Multimodality Stacking with Blockwise missing values and application to the PIONeeR biomarkers study for prediction of resistance to immunotherapy

Mohamed Boussena, Florence Monville, Jacques Fieschi-Meric, Frederic Vely, Pierre Milpied, Julien Mazieres, Maurice Perol, Eric Vivier, Laurent Greillier, Fabrice Barlesi, Sebastien Benzekry · 2026

Read Multimodality Stacking with Blockwise missing values and application to the PIONeeR biomarkers study for prediction of resistance to immunotherapy by Mohamed Boussena, Florence Monville, Jacques Fieschi-Meric, Frederic Vely, Pierre Milpied, Julien Mazieres, Maurice Perol, Eric Vivier, Laurent Greillier, Fabrice Barlesi, Sebastien Benzekry (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2605-25050.txt.

Introduction

Mohamed Boussena and colleagues present Multimodality Stacking with Blockwise missing values, a late-fusion method for blockwise-missing data. Each source is modeled alone, then results are merged by stacking. Tested on PIONeeR: 443 patients, 378 markers, it predicts progression-free survival for late-stage NSCLC patients on immune therapy. It beats rivals on the C-index: linear models improve nearly sixteen percent, random forests five point four percent, and boosting two point one percent. It shrinks the linear-model gap from 0.380 to 0.055. Lab markers, signs, and PD-L1 levels drive results.

Catalog record

CREATORMohamed Boussena, Florence Monville, Jacques Fieschi-Meric, Frederic Vely, Pierre Milpied, Julien Mazieres, Maurice Perol, Eric Vivier, Laurent Greillier, Fabrice Barlesi, Sebastien Benzekry
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE62211
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2605.25050

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Multimodality Stacking with Blockwise missing values and application to the PIONeeR biomarkers study for prediction of resistance to immunotherapy Mohamed Boussena, Florence Monville, Jacques Fieschi-Meric, Frederic Vely, Pierre Milpied, Julien Mazieres, Maurice Perol, Eric Vivier, Laurent Greillier, Fabrice Barlesi, Sebastien Benzekry Abstract Abstract Integrating multimodal datasets in clinical oncology is frequently hindered by high dimensionality and blockwise missingness, where entire data sources are unavailable for specific patient subsets. Standard survival models often struggle with these gaps, leading to biased results or patient exclusion. We introduce Multimodality Stacking with Blockwise missing values (MSB), a late-fusion framework for survival analysis that independently models modality-specific features before aggregating predictions via a cross-validated stacking meta-learner. MSB was validated on the PIONeeR study (n=443 patients, 378 biomarkers across eight heterogeneous sources) to predict progression-free survival in advanced non-small cell lung cancer patients receiving immunotherapy. MSB yielded higher predictive performance (C-index) than baseline algorithms. Improvements varied by baseline strength: linear models showed a 15.9% increase ( p<0.001 for the Wilcoxon signed-rank test, consistent across 15 cross-validation folds), random survival forests gained 5.4% ( p=0.002 ), and gradient boosting methods improved by 2.1% ( p=0.030 ). Beyond discrimination, MSB reduced the generalization gap (train-test difference in 5 folds cross-validation repeated 3 times: 0.055 vs 0.380 for linear models). Permutation importance analysis identified routine laboratory markers, clinical features, and PD-L1 expression as primary predictive drivers. Missing block indicators showed negligible importance, suggesting the model learned from biomarker values rather than data availability patterns. MSB provides a statistically validated framework for multimodal survival prediction with blockwise missingness. By enabling systematic biomarker evaluation without requiring complete data, MSB offers a practical tool for predictive modeling in biomedical research, pending external validation. Implementation of the MSB framework is available here under Inria license. 1 Introduction In many biomedical applications, three major issues frequently occur: (1) high dimensionality ( n\sim p or n\ll p ), (2) a substantial proportion of missing data and (3) high multicollinearity among features within the same data source. While conventional feature selection and ensemble-based algorithms aim to mitigate the ’curse of dimensionality’ [ 24 ] , they exhibit significant statistical instability in small cohorts, especially among correlated predictors. This problem has been studied by Bakhmach et al. [ 3 ] , to address this issue in the classification setting. These issues are compounded with missing values as standard imputation techniques lose fidelity as dimensionality increases. Given that high dimensionality in clinical datasets often arises from the integration of heterogeneous data sources, we hypothesize that addressing the problem at the source level — rather than the feature level — provides a more robust framework for survival modeling. This source-level approach aligns with an active field of machine learning: multimodal learning, which is closely connected to multi-kernel, mixture-of-experts, or multiview learning [ 20 , 37 , 19 , 13 ] . While often applied to integrate heterogeneous data types (e.g. tabular data and images), multimodal learning gives us a structured way to handle tabular data coming from many different sources. Krones et al. [ 19 ] identified three principal categories of multimodal learning: early fusion, intermediate fusion, and late fusion. Early fusion encompasses approaches that combine different data modalities prior to the learning step. This would correspond to a straightforward concatenation of all features from every modality into a single dataset, with or without prior transformation. This is the simplest and most commonly used approach for handling multimodal tabular data. Intermediate fusion designates methods in which fusion and learning occur simultaneously, for instance by assigning weights to modalities or by transforming the dataset during training. Late fusion, in contrast, describes approaches that first train separate models for each modality, and subsequently merge their outputs using a final model or a rule-based scheme. This taxonomy can be extended by including ’hybrid fusion’ strategies [ 38 ] , which refer to any fusion approach that combines aspects of the three aforementioned categories. While multimodal integration of imaging, omics, and tabular data offers significant potential for biomarker discovery [ 26 ] , clinical oncology datasets are frequently constrained by small sample sizes and high rates of missing values. Regardless of the fusion strategy considered, current multimodal approaches commonly address blockwise missingness through listwise deletion — the exclusion of patients lacking complete data across all modalities [ 18 , 9 ] . Beyond the substantial reduction in effective sample size this entails, such exclusions are rarely justified by the underlying missingness mechanism and have been shown to introduce systematic bias in predictive models [ 30 ] . Missing values in multimodal learning are receiving attention, especially for deep learning models [ 35 ] . For smaller sample sizes, Shuo Xiang et al [ 36 ] proposed a model based on late fusion where they trained an intermediate model for each modality, when available, and then imputed the missing scores. Then, a meta model was trained on top of this reduced dataset. Van Loon et al. [ 32 ] went further with the proposal of a Stacked penalized logistic regression (StaPLR) as an imputation model to overcome missing modalities in a multimodal dataset. StaPLR fits an intermediate model on each modality, performing feature selection at the modality level, and then imputing the data, for classification tasks. The HealNet model [ 16 ] was introduced for survival analysis and is capable of dealing with missing data at the modality level. However, it is a deep learning model primarily designed for imaging data and treats tabular variables on a per-feature basis rather than as a unified modality. Here, we departed from a nationwide clinical dataset collected to address a current problem in immuno-oncology: to predict the onset of resistance to immune-checkpoint inhibitors (ICI) in advanced non-small cell lung cancer (NSCLC). Indeed, long-term remissions are only achieved in 20-30% of such patients [ 5 , 12 , 11 ] , making lung cancer the leading cause of cancer-related deaths [ 6 ] . A French national consortium grouping 17 clinical centers and 6 biological and industrial partners was constituted within the PIONeeR (Precision Immuno-Oncology for advanced Non-Small Cell Lung Cancer Patients with PD1(L1) ICI Resistance) clinical study (2018-2024) [ 4 ] . The biological markers from either the peripheral blood or tumor tissue collected pre-treatment yielded a dataset with 378 biomarkers in 443 patients. Because each partner processed samples to generate specific biomarker types, the data exhibited both a multi-modal structure and blockwise missing values. Although the primary endpoint was primary resistance, defined either for monotherapy as having a best overall response (BOR) of Progressive Disease or Stable Disease at 6 months, or for combination therapy – chemotherapy plus immunotherapy – as having disease progression within 6 months, even when the BOR is Complete Response or Partial Response, [ 23 , 27 ] ,the study revealed that progression-free survival served as a more relevant continuous endpoint, prompting us to adopt here survival analysis methods. We developed a multimodal approach relying on a stacking algorithm as an aggregating learner from multiple sources [ 34 , 31 ] . While late-fusion strategies have been explored for classification [ 8 ] , their extension to right-censored survival data remains under-researched. In the scikit-survival library [ 22 ] , the stacking

Read the complete text