The Method of Simultaneous Solutions Applied to Neutron Transport and Heat Conduction Journal: Journal of Computational Physics

Dean Price, Brian Kiedrowski, Benoit Forget · 2026

Read The Method of Simultaneous Solutions Applied to Neutron Transport and Heat Conduction Journal: Journal of Computational Physics by Dean Price, Brian Kiedrowski, Benoit Forget (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2605-24606.txt.

Introduction

Dean Price, Brian Kiedrowski, and Benoit Forget present a Monte Carlo scheme called the Method of Simultaneous Solutions, solving neutron transport and heat conduction. Derived weighting factors ride a neutron-led random walk, tallying figures for the temperature distribution. The main benefit is dropping a special heat solver, cutting compute cost. Drawbacks include branching to handle unlike edge rules, possible endless variance when tracked runs diverge, and errors from treating heat conduction as Boltzmann-led. Two demos, a slab and a six-sided pin cell, explore these limits.

Catalog record

CREATORDean Price, Brian Kiedrowski, Benoit Forget
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE55309
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2605.24606

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

The Method of Simultaneous Solutions Applied to Neutron Transport and Heat Conduction Journal: Journal of Computational Physics Dean Price, Brian Kiedrowski, Benoit Forget Abstract This paper provides an initial description of the Method of Simultaneous Solutions, a Monte Carlo approach that simultaneously solves multiple Boltzmann-transport-like phenomena. Here, it is used to simultaneously solve the neutron transport and heat conduction equations. Analytically-derived weighting factors are tracked through a neutron transport-governed random walk to tally statistical estimators that can be used to calculate the temperature distribution. In this initial presentation, the method is readily applicable to neutron-heat multiphysics problems where the heat source and neutron source are identically distributed spatially. The primary theoretical benefit of MOSS lies in the reduction of computational cost that occurs from the removal of a dedicated routine to solve the heat conduction equation. Practically, branching processes required to capture the disparate boundary conditions associated with these separate physical phenomena can lead to large computational times dedicated to a single physics. In addition, this correlated sampling-based method can suffer from infinite variance associated with statistical estimators if the stochastic processes being tracked are too different. The final drawback demonstrated in this paper is that the approximation of heat conduction as a Boltzmann transport-governed process leads to errors in calculated temperatures. The paper explores these drawbacks on two demonstration problems, a problem consisting of slab geometry and a problem consisting of a hexagonal pin cell. † † highlights: Introduces the Method of Simultaneous Solutions (MOSS), a Monte Carlo technique that reuses neutron transport histories to estimate temperature fields with correlated sampling. Formulates heat conduction as a purely scattering Boltzmann transport process with boundary-condition homogenization and albedo-based boundary treatment. Demonstrates MOSS on slab and hexagonal pin-cell reactor problems, comparing neutron flux and temperature fields against reference solutions. 1 Introduction Multiphysics analysis typically requires the simulation of several distinct physical processes that come together to form the total behavior of a system. Although not realized in this work, its most complete form accounts for the interacting components of the physical processes for a fully coupled, self-consistent solution. For example, in nuclear reactors, neutron transport and heat transfer are two such interacting physical processes. This paper presents a Monte Carlo method that simultaneously solves the neutron transport and conductive heat transfer problems, using an approximate stochastic model of heat conduction derived from Boltzmann particle transport. This simultaneous solution is accomplished with analytical path weights that let a single set of random histories track separate physical phenomena. This method will be referred to as the Method of Simultaneous Solutions (MOSS) and can potentially be used to build tightly coupled multiphysics methods entirely within a Monte Carlo framework. The benefits of using the Monte Carlo method for solving the Boltzmann transport equation are well-established and include the ability to represent complex geometries without discretization in the spatial, angular or spectral dimensions. The most universal drawback comes from its low order of convergence and associated high computational cost. However, other practical drawbacks arise when using these codes in multiphysics frameworks. Deterministic approaches benefit from widely applicable numerical methods such as the finite element method that can be applied similarly to distinct physical phenomena. In a general sense, this consistency in the methodologies makes multiphysics coupling more straightforward and even enables tight coupling where a single “nonlinear solver simultaneously drives down the residual for each physics, taking into account the coupling between the physics in each nonlinear iteration” ( 18 ) . Monte Carlo methods, on the other hand, tend to be specialized and designed to treat a specific physical phenomenon. The other practical drawback observed when incorporating Monte Carlo Boltzmann equation solvers is that the constructive solid geometry representations of the problems can lead to consistency issues with typical mesh-based methods. The present method, MOSS, seeks to address some of these issues. It uses a consistent mathematical approach and geometric representation for Monte Carlo neutron transport and heat conduction. MOSS can rely on the approximation of the diffusion equation used to model heat conduction with the Boltzmann transport equation. The relationship between the Boltzmann transport equation and the diffusion equation is well-explored in the context of approximating transport with diffusion ( 11 ; 19 ; 7 ) . Specifically, 15 demonstrates that the leading order term in an asymptotic expansion of the transport solution is governed by the diffusion equation. 2 later provided a fully rigorous derivation of this diffusion equation limit for linear transport. The control of this leading order behavior on the solution is ultimately dictated by the size of the particle mean free path. Of course, the subject of interest in the current paper is reversing the direction of this approximation, representing diffusion with transport. Fortunately, this direction of approximation allows for the introduction of a manufactured parameter, \beta , to increase the dominance of this leading order solution by lowering the effective mean free path of the “heat particle”. This increases the accuracy of the diffusion to transport approximation but, within the context of MOSS, can increase the variance in statistical estimators. Independent of the transport equation, Monte Carlo methods for solving diffusion-based problems have been presented in the past ( 17 ; 12 ; 1 ) . However, MOSS relies specifically on the transport approximation for solving heat conduction to allow for consistency with the solution method for the neutron transport component of the problem. 8 initially presents the transport approximation to the heat conduction problem with additional work presented in 9 . Further exploration on the same method is presented later in 14 , 25 and 5 . These studies tend to highlight the geometric flexibility and compatibility with existing Monte Carlo simulation tools as the main motivations for their work. There is little complication in the treatment of the governing equations beyond the introduction of the \beta parameter for scaling the mean free path. Instead, as will be discussed in Section 2.2.1 , the boundary conditions imposed on the transport equation in order to approximate those found in diffusion problems are not entirely straightforward. In fact, as discussed in 14 , the need for boundary condition homogenization leads to an associated source-free diffusion problem that requires separate treatment. In 5 , a different method for addressing this challenge is presented. A central observation motivating MOSS is that in a fission-driven system, assuming local energy deposition, fission events are the common cause of both fields of interest. They produce the neutrons that determine the flux and simultaneously produce heat that determines the temperature. MOSS can exploit this common source because each simulated neutron history also seeds a co-located heat particle history governed by a similar transport process. With this observation, the best application scenarios for MOSS involve those driven by fission reactions. For now, MOSS is presented with a fixed-source form of the transport equation. With both problems governed by a transport process, a technique called correlated sampling enables neutron histories already tracked for the neutron flux to be adjusted with weight factors to estimate the temperature field. From 23 , these weight factors are calculated with “simple analytical expressions which can be computed with little additional effort”. Unfortunately, a technique called branching is required to treat the boundary

Read the complete text