SL ⁡ ( 3 , ℤ ) \operatorname{SL}(3,\mathbb{Z}) is not Howson

Shengkui Ye, Qiang Zhang · 2026

Read SL ⁡ ( 3 , ℤ ) \operatorname{SL}(3,\mathbb{Z}) is not Howson by Shengkui Ye, Qiang Zhang (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2605-25080.txt.

Introduction

Shengkui Ye and Qiang Zhang show SL(3,Z) is not Howson by construction. Two 2-generated subgroups of SL(3,Z) have an intersection not finitely generated. The construction sits inside the parabolic subgroup combining Z squared with SL(2,Z). Its step identifies the intersection with a point stabilizer under a free group's affine action on Z squared. A Schreier graph shows that stabilizer is not finitely generated. They give subgroup pairs of rank four whose intersections have rank at least q plus one while staying finitely generated.

Catalog record

CREATORShengkui Ye, Qiang Zhang
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE19291
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2605.25080

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

SL ⁡ ( 3 , ℤ ) \operatorname{SL}(3,\mathbb{Z}) is not Howson Thanks: The authors are partially supported by NSFC (No. 12471066 and 11971389). Shengkui Ye, Qiang Zhang Abstract . We give an explicit construction of two 2 2 -generated subgroups H , K ≤ SL ⁡ ( 3 , ℤ ) H,K\leq\operatorname{SL}(3,\mathbb{Z}) whose intersection is not finitely generated. The construction takes place inside the standard parabolic subgroup ℤ 2 ⋊ SL ⁡ ( 2 , ℤ ) ≤ SL ⁡ ( 3 , ℤ ) \mathbb{Z}^{2}\rtimes\operatorname{SL}(2,\mathbb{Z})\leq\operatorname{SL}(3,\mathbb{Z}) . The main point is to identify H ∩ K H\cap K with the stabilizer of a point for an affine action of a free group on ℤ 2 \mathbb{Z}^{2} , and then to prove, using the Schreier graph of this action, that this stabilizer is not finitely generated. Furthermore, we prove that there exists a sequence of subgroups H q , K q ≤ SL ⁡ ( 3 , ℤ ) H_{q},K_{q}\leq\operatorname{SL}(3,\mathbb{Z}) such that rank ⁡ ( H q ) = rank ⁡ ( K q ) = 4 \operatorname{rank}(H_{q})=\operatorname{rank}(K_{q})=4 , and rank ⁡ ( H q ∩ K q ) ≥ q + 1 , \operatorname{rank}(H_{q}\cap K_{q})\geq q+1, while H q ∩ K q H_{q}\cap K_{q} is finitely generated. 2010 Mathematics Subject Classification 20F65, 20F34. 1. Introduction Let G be a group. The rank of G , denoted \operatorname{rank}(G) , is the minimal cardinality of a generating set for G . In 1954, Howson [ 6 ] showed that the intersection of finitely generated subgroups of a free group is also finitely generated, which led to the notion of Howson group: a group G is said to be Howson , if the intersection H\cap K of any two finitely generated subgroups H,K<G is again finitely generated. Many types of groups are Howson, for instance, free groups, surface groups, Baumslag-Solitar groups BS_{1,n}=\langle a,t\mid tat^{-1}=a^{n}\rangle(n\geq 1) [ 12 ] , limit groups [ 3 ] , etc. In particular, if G is a free or surface group, then \operatorname{rank}(H\cap K)-1\leq(\operatorname{rank}(H)-1)(\operatorname{rank}(K)-1), which was conjectured by Hanna Neumann in 1957, and proved independently by Friedman [ 4 ] and by Mineyev [ 11 ] for free groups in 2011, and by Antolín and Jaikin-Zapirain [ 1 ] for surface groups in 2022. Note that the direct product F_{n}\times\mathbb{Z} of a free group F_{n} with rank n>1 is not Howson. Moreover, Kapovich [ 7 ] showed many hyperbolic groups are not Howson. It is easy to show that the class of Howson groups is closed under taking subgroups and under finite extensions. In particular, virtually free groups and virtually surface groups are both Howson. More generally, the class of Howson groups is closed under graphs of groups, where the edge groups are finite [ 16 ] . Moreover, Shusterman and Zalesskii [ 15 ] extended the Howson property to the Demushkin group: the intersection of a pair of closed topologically finitely generated subgroups of a Demushkin group is topologically finitely generated. This gives the first example of the Howson pro- p groups that are not free. It is known that the special linear group \operatorname{SL}(2,\mathbb{Z}) is Howson because it is virtually free. In contrast, \operatorname{SL}(n,\mathbb{Z})(n\geq 4) is not Howson [ 9 ] , since it contains F_{2}\times\mathbb{Z} . Nevertheless, it still remains unclear whether \operatorname{SL}(3,\mathbb{Z}) is Howson (see [ 9 ] and [ 8 ] ). In this note we prove that \operatorname{SL}(3,\mathbb{Z}) is not Howson: the intersection of two 2 -generated subgroups can fail to be finitely generated. Theorem 1.1 . The group \operatorname{SL}(3,\mathbb{Z}) is not Howson. In 2015, Araújo, Silva and Sykiotis [ 2 ] introduced a stronger quantitative version. A group G is called strongly Howson if, for all positive integers m,n , there exists a constant C(m,n) such that whenever H,K\leq G satisfy \operatorname{rank}(H)\leq m and \operatorname{rank}(K)\leq n , we have \operatorname{rank}(H\cap K)\leq C(m,n). Thus strong Howson is a uniform rank-bounded version of the Howson property. In [ 18 ] , Zhang and Zhao showed that the strongly Howson property is indeed stronger than the Howson property, by constructing the first examples of Howson groups which are not strongly Howson. In this note, we have: Theorem 1.2 . Inside \operatorname{SL}(3,\mathbb{Z}) there exist finitely generated subgroups H_{q},K_{q} for any integer q\geq 2 such that \operatorname{rank}(H_{q})=\operatorname{rank}(K_{q})=4, while H_{q}\cap K_{q} is finitely generated and \operatorname{rank}(H_{q}\cap K_{q})\geq q+1. In particular, \operatorname{SL}(3,\mathbb{Z}) does not satisfy any strong Howson-type uniform rank bound, even when restricted to those pairs whose intersections are finitely generated. 2. Schreier graphs: basic facts We shall use only standard facts about Schreier graphs of subgroups of free groups. See Stallings [ 17 ] for the core-graph viewpoint and Lyndon–Schupp [ 10 , Chapter I] for classical combinatorial group theory background. Let F=F(X) be the free group on a finite set X , and let N\leq F be a subgroup. Definition 2.1 (Schreier graph) . The (right) Schreier graph \Gamma(N\backslash F,X) has vertex set N\backslash F , the set of right cosets. For every vertex Ng and every generator x\in X , there is a directed edge Ng\xrightarrow{x}Ngx . Equivalently, one may include inverse edges labeled x^{-1} . The following properties are the ones used in the proof of our main theorems. S1. Connectedness. The Schreier graph \Gamma(N\backslash F,X) is connected. Indeed, every vertex Ng is reached from the base vertex N by reading a word representing g . S2. Words and paths. A word in the alphabet X^{\pm 1} labels a path in the Schreier graph. If the word is freely reduced, then the corresponding path has no immediate backtracking. S3. Loops and the subgroup. A word w\in F labels a loop at the base vertex N if and only if w\in N . More generally, w labels a loop at the vertex Ng if and only if gwg^{-1}\in N , with the convention appropriate to right cosets. S4. Orbital interpretation. If F acts transitively on a set \Omega and \omega_{0}\in\Omega , then the Schreier graph of \operatorname{Stab}_{F}(\omega_{0}) is naturally isomorphic to the orbital graph of the action on \omega_{0}F (The orbital graph has vertex set \Omega=\omega_{0}F , and two vertices \omega_{0}g,\omega_{0}gx are connected by an edge for x\in X ). Under this isomorphism, the base vertex corresponds to \omega_{0} . S5. The core. The core of a Schreier graph is the subgraph spanned by all edges and vertices lying on reduced closed paths. Equivalently, it is obtained by pruning off all hanging trees. A vertex that lies on a nontrivial reduced closed path lies in the core. Some form of the following is known to Stallings [ 17 ] . Lemma 2.2 (Stallings core criterion) . For a subgroup N\leq F(X) , the subgroup N is finitely generated if and only if the core of \Gamma(N\backslash F,X) is finite. In particular, if the core contains infinitely many vertices, then N is not finitely generated. Proof. A word w\in F labels a loop at the base vertex N in the graph \Gamma(N\backslash F,X) if and only if w\in N . Therefore, the subgroup N is the set P of labels of (reduced) closed paths based at the vertex N . Note that P can be viewed as a group (isomorphic to the group N )

Read the complete text