Structural constraint on delayed-choice quantum eraser architectures

Chakir Fikri · 2026

Read Structural constraint on delayed-choice quantum eraser architectures by Chakir Fikri (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2605-24994.txt.

Introduction

Chakir Fikri proves a simple probability rule for ideal delayed-choice quantum eraser setups. Such tests are often cast as defying classical causal intuition by linking detections to later choices. Post-selection is known to shape the observed interference patterns, yet their structural roots lack a unified account. Fikri shows four plain properties cannot hold together: free choice, no losses, fixed routing given the choice, and distinct conditional detection patterns. That clash classifies eraser schemes plainly. It shows how conditional interference arises without exotic mechanisms.

Catalog record

CREATORChakir Fikri
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE34430
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2605.24994

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Structural constraint on delayed-choice quantum eraser architectures Chakir Fikri Abstract Delayed-choice quantum eraser (DCQE) experiments are often presented as challenging classical causal intuitions by correlating detection events with choices implemented at later times. While it is well understood that post-selection plays a crucial role in producing the observed interference patterns, the structural features underlying such correlations are rarely analyzed within a unified framework. In this work, we introduce a simple probabilistic constraint applicable to idealized DCQE architectures. We show that four intuitive properties—statistical independence of the choice, absence of losses, deterministic routing conditioned on the choice, and distinct conditional detection distributions—cannot be simultaneously satisfied. This incompatibility provides a transparent classification of DCQE schemes and clarifies how conditional interference patterns arise without invoking exotic mechanisms. I Introduction Quantum entanglement enables correlations between distant or temporally separated events that challenge classical causal intuitions. In spatially separated systems, such correlations are quantitatively characterized by the violation of Bell inequalities 2 ; 1 ; 16 ; 7 ; 3 . In temporal scenarios, delayed-choice experiments explore how measurement outcomes appear correlated with experimental choices implemented at later times 8 . Among these, delayed-choice quantum eraser (DCQE) experiments occupy a prominent place. In a typical DCQE setup, two entangled particles are generated simultaneously. One particle is detected at a spatially resolved detector, while the other undergoes a measurement whose configuration—often interpreted as erasing or preserving which-path information—is chosen after the first detection event 15 ; 10 ; 11 . When coincidence counts are analyzed, interference patterns are observed for certain subsets of outcomes and disappear for others. Although it is well established that such patterns arise from conditional statistics and post-selection rather than any form of retrocausal influence 11 ; 5 , DCQE experiments are still frequently discussed in language suggesting a tension with standard causal explanations. This motivates a closer examination of the structural assumptions implicitly attributed to idealized DCQE scenarios, independently of any specific physical implementation. More precisely, we argue that the appearance of paradox in DCQE scenarios results from implicitly combining several intuitive structural assumptions that cannot, in fact, be simultaneously satisfied. From this perspective, the apparent tension associated with DCQE experiments can be understood as a structural illusion arising from mutually incompatible expectations rather than as evidence for any unconventional causal mechanism. Several authors have argued that the apparent paradoxical features of DCQE experiments disappear once the physical and causal structure of the experiment is analyzed explicitly. Kastner 9 emphasizes that DCQE experiments are structurally equivalent to standard EPR-type correlation experiments and therefore involve neither a genuine erasure of previously available which-path information nor any delayed physical influence. Fankhauser 4 shows that the correlations observed in DCQE experiments can be consistently described within both collapse interpretations of quantum mechanics and de Broglie–Bohm theory without invoking any backward-in-time causal influence. Waaijer and van Neerven 17 provides a step-by-step forward-time analysis of delayed-choice experiments showing that delayed and non-delayed configurations lead to the same final quantum state within standard quantum mechanics, thereby removing the appearance of retrocausal behavior at the operational level without requiring interpretational assumptions about the ontic or epistemic status of the quantum state. Qureshi 12 ; 13 ; 14 has argued that the apparent availability of which-path information in delayed configurations may already be constrained by the structure of the joint entangled state prior to the final detection stage, so that the delayed-choice configuration does not correspond to a genuine late-time operational selection between complementary measurement contexts. The present work addresses a complementary question. Rather than focusing on the temporal interpretation of delayed-choice operations or on the status of which-path information prior to coincidence post-selection, we investigate minimal probabilistic compatibility relations between structural properties commonly attributed to idealized DCQE scenarios expressed in terms of observable random variables describing the experimental architecture. The resulting incompatibility applies independently of how the delayed-choice configuration is interpreted at the level of conditional quantum states and does not rely on the dynamical structure of quantum mechanics itself. Instead, it follows from elementary probabilistic constraints relating experimentally accessible variables. Specifically, we identify four conditions that formalize common expectations: statistical independence between the experimental choice and the earlier detection event, absence of losses, deterministic association between choices and detection outcomes, and the existence of distinct conditional detection distributions corresponding to interference and non-interference patterns. We show that these conditions are mutually incompatible. This simple structural constraint does not rely on quantum dynamics or specific experimental details. Instead, it provides a unifying perspective that clarifies why realistic DCQE implementations necessarily violate at least one of these intuitive properties. We then apply this framework to several representative DCQE architectures, illustrating how losses, coarse-graining, or nondeterministic routing account for the observed correlations. Our analysis is not intended to resolve interpretational debates, but rather to provide a transparent classification of DCQE schemes and to identify the minimal structural ingredients responsible for their behavior. In this way, it clarifies why the apparent paradoxical features of DCQE experiments arise naturally in idealized descriptions but disappear once the underlying compatibility constraints are made explicit. II Formal framework and definitions II.1 Probabilistic framework We consider a generic DCQE scenario involving two correlated systems, denoted S and I . System S is detected at a spatially resolved detector (or an equivalent scanning detection device), producing a random variable X that labels the detection position. System I is subjected to a measurement configuration chosen at a later time and subsequently detected. To describe such experiments at a minimal probabilistic level, we introduce three random variables defined on a common probability space: • X , representing the detection outcome of system S at the spatially resolved detector; • C , representing the experimental choice implemented on system I . For simplicity, we take C\in\{\mathrm{erase},\mathrm{preserve}\} ; • D , representing the detection outcome associated with system I . In realistic implementations, multiple detectors may be associated with each experimental configuration. It is therefore useful to distinguish between fine-grained detection outcomes, corresponding to individual physical detectors, and coarse-grained outcomes that group detectors according to the experimental choice they are intended to implement. Throughout this work, D may denote either level of description, with the relevant coarse-graining explicitly stated when necessary. We now formalize four intuitive properties that are often implicitly attributed to idealized DCQE scenarios. • Independence of the experimental choice: X\perp C . This condition expresses the assumption that the choice of measurement configuration applied to system I is statistically independent of the earlier detection outcome of system S . Operationally, it corresponds to the usual notion of a freely chosen experimental setting. • Absence of losses: All realizations of S are assumed to be paired with a detection event of I . In probabilistic terms, X and D are jointly defined for every trial. No post-selection based on missing detection events is required. • Deterministic routing conditioned on the choice: We assume that the detection outcome of system I is uniquely determined by the experimental choice: D=f(C) , for some deterministic function f . At the coarse-grained level, this corresponds to the idealized picture in which each choice \mathrm{erase} or \mathrm{preserve} leads to a distinct and exclusive detection channel. • Distinct conditional detection distributions: Finally, we assume that

Read the complete text