On the Shirshov–Cohn theorem for JB-algebras

Mark Roelands, Samuel Tiersma · 2026

Read On the Shirshov–Cohn theorem for JB-algebras by Mark Roelands, Samuel Tiersma (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2605-24427.txt.

Introduction

Roelands and Tiersma prove that a JB-algebra formed from a pair of its associative Jordan subalgebras is always a JC-algebra, hence special. They obtain a parallel Macdonald-style refinement for JB-algebras. They further show the free unital JB-algebra on n projections is a JC-algebra exactly when n is 1, 2, or 3. Finally, they describe the free unital JB-algebra on two projections explicitly, in the spirit of the Raeburn-Sinclair theorem for C*-algebras.

Catalog record

CREATORMark Roelands, Samuel Tiersma
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE54651
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/publicdomain/zero/1.0/
RIGHTSCC0
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2605.24427

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

On the Shirshov–Cohn theorem for JB-algebras Mark Roelands, Samuel Tiersma Abstract It is shown that a JB-algebra which can be generated by the union of two of its associative Jordan subalgebras is a JC-algebra, hence special. A similar refinement of Macdonald’s principle for JB-algebras is obtained. Moreover, we prove that the free unital JB-algebra generated by n n projections is a JC-algebra if and only if n ∈ { 1 , 2 , 3 } n\in\{1,2,3\} . Finally, we give an explicit description of the free unital JB-algebra generated by two projections paralleling the Raeburn-Sinclair theorem for C*-algebras. Keywords: JB-algebras, Shirshov–Cohn theorem, Mcdonald’s principle, special Jordan algebras, exceptional JB-algebras, identities in Jordan algebras, Albert algebra, free JB-algebra generated by projections Subject Classification: 17C05, 17C40, 17C10 1 Introduction Jordan algebras were introduced in the 1930s as an alternative algebraic framework for the mathematical formulation of quantum mechanics [ 20 ] . Since, Jordan algebras have been extensively studied for their rich connections with other fields of mathematics, such as Lie theory [ 17 ] , [ 10 ] , [ 28 ] , the study of symmetric spaces [ 25 ] , [ 32 ] , [ 21 ] and operator theory [ 31 ] , [ 8 ] , [ 5 ] , [ 33 ] . For each associative real algebra A and linear subspace J\subset A which is closed under taking squares, J is a Jordan algebra under the product x\circ y:=\frac{1}{2}(xy+yx) . A Jordan algebra is called special if it arises in this way from an associative algebra, otherwise it is called exceptional . A.A. Albert proved that the Albert algebra \mathbb{A}:=M_{3}(\mathbb{O})_{sa} of self-adjoint 3\times 3 -matrices with entries in the nonassociative division algebra \mathbb{O} of octonions is exceptional [ 2 ] . Later, Glennie gave an elegant proof of this fact by exhibiting two Jordan identities satisfied by all special Jordan algebras but not by the Albert algebra [ 11 ] , initiating a quest for other such identities [ 30 ] , [ 38 ] , [ 29 ] . The distinction between special and exceptional Jordan algebras forms a central theme in the structure theory of Jordan algebras [ 36 ] , [ 18 ] , [ 37 ] . There are two classical results that address this theme: the Shirshov–Cohn theorem and Macdonald’s principle. The Shirshov–Cohn theorem asserts that every Jordan algebra which can be generated by two elements (and 1 ) is special. According to Macdonald’s principle, if a Jordan identity involving three variables is linear in one of these and is satisfied by all special Jordan algebras, then this identity is satisfied by all Jordan algebras. Macdonald’s principle has been recognized as an indispensable tool [ 24 , p. 458] in the development of the theory of Jordan algebras, allowing the efficient verification of many Jordan identities by reducing to the case of a special Jordan algebra and then calculating in the ambient associative structure. In this paper we revisit these results in the setting of JB- and JBW-algebras. The prototypical example of a JB–algebra is the self-adjoint part A_{sa} of a C*-algebra A endowed with the Jordan product x\circ y:=\frac{1}{2}(xy+yx) . Note that while the C*-algebra product of two self-adjoint elements is generally not self-adjoint, the Jordan product does yield an intrinsic algebraic structure on the ordered vector space A_{sa} . For this reason, JB-algebras provide a versatile algebraic framework to study order theory in a C*-algebra. A JB-algebra is called a JC-algebra if it embeds in B(H)_{sa} for some complex Hilbert space H . The Shirshov–Cohn theorem for JB-algebras says that each JB-algebra which can be generated by two elements (and 1 ) is a JC-algebra. We generalize this theorem by replacing the two elements in its statement with two associative Jordan subalgebras. Theorem 1.1 . A JB-algebra is a JC-algebra if it can be generated by the union of two of its associative Jordan subalgebras. This result is proved as Theorem 3.1 . Since the Albert algebra can be generated by three elements [ 1 , Cor. 2] , it is perhaps surprising that a JB-algebra generated by three projections is necessarily a JC-algebra. Theorem 1.2 . A JB-algebra is a JC-algebra if it can be generated by three projections (possibly together with the unit element). We prove this result as Theorem 6.3 . The analogous assertions for JBW-algebras also hold. We give a similar refinement of Macdonald’s principle for JB-algebras. Recall that elements x_{1},x_{2} in a JB-algebra A are said to operator commute if x_{1}\circ(x_{2}\circ a)=x_{2}\circ(x_{1}\circ a) for all a\in A . Theorem 1.3 . Let F(X_{1},\dots,X_{n},Y_{1},\dots,Y_{m},Z) be a real Jordan polynomial which has degree at most 1 in Z and is satisfied by all JC-algebras. Let A be a JB-algebra. Suppose that (x_{1},\dots,x_{n}) and (y_{1},\dots,y_{m}) are two tuples of mutually operator commuting elements in A . Then for every z\in A it holds that F(x_{1},\dots,x_{n},y_{1},\dots,y_{m},z)=0 . This result will be established as Theorem 4.3 . Each of these results is proved by making a reduction using [ 3 , Thm. 9.5] to the case of the Albert algebra and analyzing the Jordan subalgebras of M_{3}(\mathbb{O})_{sa} having certain generating sets. Moreover, in Section 5 we describe the free unital JB-algebra generated by two projections as the JB-algebra of all continuous functions f\colon[0,1]\to M_{2}(\mathbb{R})_{sa} into the 3 -dimensional spin factor such that f(0) and f(1) are diagonal matrices. This result is the JB-analogue of a theorem due to Raeburn–Sinclair for C*-algebras [ 27 ] . In order to make the article accessible to a broad spectrum of readers, Section 2 includes a relatively self-contained discussion of the pertitent concepts and results in the theory of Jordan algebras and JB-algebras. 2 Preliminaries 2.1 Jordan algebras A real Jordan algebra is a real vector space J equipped with a commutative (but not necessarily associative) bilinear product (x,y)\mapsto x\circ y which satisfies the following Jordan identity for all x,y\in J : x\circ(y\circ x^{2})=(x\circ y)\circ x^{2}. (1) A real linear subspace E of J is called a Jordan subalgebra of J if it is closed under the product \circ , and E is called a (Jordan) ideal of J if x\circ y\in E for all x\in E and y\in J . We say J is unital if it has a unit element 1_{J} such that 1_{J}\circ x=x for all x\in J . If J is not unital, then we may form its unitization \tilde{J}:=\mathbb{R}1_{J}\oplus J with the product (\lambda 1_{J}+x)\circ(\mu 1_{J}+y)=\lambda\mu 1_{J}+(\lambda y+\mu x+x\circ y) for \lambda,\mu\in\mathbb{R} and x,y\in A ; then \tilde{J} is a unital Jordan algebra containing J as an ideal. Let K be a second Jordan algebra. A linear map \phi\colon J\to K is called a Jordan homomorphism if \phi(x\circ y)=\phi(x)\circ\phi(y) . If J and K are unital with unit elements 1_{J} resp. 1_{K} , then a Jordan homomorphism \phi\colon J\to K is called unital if \phi(1_{J})=1_{K} . Example 2.1 . Let A be an associative real algebra. Let J\subset A be a real linear subspace which is closed under taking squares. Then J is a real Jordan algebra under the Jordan product x\circ y:=\tfrac{1}{2}(xy+yx). (2) Example 2.2 . Let \mathbb{O}=\mathbb{R}1\oplus\sum_{i=1}^{7}\mathbb{R}e_{i} be the non-associative real division algebra of Cayley

Read the complete text