A Category-theoretic Reconstruction of Logical Expressivism
Kristopher Brown · 2026
Read A Category-theoretic Reconstruction of Logical Expressivism by Kristopher Brown (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2605-24796.txt.
Introduction
Kristopher Brown rebuilds logical expressivism. The aim is a clearer view of how logic works in use. In pragmatism, meanings come from practices of use, and logical expressivism offers a distinct view of logic. The paper clarifies a recent Brandom-Hlobil account of logical expressivism by rebuilding its formal meaning with universal constructions. This shows links with categorical logic: judgment structure moves inside, and connectives come from adjunctions.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Kristopher Brown |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 132289 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2605.24796
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
A Category-theoretic Reconstruction of Logical Expressivism Kristopher Brown Abstract In the philosophical tradition of ‘analytic pragmatism’, which attempts to account for linguistic meanings in terms of their practices of use, logical expressivism is a theory which offers a distinct perspective on logic. We shed light on Brandom and Hlobil’s recent formalization of logical expressivism by reconstructing its formal semantics through the use of universal constructions. This reveals similarities with categorical logic: there is a focus on internalizing judgment structure, and connectives arise from adjunctions. Notation: We denote multisets of elements from some set X with \mathbb{N}[X] , whereas the power set of X is \mathcal{P}[X] . Singletons and unions of multisets are, as with sets, denoted with \{-\} and \cup respectively. We liberally apply the bijections \mathbb{N}[X+X]\cong\mathbb{N}[X]\times\mathbb{N}[X] and \mathcal{P}[X+X]\cong\mathcal{P}[X]\times\mathcal{P}[X] implicitly. Functor compositions like GF are shorthand for G\circ F , though functors (and morphisms in general) are sometimes composed in diagrammatic order, written F\cdot G . At times, pairs will be written \langle-,-\rangle rather than (-,-) , especially if the elements inside contain further pairs. \sigma denotes the swap operation on pairs. All mentioned monoids and quantales will be commutative and unital. The categories of quantales, monoids, and preordered monoids are respectively denoted \mathsf{Quant} , \mathsf{CMon} , and \mathsf{PreOrdCMon} . Given a preorder \mathcal{X}:=(X,\leq) , let \mathcal{X}^{\downarrow} be the lattice of lower sets of \mathcal{X} ordered by \subseteq whose principal lower sets are of the form x^{\downarrow}:=\{x^{\prime}\in X\ |\ x^{\prime}\leq x\} . Lastly, we warn that \bot and (-)^{\bot} are overloaded notations which have distinct but related meanings in the categories we will encounter. 1 Background: inferentialism and logical expressivism In this section, we briefly summarize some concepts from Reasons for Logic, Logic for Reasons [ 11 ] . We can understand a domain of reasoning as having claims (that which can be asserted in that domain’s vocabulary) and a notion of consequence, i.e. of some claims following from other claims. Example domains could range from ‘group theory’ to ‘the game of chess’ to ‘18th century maritime law’. A special class of examples comes from formal logics (e.g. classical, linear, paraconsistent) and their consequence relations. These consequence relations, despite their diversity, share some common structure. For example, the consequence operator , which takes a set of premises to its set of consequences, is often assumed to satisfy the Tarskian conditions of reflexivity, monotonicity, and idempotence. From the proof-theoretic perspective, such constraints respectively correspond to structural rules of identity, weakening, and cut. The formalization of a domain, i.e. the encoding of its claims within a formal system such that its consequence relation coincides with the logical consequence relation, is a powerful tool if successfully accomplished. This is because weakening allows for portability of conclusions in different contexts, and cut allows for composability of reasoning. Thus it is a remarkable achievement that we have suitable logical encodings for some domains: for example, quantum logic for statements about quantum-mechanical observables [ 2 ] , intuitionistic logic for constructive mathematics [ 8 ] , linear logic for resource-sensitive reasoning [ 10 ] . Inspired by the success of formalization of (certain aspects of) scientific reasoning, one could take the view that good reasoning always has this form: insofar as we genuinely mean something by ‘It is a dog’ and ‘It is a mammal’, and the former is a reason for the latter, then it must be the case that there must exist some encoding in some logic that is able to recover this inference as a logical consequence. Russell’s On Denoting [ 25 ] offers an example of logical analysis of ordinary language expressions like “the present King of France” using classical predicate logic; however, one can reject his analysis on the basis of it not reproducing our ordinary inferences: e.g. he would be forced to endorse ‘‘The present King of France is bald’’ is a good reason for ‘‘The moon is made of cheese’’, as his analysis of the antecedent is that it is meaningful but false. There are many ways to react to this failure: one could seek a different encoding in classical logic, one can seek to develop new kinds of logics (e.g. free logics) to deal with ‘non-existent entities’, and, lastly, we emphasize one could reject the attempt to ground the domain of interest in logical reasoning. It may be the case that legal, ethical, and medical reasoning do not satisfy the Tarskian constraints. 1 1 1 Of the three constraints characteristic of logical consequence, weakening is the easiest to drop. Categorical logic, by moving from cartesian closed categories to symmetric monoidal closed categories, allows for viewing weakening as a property rather than assumed structure; however, identity and cut remain fixed. We note that rejection of cut is one way to make sense of logical paradoxes (such as the liar sentence) [ 23 ] , and there many ordinary language (non-paradoxical) examples [ 26 ] . In contrast to this logico-semantic approach to meaning, inferentialism about meaning is the thesis that we should firstly think of the meaning of a sentence in terms of its good inferences and secondarily (if at all) think of it as represented by a formal term in some deductive calculus or an element in some semantic domain; this is the opposite order of explanation relative to the story explained above [ 3 ] . In this work, we focus on the formal treatment of inferentialism of [ 11 ] , noting there exist other formal treatments, too [ 14 , 20 ] . We begin with some norm governing good judgments involving atomic sentences. Definition 1.1 . A signed incompatibility frame is a set X of propositional atoms, equipped with a subset \bot\subseteq\mathbb{N}[X+X] . Idempotent signed incompatibility frames are sets X equipped with \bot\subseteq\mathcal{P}[X+X] . Elements of \mathbb{N}[X+X] (or \mathcal{P}[X+X] in the idempotent case) are called positions , and \bot is the subset of incompatible positions. We equivalently refer to a signed incompatibility frame as an implication frame because we often interpret a position (\Gamma,\Delta) as a candidate implication \Gamma\vdash\Delta , with sets (or multisets) of atoms on each side of the turnstile [ 11 , Def. 62] . Such a candidate implication may or may not obtain, according to the frame; the ‘good implications’, i.e. the ones which obtain, are the elements of \bot . 2 2 2 Following [ 22 ] , a bilateralist reading of the turnstile \Gamma\vdash\Delta is that ‘It is normatively out-of-bounds’ to accept everything in \Gamma and reject everything in \Delta . Interpreting sequents in this way (where the left hand side represents accepted claims, and the right hand side represents simultaneously rejected claims) explains why an ‘incompatible’ position (i.e. out-of-bounds) is a ‘good’ implication ( \Delta follows if you cannot reject it while accepting \Gamma ). For example, a,b\vdash a,c is notation for (\{a,b\},\{a,c\})\in\bot and a,b\nvdash c is notation for (\{a,b\},\{c\})\notin\bot . Idempotent frames implicitly enforce contraction as a structural rule, and both frames implicitly enforce exchange. Thinking of an implication frame’s turnstile as ‘raw, input data’ leads to logical expressivism , which takes the concept of inferences being ‘simply’ good (as in an implication frame) to be explanatorily-prior to the concept of logically-good inferences [ 4 ]