Beyond the [O iii ]λ4363 auroral line: [Ne iii ]λ3868 as a direct tracer of electron temperature
Borja Pérez-Díaz, José M. Vílchez, Marco Castellano, Ricardo Amorín, Davide Bevacqua, Adriano Fontana, Giovanni Gandolfi, Antonio Giménez-Alcázar, Laura Pentericci, Enrique Pérez-Montero, Paola Santini, Roberta Tripodi · 2026
Read Beyond the [O iii ]λ4363 auroral line: [Ne iii ]λ3868 as a direct tracer of electron temperature by Borja Pérez-Díaz, José M. Vílchez, Marco Castellano, Ricardo Amorín, Davide Bevacqua, Adriano Fontana, Giovanni Gandolfi, Antonio Giménez-Alcázar, Laura Pentericci, Enrique Pérez-Montero, Paola Santini, Roberta Tripodi (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2605-25691.txt.
Introduction
Pérez-Díaz and colleagues offer a way to measure electron temperature where the classic [OIII] 4363 line is barely detectable. Their approach uses the [NeIII] 3868 line with [OIII] 4959 and 5007. Photoionization models link the O3Ne3 line ratio to temperature in the doubly ionized oxygen zone. Tested on galaxies from redshift zero to nine plus extragalactic HII regions, the ratio with an ionization tracer matches the classic line within uncertainties. The relation works in the cool regime from 6,000 to 13,500 K, where the classic line fades.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Borja Pérez-Díaz, José M. Vílchez, Marco Castellano, Ricardo Amorín, Davide Bevacqua, Adriano Fontana, Giovanni Gandolfi, Antonio Giménez-Alcázar, Laura Pentericci, Enrique Pérez-Montero, Paola Santini, Roberta Tripodi |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 43609 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2605.25691
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Beyond the [O iii ]λ4363 auroral line: [Ne iii ]λ3868 as a direct tracer of electron temperature Borja Pérez-Díaz, José M. Vílchez, Marco Castellano, Ricardo Amorín, Davide Bevacqua, Adriano Fontana, Giovanni Gandolfi, Antonio Giménez-Alcázar, Laura Pentericci, Enrique Pérez-Montero, Paola Santini, Roberta Tripodi Abstract Context. Auroral lines enable accurate measurements of chemical abundances in ionized gaseous nebulae thanks to their sensitivity to electron temperature. However, metal-enriched systems remain a challenge, as even deep observations cannot retrieve auroral lines due to their intrinsic faintness. Aims. To overcome this limitation, we present a novel approach to estimate electron temperatures in the conditions where the [O iii ]λ4363 auroral line is barely detectable ( T e < 11,000 T_{e}<11,000 K). This approach relies on the detection of [Ne iii ]λ3868 and [O iii ]λ4959,5007 , which are among the brightest rest-frame optical emission lines. Methods. By means of detailed photoionization models, we derive a tight relation between the O3Ne3 ≡ \equiv [O iii ]λ4959,5007 / [Ne iii ]λ3868 ratio and the electron temperature weighted in the O ++ dominated region. We test the validity of this relation in a large sample of galaxies that cover a wide range of redshifts z ∼ \sim 0-9 and extragalactic HII regions. Results. Our results show that the O3Ne3 ratio, in combination with the O3O2 ratio (tracer of ionization), yields electron temperature estimates consistent within the uncertainties with those based on [O iii ]λ4363 . The proposed relation can be used to estimate electron temperature in the cool (equivalently high-metal) regime [6,000, 13,500 K] where the emissivity of [O iii ]λ4363 drops drastically. 1 Introduction The chemical composition of the interstellar medium (ISM) contains the footprints of the different processes that govern galaxy evolution. The multiphase structure of the ISM -molecular, neutral and ionized gas- requires distinct and complex modeling approaches to infer the composition of each phase ( Cox 2005 ; Maiolino & Mannucci 2019 ; Schinnerer & Leroy 2024 , e.g.) . The ionized ISM is a proxy to understand the physical and chemical properties of the gas that feeds or has recently fed ongoing events of galaxies: young massive stars ( Kennicutt & Evans 2012 , e.g.) , asymptotic giant branch phases ( Guerrero et al. 2013 , e.g.) , supernovae events ( Hillier & Dessart 2019 , e.g.) or feeding of supermassive black holes in Active Galactic Nuclei ( Venturi et al. 2018 , e.g.) . The ionized ISM is characterized by a moderately-high temperature (T \sim 10 4 K), and is traced by prominent emission lines which carry out the bulk of the energy re-processed within the gas surrounding the ionizing source. The luminosity of a particular transition from a particular ion (Y i ) is given by F {}_{\lambda}\equiv n(Y^{i})\epsilon_{\lambda}(Y^{i},n_{e},T_{e}) , being n(Y^{i}) the density of the ion and \epsilon_{\lambda}(Y^{i},n_{e},T_{e}) the emissivity of the line. The latter depends on all parameters that characterize the physical conditions of the ISM (e.g. temperature T_{e} and density n_{e} ), and also on the nature of the transition (recombination or collisional excitation). The emissivities of recombination lines (RLs, e.g. Balmer lines) show little dependence on T_{e} and n_{e} conditions, and hence, the brightness of these lines is mainly driven by the abundance of the corresponding ions (being mainly H and He). On the contrary, as collisions are driven by the kinetic distribution of electrons, collisionally-excited lines (CELs, e.g. [O iii ]λ5007 , [Ne iii ]λ3868 , [N ii ]λ6584 ) are pumped by temperature conditions, with additional dependence on density conditions due to collisional de-excitation. Hence, even for metal ions (O, N, Ne, C), which are several orders of magnitude less abundant than H or He, these CELs are bright enough to be recovered. Inferring the ionic abundance of heavy metals from the observed metal CELs requires robust estimations of n_{e} and T e to fully constrain the associated emissivity of the transition from available sets of atomic data ( Luridiana et al. 2015 ; Peimbert et al. 2017 ; Pérez-Montero 2017 ) . n_{e} can be estimated from doublets of emission lines (transitions from two different, yet very close in energy, excited states) due to spin-coupling to the ground level, as the ratio between their emissivities depends mostly on density. Estimating T_{e} is more challenging, as it is related to the abundance of metals: the more metals are present within the ionized gas, the more coolants are available to disperse the energy, dropping the temperature. A very particular set of emission lines, associated to the transition from the second lowest to the first lowest excited states of the ions, can be used to infer T_{e} : the auroral lines. However, such emission lines are on the order of 1/20th (for metal-poor systems) to 1/1000th (for metal-rich systems) less bright than other CELs from the same ions. Hence, many alternative approaches, such as relying on photoionization models (e.g. HII-CHI-Mistry Pérez-Montero 2014 , NebulaBayes Thomas et al. 2018 , HOMERUN Marconi et al. 2024 ) or using strong-line calibrations tested on galaxies for which auroral lines are retrieved ( Curti et al. 2017 ; Sanders et al. 2024 ; Brazzini et al. 2024 , e.g.) , have been proposed in the literature. In this work we present a novel approach to infer electron density from [Ne iii ]λ3868 in metal-rich systems, where electron temperature is so low ( T_{e}\leq 1.1\cdot 10^{4} K) that auroral lines cannot be retrieved in large surveys or even with deep observations. In Sec. 2 we present the physical motivation for our methodology. In Sec. 3 we discuss and provide both model-relations to derive T_{e} from the [O iii ]λ4959,5007 / [Ne iii ]λ3868 ratio. We review in Sec. 4 the performance of the new estimator. Finally, in Sec. 5 we summarize the implications of this work. 2 Physical motivation The analysis presented in this section was done from the atomic databases listed in Table 1 (see Appendix A for more details). 2.1 The case of [O iii ]λ4363 The auroral line [O iii ]λ4363 is the main de-excitation mechanism for O ++ to transit from 1 S 0 (O ++ ) [5.3543 eV] to 1 D 2 (O ++ ) [2.5146 eV]. The 1 D 2 constitutes an intermediate excited state for O ++ , which de-excites with a higher probability to the 3 P 2 (O ++ ) [0.0380 eV], resulting in the prominent [O iii ]λ5007 emission line, followed by the transition to the 3 P 2 (O ++ ) [0.0140 eV] resulting in [O iii ]λ4959 . In the low density regime ( n_{e}<10^{5} cm -3 ), electrons collide with the ground base O ++ state, and if they have enough ( \sim 2.5 eV) energy, they excite them to the 1 D 2 level. In such conditions, more electrons can collide with the already excited ions, but they require more energy to excite them to the 1 S 0 state ( \sim 2.8 eV). Under the assumption of a Maxwellian distribution for electrons, higher temperatures imply a higher probability not only of having \sim 2.8 eV electrons, but also \sim 5.3 eV (direct excitation from the ground state to 1 S 0 ), so the [O iii ]λ4363