Strategic Non-Shareability of Quantum Correlations
Fumin Wang · 2026
Read Strategic Non-Shareability of Quantum Correlations by Fumin Wang (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2605-25516.txt.
Introduction
Fumin Wang treats quantum correlations as a resource that a mediator shares but a colluder must not inherit. Symmetrically extendible sources are free, shareability-preserving maps are free operations, and distance to the free set gives a faithful convex measure. For Werner and isotropic sources the resource takes an exact threshold form, and for qubit Werner sources Pauli measurements yield an exact one-colluder capacity. Strikingly, Bell nonlocality does not order collusion resistance the same way, so some Bell-nonlocal states resist collusion less than Bell-local ones.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Fumin Wang |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 73658 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2605.25516
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Strategic Non-Shareability of Quantum Correlations Fumin Wang Abstract Correlations distributed by a mediator are usually valued for the coordination they enable between authorized agents, but in adversarial settings a more decisive property is whether the same coordination can be inherited by an outside colluder without disturbing the authorized marginal. Classical shared randomness is freely copyable, so a hidden seed coordinating two agents can be duplicated for a third; entanglement is constrained by monogamy, which can forbid such lossless extensions in strongly nonlocal regimes. We turn this asymmetry into an operational resource for private-information games. For a fixed authorized behavior P 12 P_{12} , we define its collusive shadow as the set of relabelled behaviors a colluder can reproduce in any admissible tripartite extension preserving P 12 P_{12} , and we identify strategic non-shareability with the distance from this shadow. We prove that, on finite alphabets, the game-optimized anti-collusion capacity equals the total-variation distance to the shadow; a fixed game provides a task-specific separating witness, while optimization over relabelled games recovers the full distance. In the CHSH score slice, Toner–Verstraete monogamy yields the exact certified frontier Γ CHSH + ( S 12 ) = [ S 12 − 8 − S 12 2 8 ] + , \Gamma_{\rm CHSH}^{+}(S_{12})=\left[\frac{S_{12}-\sqrt{8-S_{12}^{2}}}{8}\right]_{+}, so the Bell local bound S 12 = 2 S_{12}=2 is the sharp onset of positive certified anti-collusion power, saturating at 1 / ( 2 2 ) 1/(2\sqrt{2}) for the maximally entangled CHSH strategy. Classical hidden-variable mediators have zero capacity in this slice. We complement these results with two operational tools: a Hoeffding-based finite-data certification protocol that turns observed Bell scores into confidence-bounded anti-collusion certificates, and a level-2 NPA semidefinite relaxation that extends certified upper envelopes to tilted Bell inequalities. These results recast entanglement monogamy as a measurable shareability deficit for quantum-mediated strategic networks. keywords entanglement monogamy, quantum mediation, private-information games, collusion resistance, nonlocality, anti-collusion power, shareability deficit 1 Introduction Quantum entanglement and Bell nonlocality have evolved from foundational curiosities into indispensable resources for quantum information processing Bell1964 ; CHSH1969 ; Tsirelson1980 ; Brunner2014 ; Horodecki2009 . Device-independent quantum cryptography, in particular, leverages Bell-inequality violations to guarantee security without trusting the internal workings of devices Ekert1991 ; Acin2007 ; Barrett2005 ; Pironio2009 ; Masanes2011 ; ArnonFriedman2018 ; Portmann2022 . Recent breakthrough experiments have demonstrated device-independent quantum key distribution (DI-QKD) over increasingly long distances Nadlinger2022 ; Zhang2022 ; Liu2022 ; Zapatero2023 , underscoring the transition from theory to practical quantum networks Wehner2018 ; Tavakoli2022 . In these protocols, the security against an eavesdropper is fundamentally rooted in the monogamy of Bell correlations—the same strong nonlocal correlation cannot be shared with a third party Toner2006 ; Terhal2004 ; Coffman2000 ; Osborne2006 ; Scarani2001 . Beyond cryptography, quantum correlations also serve as mediators in strategic games with private information, where they can enlarge the set of achievable correlated equilibria beyond classical limits Aumann1974 ; Cleve2004 . Classical mediators rely on shared randomness, which is freely copyable and therefore inherently vulnerable to collusion: every authorized correlation can be duplicated for a colluder without loss. Quantum mediators, by contrast, are constrained by the no-cloning theorem and entanglement monogamy Horodecki2009 ; Werner1989 . These physical restrictions suggest that quantum coordination carries a built-in defense against unauthorized extension. Yet, a rigorous operational framework that quantifies this defense—and certifies it from observed data—has been missing. Certification of quantum correlations relies on semidefinite programming relaxations NPA2007 ; NPA2008 ; DPS2002 ; DPS2004 , self-testing inequalities Kaniewski2016 ; Yang2013 ; Acin2012 ; Bamps2015 , and information-theoretic distinguishability measures Uhlmann1976 ; Fuchs1999 , while finite-data security proofs employ entropy accumulation Dupuis2020 ; ArnonFriedman2018 and randomness extraction Pironio2010 . The central gap addressed here is the absence of a unified language that connects these tools to the strategic problem of collusion resistance. We close this gap by shifting attention from correlation strength to correlation extendibility . In adversarial settings, the decisive question is not how well a mediator coordinates authorized agents, but whether the same coordination can be inherited by a colluder without disturbing the authorized marginal. We call the obstruction to such inheritance strategic non-shareability : the inability of a useful authorized correlation to be reproduced in any admissible collusive extension. The central geometric object is the collusive shadow —the set of all relabelled behaviors that a colluder can cast with an authorized party while preserving the observed marginal (Fig. 1 ). Distance from this shadow measures the operational shareability deficit and directly bounds the optimal anti-collusion advantage. Our contributions are fivefold. First, we formalize the collusive shadow for classical, no-signalling, and quantum extension classes, including fixed-dimensional and closed quantum sets. Second, we prove that—under standard finite-alphabet compactness assumptions—the game-optimized anti-collusion capacity equals the total-variation distance from the collusive shadow (Theorem 2 ). Third, we solve the Clauser-Horne-Shimony-Holt (CHSH) score-certified frontier exactly, \Gamma_{\rm CHSH}^{+}(S_{12})=\Bigl[\frac{S_{12}-\sqrt{8-S_{12}^{2}}}{8}\Bigr]_{+}, and identify the Bell local bound S_{12}=2 as the sharp onset of certifiable strategic non-shareability (Theorem 6 ). The maximal quantum separation 1/(2\sqrt{2}) at Tsirelson’s bound is attained by maximally entangled states via exact monogamy (Theorem 7 ). Fourth, we provide a finite-data certification protocol based on Hoeffding concentration, enabling experimenters to certify a positive shareability deficit from observed Bell scores at prescribed confidence levels (Section 2.5 , Fig. 3 ). Fifth, we extend the framework beyond analytically solvable CHSH frontiers by formulating an NPA semidefinite relaxation for general collusive vulnerability and demonstrating certified upper envelopes for tilted CHSH inequalities (Section 2.6 , Fig. 4 ). These results recast entanglement monogamy not merely as a static structural property, but as a dynamic, game-weighted resource for strategic networks. They bridge quantum foundations—Bell nonlocality, monogamy, and device-independent certification—with the operational needs of quantum-mediated games and quantum-internet architectures. 2 Results 2.1 Strategic non-shareability of mediated correlations We consider three agents. Players 1 and 2 form the authorized pair, and player 3 is a potential colluder. Each player i receives a private type t_{i}\in\mathcal{T}_{i} and produces an action x_{i}\in\mathcal{X}_{i} . After receiving types, players cannot communicate. A mediator supplies local recommendations, which may be classical or quantum. A classical mediator is a local hidden-variable device, P_{12}(x_{1},x_{2}|t_{1},t_{2})=\sum_{\lambda}p(\lambda)p_{1}(x_{1}|t_{1},\lambda)p_{2}(x_{2}|t_{2},\lambda), (1) and a quantum mediator uses a bipartite state and local POVMs, P_{12}(x_{1},x_{2}|t_{1},t_{2})=\Tr\!\left[\rho_{12}\left(E^{(1)}_{t_{1},x_{1}}\otimes E^{(2)}_{t_{2},x_{2}}\right)\right]. (2) The mediator is required to be no-signalling: for every subset S\subseteq\{1,2,3\} , P(x_{S}|t_{1},t_{2},t_{3})=P(x_{S}|t_{S}). (3) This condition rules out explanations based on hidden communication. A collusive extension is a tripartite distribution satisfying \sum_{x_{3}}P_{123}(x_{1},x_{2},x_{3}|t_{1},t_{2},t_{3})=P_{12}(x_{1},x_{2}|t_{1},t_{2}). (4) The physical question is whether such an extension can preserve the authorized marginal while also giving the colluder a high score with player 1. For an authorized behavior P_{12} , we define the collusive extension set under resource class \mathsf{R}\in\{\mathsf{C},\mathsf{NS},\mathsf{Q}_{\rm fin},\mathsf{Q}_{\leq d},\mathsf{Q}_{\rm cl},\mathsf{Q}_{\rm co}\} as {\rm Ext}_{\mathsf{R}}(P_{12})=\left\{P_{123}\in\mathsf{R}:\sum_{x_{3}}P_{123}(\cdot,\cdot,x_{3}|\cdot,\cdot,\cdot)=P_{12}\right\}, (5) where \mathsf{C} denotes classical hidden-variable extensions, \mathsf{NS} general no-signalling extensions, \mathsf{Q}_{\rm fin} finite-dimensional quantum extensions, \mathsf{Q}_{\leq d} fixed-dimensional quantum extensions with local Hilbert-space dimension bounded by d , \mathsf{Q}_{\rm cl}:=\overline{\mathsf{Q}_{\rm fin}} the closure of the finite-dimensional quantum set, and \mathsf{Q}_{\rm co} the commuting-operator model associated with the NPA limit. Unless closure issues are relevant, we use “quantum extension” informally; the precise closed classes are specified in theorems that require compactness. Definition 1 (Collusive shadow) . Let \Pi_{13\to 12} denote the relabelling map that identifies player 3’s type and action