Function-Valued Causal Influence in Nonlinear Time Series

Valentina V. Kuskova, Dmitry Zaytsev, Michael Coppedge · 2026

Read Function-Valued Causal Influence in Nonlinear Time Series by Valentina V. Kuskova, Dmitry Zaytsev, Michael Coppedge (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2605-26408.txt.

Introduction

Valentina V. Kuskova, Dmitry Zaytsev, and Michael Coppedge argue that boiling each causal link to one number discards the real finding. Nonlinear models learn an effect that shifts with regime and size, so the trio formalize function-valued causal influence for additive, splittable designs. With Neural Additive Vector Autoregression, they estimate response curves via Individual Conditional Expectation plots. Synthetic trials show edges with matching scalar scores can rise, jump at a threshold, level off, or flip sign. A democratic-development study finds regime-specific patterns that score views miss.

Catalog record

CREATORValentina V. Kuskova, Dmitry Zaytsev, Michael Coppedge
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE79140
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2605.26408

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Function-Valued Causal Influence in Nonlinear Time Series Valentina V. Kuskova, Dmitry Zaytsev, Michael Coppedge Abstract Causal discovery in time series is increasingly performed using nonlinear machine-learning models, yet the resulting causal relationships are almost always summarized by scalar edge scores. We argue that this practice obscures the true object learned by nonlinear autoregressive models: a state-dependent function whose effect varies across regimes, magnitudes, and contexts. We formalize function-valued causal influence for additive, contribution-decomposable architectures and show that scalar causal scores constitute a severe information bottleneck, conflating between-state variation with within-state residual noise. Using Neural Additive Vector Autoregression as a representative architecture, we introduce a practical framework based on Individual Conditional Expectation for estimating causal response functions directly from trained models. Through controlled synthetic experiments, we demonstrate that edges with indistinguishable scalar scores can exhibit qualitatively different functional behaviors, including monotonic, thresholded, saturating, and sign-changing effects. An applied case study on democratic development further shows that function-valued analysis reveals regime-specific and asymmetric causal structure systematically missed by score-centric approaches. 1 Introduction Nonlinear causal discovery in time series has advanced rapidly in recent years, driven by flexible machine-learning models that learn rich, state-dependent representations of temporal dependence ( 6 ) . Neural autoregressive and additive architectures extend classical vector autoregression ( 16 ) by allowing causal relationships to vary across states of the system ( 5 ) , enabling the representation of threshold effects, saturation, asymmetry, and other nonlinear dynamics that are inaccessible to linear methods ( 4 ) . As a result, modern causal time-series models are capable of learning expressive, structured representations of directed temporal influence ( 26 ) . Despite these advances, the outputs of nonlinear causal discovery methods are almost universally reported in a highly compressed form ( 28 ) . Causal influence is typically summarized using scalar edge scores that quantify the strength or importance of directed relationships between variables ( 35 ) . These scores are convenient for ranking edges, thresholding graphs, and benchmarking performance ( 20 ) , and they mirror the role played by coefficients in linear vector autoregression ( 1 ) . However, this practice introduces a fundamental mismatch between the representations learned by nonlinear causal models and the summaries used to evaluate and interpret them. In nonlinear systems, causal influence cannot, in general, be represented by a single magnitude ( 37 ) . Nonlinear autoregressive models do not learn fixed effects or constant weights; instead, they learn state-dependent functions that map past system configurations to future outcomes ( 14 ) . Each directed relationship in such a model therefore corresponds not to a scalar quantity, but to a function-valued causal influence whose effect can vary across regimes, magnitudes, and contexts of the system ( 36 ) . Reducing these functions to scalar summaries collapses essential structure and can obscure threshold behavior, saturation, asymmetry, and sign changes that are intrinsic to nonlinear dynamics ( 37 ) . This representational collapse has important consequences for the adequacy of model outputs as summaries of learned causal structure, even when predictive accuracy is high. Scalar summaries average over regimes and interactions, masking where and how causal influence operates ( 32 ) . Two causal relationships with similar scalar scores may correspond to qualitatively different mechanisms, while strong but localized effects may appear indistinguishable from weak but globally active ones ( 31 ) . As a result, scalar causal scores provide, at best, a partial and potentially misleading picture of causal structure in nonlinear time series. To provide an example, consider two directed relationships in a democracy panel. Suppose a nonlinear model learns that civil liberties influence electoral quality, but only after a moderate institutional baseline is crossed, with no effect below that threshold. A second relationship captures the influence of judicial constraints on electoral quality through a monotonically linear effect of similar overall magnitude. Both edges receive comparable scalar causal scores of, e.g., approximately 0.15. Yet their policy implications are entirely different: the first implies a threshold below which interventions are unlikely to improve electoral outcomes; the second implies a uniform marginal return across all levels of judicial strength. Scalar summaries cannot communicate this distinction. Function-valued causal influence, as we formalize and estimate in this paper, recovers exactly this structure, and we demonstrate empirically in Section 5.2 that this scenario arises in real democratic panel data. The consequences of this mismatch are particularly salient in theory-driven domains, such as the social sciences, which serve as a stringent stress test for causal representations ( 33 ) . In these settings, causal priorities must be interpretable and defensible ( 19 ) in terms of mechanisms and regimes, not merely detected or ranked. Models that cannot explain how causality operates (e.g., when effects activate, saturate, or reverse), are rarely adopted in substantive research or policy analysis, regardless of predictive performance ( 13 ; 17 ) . Consequently, many nonlinear causal models remain underutilized ( 12 ) in precisely the domains where their expressive power would be most valuable. In this paper, we address this gap by reframing causal influence in nonlinear time-series models as a function-valued object rather than a scalar score. We formalize function-valued causal influence for a broad class of additive, contribution-decomposable autoregressive models, independent of a specific architecture, and show that commonly used scalar causal scores correspond to low-dimensional projections of these functions, constituting an information bottleneck. We then introduce a practical, intervention-style framework based on Individual Conditional Expectation (ICE) ( 18 ) for estimating causal response functions directly from trained models. Through controlled synthetic systems, we demonstrate that qualitatively distinct causal mechanisms can collapse to similar scalar summaries. We further show, using a panel dataset on democratic development, that function-valued analysis reveals regime-dependent causal behavior that is systematically invisible to scalar scores. 2 Background and Setup 2.1 Multivariate Time Series and Autoregressive Prediction We consider a multivariate time series \{X_{t}\}_{t=1}^{T} , where each observation x\in\mathbb{R}^{N} is a vector of N variables measured at time t . Let K\in\mathbb{N} denote a fixed lag window. Autoregressive models predict the current state X_{t} using its recent history X_{t-K:t-1}=\{X_{t-K},...,X_{t-1}\} thereby capturing temporal dependence through lagged inputs. An autoregressive predictor for the j -th variable takes the general form \hat{X}_{t}^{j}=f_{j}(X_{t-K:t-1}) , where f_{j}(\cdot) is an arbitrary, potentially nonlinear function. Throughout this paper, we focus on models trained to minimize a predictive loss (e.g., squared error). Under this setting, causal interpretation follows the standard Granger-style notion of predictive influence ( 42 ; 40 ) in which causality is defined operationally via improvements in prediction. 2.2 Directed Predictive Influence and Causal Edges In this framework, we define a directed edge i\rightarrow j to mean that the lagged history of variable i contributes to predicting variable j. Formally, an edge i\rightarrow j exists if the prediction function f_{j}(\cdot) depends on X_{t-K:t-1}^{(i)} in a way that improves predictive accuracy. This notion aligns with Granger causality ( 42 ; 40 ) : a variable is said to have a causal influence if its past helps predict another variable’s future beyond what is achievable using other variables alone. Importantly, this definition does not imply structural or interventional causality in the sense of causal graphs or counterfactual frameworks. Rather, it captures directed predictive influence in time series,

Read the complete text