid exploration across plausible PNS configurations. In this paper, we present a simple analytic estimate for the crust-formation timescale during the late PNS cooling phase. Our approach combines (i) an analytic description of the neutrino luminosity and entropy evolution based on the diffusion approximation ( Suwa et al. 2021 ) , together with the approximately isentropic thermal structure found in the late cooling phase ( Suwa 2014 ; Nakazato et al. 2018 ) , which we interpret as a simplified post-convective PNS profile, 1 1 1 PNS convection enhances lepton and energy transport and can drive much of the PNS interior toward a nearly isentropic state within the first few seconds after bounce, with characteristic entropies of order s\sim 1 – 3\,k_{\rm B} per baryon depending on the EOS ( Roberts et al. 2012 ; Mirizzi et al. 2016 ; Nagakura et al. 2020 ; Pascal et al. 2022 ; Janka 2025 ; Rusakov et al. 2026 ) . We do not model convection explicitly. and (ii) the crystallization criterion for a Coulomb lattice expressed through the Coulomb coupling parameter ( Shapiro & Teukolsky 1983 ) . This yields the time-dependent trajectory of the PNS thermodynamic profile in the \rho – T plane, which we compare to the critical temperature for crystallization. Adopting representative nuclear composition parameters motivated by cold-catalyzed matter calculations ( Baym et al. 1971b ) and allowing for plausible variations in Z , we derive an explicit estimate of the epoch at which the PNS first satisfies the crust-formation condition near the neutrinosphere/outer layers. The resulting crust-formation time is typically of order \sim 10^{2}\ \mathrm{s} for canonical parameters, while exhibiting strong and explicit dependence on the PNS mass, radius, and the neutrino-cooling normalization. This paper is organized as follows. In Section 2 , we summarize the analytic description of neutrino cooling and the resulting entropy and temperature evolution. In Section 3 , we describe the crystallization condition and derive the crust-formation time by matching the PNS thermal trajectory to the critical line in the \rho – T plane. In Section 4 , we summarize our results and discuss their interpretation and limitations. 2 Neutrino cooling This section summarizes the analytic PNS cooling model that we use to obtain the time-dependent thermal trajectory in the \rho – T plane. We focus on the quasi-stationary late cooling phase, after convective mixing has helped flatten the entropy profile, and use a diffusion-based parametrization for the subsequent thermal evolution ( Suwa 2014 ; Nakazato et al. 2018 ) . For the purpose of a scaling estimate, we adopt the diffusion-based analytic solution developed by Suwa et al. 2021 . We note that the analytic formulae were calibrated against detailed cooling calculations mainly up to \sim several \times 10\ {\rm s} in Suwa et al. 2019 ; in this work we use them as an extrapolative parametrization to later times in order to derive explicit scaling relations for crust formation. The neutrino transport equation can be derived from the Boltzmann equation. State-of-the-art core-collapse supernova simulations solve the transport problem with minimal approximations (see, e.g., Janka 2012 ; Yamada et al. 2024 for reviews), but such calculations are computationally expensive for broad parameter surveys and long-term integrations. Here we therefore employ the diffusion approximation, which is appropriate in optically thick regions and provides simple analytic scaling relations. In the

Read the complete text