On some open problems in commutative algebra resolved by Rethlas

Jiedong Jiang, Yixiao Li, Zeming Sun, Yuefeng Wang, Liang Xiao, and Jiahong Yu · 2026

Read On some open problems in commutative algebra resolved by Rethlas by Jiedong Jiang, Yixiao Li, Zeming Sun, Yuefeng Wang, Liang Xiao, and Jiahong Yu (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2605-25259.txt.

Introduction

Jiedong Jiang and colleagues report open problems in commutative algebra. A natural-language reasoning system called Rethlas has settled them, either by proof or by disproof. The problems are drawn from published lists on commutative ring theory and Boij-Söderberg theory. Each item gets its exact statement plus a self-contained proof produced by Rethlas with no human intervention. Human experts then checked every machine proof, closing problems that had resisted manual attack.

Catalog record

CREATORJiedong Jiang, Yixiao Li, Zeming Sun, Yuefeng Wang, Liang Xiao, and Jiahong Yu
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE45120
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2605.25259

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

On some open problems in commutative algebra resolved by Rethlas Jiedong Jiang, Yixiao Li, Zeming Sun, Yuefeng Wang, Liang Xiao, and Jiahong Yu Abstract . We report on a collection of open problems in commutative algebra and related areas that have been resolved (proved or disproved) using the Rethlas natural-language automated reasoning system. The problems are drawn from several published lists, including Open Problems in Commutative Ring Theory (Cahen–Fontana–Frisch–Glaz), Erman–Sam’s survey of Boij–Söderberg theory. For each problem we record the precise statement and a self-contained proof produced (with no human intervention) by Rethlas and subsequently verified by human experts. 2020 Mathematics Subject Classification 13C15, 13D02, 13F05, 13F20, 13J10, 17B55, 05E40 1. Introduction This paper records solutions to a collection of open problems in commutative algebra and related areas. The problems are drawn from two sources: the volume Open Problems in Commutative Ring Theory edited by Cahen, Fontana, Frisch and Glaz [ 4 ] , and the survey of Boij–Söderberg theory by Erman and Sam [ 9 ] . All proofs were generated by the Rethlas automated reasoning system [ 14 ] 1 1 1 The raw output of Rethlas is available at Rethlas results homepage . and subsequently verified by human experts. We summarize the results below, organized by mathematical subject. Two of the problems concern the behaviour of GCD-like ring conditions under group-ring constructions. Glaz [ 11 , 12 ] studied the notations of G-GCD rings and finite conductor rings, extending the classical theory of GCD domains. Problems 2.1 and 2.2 ask whether the finite conductor and quasi coherent properties ascend from a G-GCD ring R to the group ring RG for a finitely generated abelian group G . Both answers are negative, via counterexamples built from Glaz’s non-coherent UFD of characteristic 2 in [ 11 ] . Closely related is Problem 2.5 , which asks whether an almost GCD (AGCD) domain in which every nonzero t -locally principal ideal is t -invertible must be of finite t -character. Unlike Problems 2.1 and 2.2 , the answer here is affirmative, proved using results of Zafrullah on t -invertibility [ 15 , 16 ] . Problem 2.3 belongs to the theory of completions of Noetherian local rings. Anderson [ 1 ] proved that a ring is quasi-complete if and only if every homomorphic image is weakly quasi-complete, and asked whether the two properties actually coincide. We construct a counterexample, thereby answering the question in the negative. This proof was later auto-formalized in Lean 4 by the Archon system and is thus formally machine-checked; see [ 14 ] . Problem 2.4 concerns the algebraic structure of rings of integer-valued polynomials, see [ 3 ] for background on \operatorname{Int}(D) . Elliott [ 8 ] showed that \operatorname{Int}(D) admits a D - D -biring structure compatible with D[X]\hookrightarrow\operatorname{Int}(D) if and only if the canonical maps \operatorname{Int}(D)^{\otimes_{D}n}\to\operatorname{Int}(D^{n}) are isomorphisms for all n . Problem 2.4 asks whether such a biring structure always exists. We show it does not by providing a counterexample. Problem 2.6 asks whether David’s 3 -dimensional non-Noetherian factorial domain J [ 5 ] is locally Jaffard. Dobbs, Fontana, and Kabbaj [ 6 ] showed that J is Jaffard, but the locally Jaffard property does not follow formally from this. We give an affirmative proof showing that J is indeed locally Jaffard. Finally, we address two questions on Boij–Söderberg theory [ 2 , 7 ] . A natural problem in this theory is to determine which integral points on a pure ray of the Boij–Söderberg cone are realizable as Betti table of some module. Question 2.7 asks whether every such point (in codimension 3 ) is realized over either S=k[x,y,z] or the enveloping algebra of the Heisenberg Lie algebra; Question 2.8 asks the analogous question for arbitrary finite-dimensional positively graded Lie algebras generated in degree 1 . Both answers are negative, via constructing explicit degree sequences whose primitive integral points cannot be realized. Acknowledgements The authors would like to thank Shiji Lyu for verifying the proof of Anderson’s open problem. They also thank Haocheng Ju, Shurui Liu, Guoxiong Gao, Leheng Chen, Bin Wu and Bin Dong for their contributions to the Rethlas project [ 14 ] . This work is supported in part by the National Key R&D Program of China grant 2024YFA1014000, the Fundamental and Interdisciplinary Disciplines Breakthrough Plan of the Ministry of Education of China (JYB2025XDXM113), and the New Cornerstone Investigator Program. 2. Statements of resolved problems We list below the open problems resolved by Rethlas, organised by source. The corresponding proofs appear in Section 3 . 2.1. Problems from Open Problems in Commutative Ring Theory The reference is the volume Open Problems in Commutative Ring Theory edited by Cahen, Fontana, Frisch and Glaz [ 4 ] . We retain the problem numbering of loc. cit. Problem 2.1 (Problem 4a(i) of [ 4 ] ) . A ring R is a finite conductor ring if aR\cap bR and (0:c) are finitely generated ideals of R for all a,b,c\in R , and a G-GCD ring if principal ideals of R are projective and the intersection of two finitely generated flat ideals is a finitely generated flat ideal. Assume that R is a G-GCD ring and G is a finitely generated abelian group. Does the finite conductor property ascend from R to the group ring RG ? Problem 2.2 (Problem 4a(ii) of [ 4 ] ) . A ring R is a quasi coherent ring if a_{1}R\cap\cdots\cap a_{n}R and (0:c) are finitely generated ideals of R for all a_{1},\dots,a_{n},c\in R , and a G-GCD ring if principal ideals of R are projective and the intersection of two finitely generated flat ideals is a finitely generated flat ideal. Assume that R is a G-GCD ring and G is a finitely generated abelian group. Does the quasi coherent property ascend from R to the group ring RG ? Problem 2.3 (Problem 8a of [ 4 ] (Anderson’s conjecture)) . Let (R,\mathfrak{m}) be a Noetherian local ring. R is said to be quasi-complete if for every decreasing sequence \{I_{n}\}_{n=1}^{\infty} of ideals of R and every natural number k , there exists s_{k} with I_{s_{k}}\subseteq\bigl(\bigcap_{n=1}^{\infty}I_{n}\bigr)+\mathfrak{m}^{k} ; if this condition is required only for sequences with \bigcap_{n}I_{n}=(0) , then R is called weakly quasi-complete . It is known that R is quasi-complete if and only if each homomorphic image of R is weakly quasi-complete [ 1 ] . Prove that there exists a weakly quasi-complete ring that is not quasi-complete. Problem 2.4 (Problem 21 of [ 4 ] ) . For an integral domain D with field of fractions K , let \operatorname{Int}(D):=\{f\in K[X]\mid f(D)\subseteq D\} denote the ring of integer-valued polynomials on D . By [ 8 ] the existence of a D - D -biring structure on \operatorname{Int}(D) such that D[X]\to\operatorname{Int}(D) is a biring homomorphism is equivalent to the canonical maps \operatorname{Int}(D)^{\otimes_{D}n}\to\operatorname{Int}(D^{n}) being isomorphisms for all n . Does \operatorname{Int}(D) always admit a unique D - D -biring structure such that D[X]\to\operatorname{Int}(D) is a homomorphism of D - D -birings? Problem 2.5 (Problem 35 of [ 4 ] ) . An integral domain D is an almost GCD (AGCD) domain if for every pair x,y\in D\setminus\{0\} there is an integer n=n(x,y)\geq 1 with x^{n}D\cap y^{n}D

Read the complete text