Reassessing high-energy emission correlations in gamma-ray bursts using a large, homogeneous sample of X-ray afterglows
A. A. Vigliano, F. Longo, Ž. Bošnjak · 2026
Read Reassessing high-energy emission correlations in gamma-ray bursts using a large, homogeneous sample of X-ray afterglows by A. A. Vigliano, F. Longo, Ž. Bošnjak (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2605-25644.txt.
Introduction
Vigliano, Longo and Bošnjak revisit claimed links between high-energy detection in gamma-ray bursts and the shapes of their X-ray afterglows. Earlier claims rested on small or mixed samples. They analyze the full Swift-XRT catalog of more than 1400 events with one uniform, model-free pipeline. They find that both afterglow complexity and plateaus track the observation start time. Once that timing is accounted for, the apparent links to high-energy emission vanish, showing early X-ray shape does not predict high-energy detection.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | A. A. Vigliano, F. Longo, Ž. Bošnjak |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 47367 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2605.25644
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Reassessing high-energy emission correlations in gamma-ray bursts using a large, homogeneous sample of X-ray afterglows A. A. Vigliano, F. Longo, Ž. Bošnjak Abstract Context. Gamma-ray bursts (GRBs) exhibit diverse X-ray afterglow light-curves, including breaks and plateau phases, whose physical origins remain debated. Previous studies have often relied on small and heterogeneous samples, which limited their statistical power and led to apparently conflicting claims. Most notably, correlations have been suggested between high-energy ( E ≥ 100 E\geq 100 MeV) detection and X-ray afterglow complexity or plateau incidence. Aims. We performed a comprehensive large-scale and unbiased statistical analysis of GRB X-ray afterglows to clarify the origins of light-curve complexity and plateau phases, and to reassess their possible connection with high-energy emission. Methods. We developed a fully automated, model-independent analysis of the complete Swift -XRT GRB afterglow catalog, comprising more than 1400 events. Our pipeline applies uniform flare removal and segmented power-law fitting, enabling consistent measurements throughout the entire sample and robust statistical inference. Results. We found that both light-curve complexity and plateau incidence are strongly governed by the data-taking starting time of XRT observations ( t X R T t_{XRT} ). When t X R T t_{XRT} is ignored, apparent correlations emerge between high-energy emission and X-ray afterglow morphology, but when the data are stratified or controlled for t X R T t_{XRT} , these associations vanish. X-ray complexity and plateaus are therefore not directly coupled to high-energy detectability, indicating that early X-ray morphological features are not predictive of high-energy emission. Conclusions. Our results resolve long-standing claims in the literature and highlight a crucial methodological lesson: controlling for t X R T t_{XRT} is indispensable in large-sample studies of GRBs. The automated analysis pipeline provides a foundation for reproducible, large-sample inferences and will be essential for exploiting upcoming datasets from missions such as SVOM, Einstein Probe and THESEUS. 1 Introduction Gamma-ray bursts (GRBs) are among the most powerful cosmic explosions. They produce prompt and afterglow emissions that span the entire electromagnetic spectrum (see 24 for a recent review). The X-ray afterglow phase, in particular, displays a rich phenomenology: steep early decays, plateau phases, flares, and late-time breaks. Although a general canonical shape has been proposed ( 21 ; 25 ; 28 ) , individual light-curves often diverge significantly, and the physical origins of several features, such as plateaus and flares, remain a matter of debate. The standard interpretation of the X-ray afterglow is based on the external shock model, in which the forward shock produced by the relativistic ejecta interacting with the circumburst medium gives rise to the broadband synchrotron emission that dominates at late times. However, observations from the Neil Gehrels Swift Observatory X-ray Telescope ( Swift -XRT) have revealed early-time (within about a few hundred to a few thousand seconds after the GRB trigger) features such as steep decays, plateaus, and flares that deviate from the expectations of a simple external-shock scenario ( 21 ; 22 ; 28 ) . These features require additional physical ingredients, including long-lasting central-engine activity ( 17 ) , long-lived reverse shocks, or structured jets viewed off-axis. In particular, plateau phases have been modeled as manifestations of late energy injection or magnetar spin-down processes, while flares are generally attributed to episodic central-engine activity ( 22 ; 28 ; 17 ) . The most frequently discussed signatures include plateau phases, also referred to as shallow decay phases, and light-curve complexity. Both have been suggested as important diagnostics of central engine emissions and jet structure. These might be used as possible markers of connections to high-energy (HE, E\geq 100 MeV) and very high-energy (VHE, E\geq 100 GeV) emission detected by instruments such as the Fermi Gamma-ray Space Telescope Large Area Telescope ( Fermi -LAT) and ground-based Cherenkov telescopes. Recently, some studies have reported that GRBs with HE photons tend to show less complex X-ray afterglows or are less likely to display plateaus (e.g. 26 ; 10 ). If this were confirmed, these correlations would have important implications for the interplay between internal- and external-shock processes in GRBs and for theoretical models of HE and VHE emission (e.g. 20 ; 4 ). A correlation might indicate a common underlying geometric origin for these features, such as a shared dependence on jet-opening angle, viewing angle, or jet structure. The presence of plateaus (e.g. 5 ) and the detection of HE emission (e.g. 7 ) have both been proposed in the literature to depend on such geometric parameters. However, GRB afterglow studies have historically faced two limitations. First, most analyses were based on relatively small samples (typically 60–80 GRBs; e.g. 9 ), which limits statistical power and comparability. Second, the lack of uniform analysis procedures (in particular, the fitting of light-curves and the identification of features such as flares and plateaus) makes it difficult to establish whether the reported differences reflect astrophysical trends or methodological choices. A further challenge lies in the role of the data-taking starting time t_{XRT} , which is defined as the elapsed time between the GRB trigger time and the moment Swift -XRT started taking data for it. Because earlier t_{XRT} values naturally encompass a wider temporal baseline, they can artificially increase the measured complexity and alter the detectability of plateaus. If this is not accounted for, t_{XRT} can act as a hidden confounder in correlations between afterglow features and HE emission. To overcome these issues, we developed a fully automated, model-independent pipeline for the systematic analysis of X-ray afterglow light-curves. The pipeline applies a uniform flare removal and segmented linear regression in log–log space, yielding reproducible measurements of breakpoints, plateaus, and other temporal properties for the entire Swift -XRT catalog. Applied to 1438 GRBs observed between December 2004 and December 2025, this represents by far the largest homogeneous study of X-ray afterglows to date. The scale and uniformity of the analysis enable us for the first time to apply rigorous statistical tests to assess the proposed correlations with HE emission. We focus on two relations that have been suggested in the literature: (i) between HE emission and X-ray afterglow complexity, and (ii) between HE emission and X-ray plateau phases. We show that these two apparent associations are in fact driven by the distribution of t_{XRT} . When this is controlled for, neither complexity nor plateau incidence shows a significant link with HE emission. This result is consistent with scenarios in which the processes shaping early X-ray morphology do not strongly regulate HE emission detectability, and it demonstrates the importance of incorporating t_{XRT} control in all future large-sample studies. The remainder of this paper is organized as follows. In Section 2 , we describe the dataset, and in Section 3 we describe the automated analysis pipeline. Section 4 presents the results for complexity and plateaus, with and without t_{XRT} control. In Section 5 , we interpret the findings in the context of GRB emission models, and Section 6 summarizes our main conclusions and implications for future work. 2 Sample of GRBs The analysis we present is based on the complete set of X-ray afterglows observed by Swift -XRT from December 2004 to December 2025. Over this period, XRT followed up 1565 GRBs and produced the most extensive and