A Symmetry-First Elementary Derivation of the Lorentz Transformation

Tan Nianjun [email protected] · 2026

Read A Symmetry-First Elementary Derivation of the Lorentz Transformation by Tan Nianjun [email protected] (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2605-25159.txt.

Introduction

Nianjun Tan derives the Lorentz transformation from symmetry alone, without taking the speed of light as given at the start. Homogeneity of spacetime gives additivity, and continuity along free paths gives linearity. Isotropy plus the commutativity of same-line boosts gives the reciprocity rule. Those steps leave a one-parameter family of such maps, and identifying the invariant speed with light in vacuum picks the real branch, fixing the constant and recovering the known form.

Catalog record

CREATORTan Nianjun [email protected]
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE41327
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2605.25159

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

A Symmetry-First Elementary Derivation of the Lorentz Transformation Tan Nianjun [email protected] Abstract Abstract: We present an elementary, symmetry-first derivation of the Lorentz transformation together with a methodological clarification of the linearity step. Starting from the Principle of Relativity, supplemented by spacetime homogeneity, isotropy, continuity in the event coordinates, and the absence of a distinguished inertial frame, we first establish linearity and then determine the general symmetry-constrained form of inertial-frame transformations. The inverse transformation is written with parameter -v , not as a separate technical theorem, but as the physically natural expression of the equivalence of inertial frames in the standard configuration. Transformation consistency is used in stages: its identity-and-inverse part constrains the remaining coefficients, while its composition part leads to a one-parameter family of inertial-frame transformations characterized by a universal constant R . The light postulate is introduced only in the final step, where it selects the physically relevant branch by fixing R=-c^{2} , thereby recovering the Lorentz transformation and identifying c as maximal. The derivation is explicitly expository, making transparent several steps often compressed in standard treatments, especially the derivation of linearity, the elimination of transverse cross-terms, and the algebraic determination of the relative-velocity composition law. A central methodological point is that once homogeneity has reduced the problem to an additive transformation law, continuity, differentiability, and boundedness are equivalent regularity routes to the same linear class of inertial-frame transformations. In the present approach, only continuity in the event coordinates is assumed, while continuity in the velocity parameter emerges a posteriori from the explicit coefficient formulas. Keywords: Special Relativity; Lorentz Transformation; Elementary Derivation; Symmetry; Pedagogy; Undergraduate Education; Principle of Relativity 1. Introduction and Literature Review The Lorentz transformation, the mathematical cornerstone of special relativity, has been derived in many ways, depending on which postulates are taken as primitive and which mathematical tools are used. The aim here is modest: not to propose a new kinematics, but to give a symmetry-first derivation that remains at an elementary level while making explicit several steps often compressed in standard presentations. A second aim is to clarify a methodological point often left implicit in such derivations, namely the equivalence of the standard regularity routes from additivity to linearity once spacetime homogeneity has been imposed. Einstein’s original derivation starts from the Principle of Relativity and the constancy of the speed of light together [1]. A different line of thought was opened by Ignatowski, who showed that the general transformation law can be derived from relativity, homogeneity, and isotropy without initially assuming invariance of the speed of light [2]. This symmetry-first tradition was later developed along several lines. For the present paper, Berzi and Gorini are especially relevant because they make precise how spacetime homogeneity leads to an additive functional equation and how a weak regularity condition excludes pathological solutions [3]. Lévy-Leblond emphasized the group-theoretic structure [4], Pal gave a compact algebraic derivation [5], and Gannett showed that boundedness conditions can replace stronger smoothness assumptions in the passage from additivity to linearity [6]. Moylan [7] later revisited the status of velocity reciprocity. We use that discussion only in a limited sense: it helps clarify why later authors isolated reciprocity as a separate technical issue, but we do not adopt the view that the physical content of the relativity principle is best represented by allowing the same relative motion to receive unequal speed magnitudes in the two reciprocal descriptions. More recent papers have returned to the explicit derivation of linearity [8] and to a linear-algebraic presentation of the Lorentz transformation [9]. The present derivation belongs to this symmetry-first line of work, but differs mainly in organization and level of exposition. Rather than beginning with the light postulate, we first derive the general symmetry-constrained kinematics and postpone the empirical identification of the invariant scale until the final stage. We also make explicit that, within the additive framework supplied by homogeneity, continuity, differentiability, and boundedness are equivalent regularity routes to linearity, and that continuity is needed only in the event coordinates rather than as an a priori assumption on the velocity parameter. Methodologically, we adopt a stronger physical reading of the Principle of Relativity than the merely formal requirement that admissible transformations form a common kinematical class. Whether or not one chooses to subsume it under the Principle of Relativity as a matter of definition, the absence of a distinguished inertial frame must in any case be retained as an independent and indispensable physical requirement. In the present context, this means that two reciprocal descriptions of one and the same relative motion must remain physically equivalent. If the direct and reciprocal descriptions were allowed to assign unequal speed magnitudes to that motion, the discrepancy itself would provide a criterion for distinguishing the status of the two frames. From this viewpoint, the appearance of -v in the inverse transformation is not best regarded as an extraneous technical theorem obtained only after supplementing relativity by additional assumptions on a velocity-labeling map. Rather, in the standard configuration it is the natural kinematical expression of inertial-frame equivalence. Section 2.2 establishes linearity and clarifies the equivalence of regularity assumptions. Section 2.3 determines the coefficient structure and the associated one-parameter family of transformations. Section 2.4 uses the light postulate to select the physically relevant branch, recover the Lorentz transformation, extend the one-dimensional light postulate to full three-dimensional kinematics, and show that c is maximal. Section 2.5 briefly records the resulting group structure. 2. Derivation Process 2.1 Physical Assumptions Our derivation rests on the following assumptions. 1. Spacetime Structure Assumption Spacetime is homogeneous, isotropic, and continuous. 2. Principle of Relativity The laws of physics have the same form in every inertial frame. 3. No Distinguished Inertial Frame No inertial reference frame is physically privileged over another. 4. Transformation Consistency The inertial transformations include the identity, admit inverses, and are closed under composition. 5. Principle of the Constancy of the Speed of Light (hereafter, the light postulate) The speed of light in vacuum, c , is the same in all inertial frames. 2.2 Proof of Transformation Linearity 2.2.1 Definition of the Transformation and Its Parameters Consider two inertial reference frames K(x,y,z,t) and K^{\prime}(x^{\prime},y^{\prime},z^{\prime},t^{\prime}) . Frame K^{\prime} moves with constant velocity v along the common x -axis of K . Their spatial and temporal origins coincide at t=t^{\prime}=0 , as shown in Figure~ 1 . x^{\prime} y^{\prime} z^{\prime} K’ x y z K \mathbf{v} O ( t=t^{\prime}=0 ) Figure 1: Two inertial frames K and K^{\prime} whose origins coincide at t=t^{\prime}=0 with K^{\prime} moving along the x -axis with velocity v . The spatial axes are aligned. Every physical event is represented by a four-dimensional coordinate vector, \mathbf{e}=(x,y,z,t)^{T}\quad\text{in frame $K$,}\quad\text{and}\quad\mathbf{e}^{\prime}=(x^{\prime},y^{\prime},z^{\prime},t^{\prime})^{T}\quad\text{in frame $K^{\prime}$.} The most general transformation between the coordinates of the same event is written as \mathbf{e}^{\prime}=T(\mathbf{e},p) where T is a mapping between the event coordinates in the two frames, and p represents a set of parameters describing the relative configuration of K and K^{\prime} . For inertial Cartesian frames, spacetime homogeneity and isotropy allow one, without loss of generality, to adopt the standard configuration in which the origins coincide at t=t^{\prime}=0 , the spatial axes are parallel and chosen with the same orientation, and the relative motion is along the common x -axis. In general, the parameter

Read the complete text