The petrol station game: the regional average price. A mean field analysis

Fabio Bagagiolo, Federico Pontiroli, Ivan Romanò · 2026

Read The petrol station game: the regional average price. A mean field analysis by Fabio Bagagiolo, Federico Pontiroli, Ivan Romanò (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2605-24241.txt.

Introduction

Bagagiolo, Pontiroli, and Romano model Italy's petrol-station game after the January 2023 rule requiring stations to display the regional average fuel price. Each station sets tomorrow's price using an estimate of the average the local authority will publish. The authors build a mean-field game model of this price evolution and analytically investigate whether a mean-field equilibrium exists and how it evolves. Simulated prices are checked against Trento's Autonomous Province data.

Catalog record

CREATORFabio Bagagiolo, Federico Pontiroli, Ivan Romanò
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE21579
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2605.24241

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

The petrol station game: the regional average price. A mean field analysis Fabio Bagagiolo, Federico Pontiroli, Ivan Romanò Abstract In January 2023, the obligation for petrol stations to display the average fuel price calculated on a regional basis was introduced by the Italian Government. A mean field game model is here proposed to describe the evolution of the fuel price. In particular, each petrol station decides its own price, for the next day, taking account of an estimate of the average price, to be communicated by the Local Authority. The existence and the evolution of a mean field equilibrium are analytically investigated. Some simulations are compared with real data from the Autonomous Province of Trento, Italy. 1 Introduction In the spring of 2023, at the petrol stations in Italy, displaying the average regional fuel prices to the costumers become mandatory. Actually, such obligation was suspended during 2024. However, data collection and processing continued, available on osservaprezzi . This was due to an Italian law designed, among other goals, to increase transparency and fuel price control. The underlying concept is: the “rational” consumer will avoid filling up at outlets whose prices are significantly above the average, knowing that for every gas station that has above-average prices, there is at least another one that has cheaper prices. In practice, the issue is more complex, because other factors may influence the choice of the customers, such as the presence of a bar, a car wash, a repair shop, etc.. The average price to be displayed is updated daily based on the individual price that each gas station has communicated to the Ministry of Enterprise and Made in Italy (MIMiI) the day before. It is then a quantity subject to a certain degree of uncertainty, until it is published, and every gas station attendant must somehow estimate it in order to understand what price is best for her/him. In this paper we interpret the problem as a a mean-field game, in which the mean field is the average price. In particular, in the formulation of the problem, we get inspiration from a simple model that regulates the start time of a company meeting, “When does the meeting start”, which is contained in liolasgue . It is assumed that the gas station attendants, and consequently the consumers, are rational decision makers: in practice, this means that the players’ decisions are assumed to minimize some cost function. In our main model we assume that the cost of the raw material is constant and is the same for everyone. This may be justified since the evolution of the average price is considered in a rather short windows of days (see also Remark 1 ). The model then aims to describe the dynamics of decisions, that is the evolution of prices, and therefore to rationally interpret the process that leads each gas station attendant to choose a certain price, in order to be capable to possibly predict future behaviors, suitably fitting the parameters. This Introduction continues with some further details on the legislative context, on the available data and with a first notational description of the price evolution. Then, in Section 2 , an analytical model is constructed and studied for what concerns equilibria and their convergence. In Section 3 some simulations are presented, comparing with data from the Autonomous Province of Trento and after a possible clustering of the petrol stations with respect to some of their specificities. As general references for the numerical and statistical tools, we refer to nowrig , hastibfri . 1.1 Law & Model With the Legislative Decree of January 14, 2023 (see decretolegge for the full text), the government communicated the new “Provisions regarding fuel bonuses and transparency and control of the retail price of automotive fuel.” What must be done in practice is highlighted in the dedicated FAQ section (see faq ) of the MIMiI website, of which we only report the most significant aspects. MImiI, upon receiving the price communications, processes the data and calculates the arithmetic mean, on a regional and autonomous province basis, of the prices communicated by those engaged in the sale of automotive fuel to the public at facilities located outside the motorway network […] MIMiI, starting August 1, 2023, will publish average prices in open format daily by 8:30 a.m. in a dedicated section of its institutional website, at www.mimit.gov.it/it/prezzomedio- carburanti […] Gas station attendants must display a sign showing the average prices for the types of fuel available at their point of sale, ensuring that it is updated daily. Let us suppose that we have fixed a data collection day. We are going to use the following notation: \overline{p} as the average price displayed on that day (and communicated by the Ministry early in the morning); p_{i}^{+} as the price decided by the i -th player (the i -th petrol station) for the next day for her/his own station; \overline{p}^{+} as the average price of the next day calculated as arithmetic mean of all prices p_{i}^{+} . The transition scheme is then \overline{p}\ \longrightarrow\ \left(p_{i}^{+}\right)_{i}\ \longrightarrow\ \overline{p}^{+} (1) From the game theory point of view (see for example pet ), we have a non-cooperative game with imperfect information (no one knows the prices that others will set, and consequently the average price, until the following day) and complete information (ignorance of the others’ moves is the same for each player; the average price of the current day on which to base estimates is known to all). The data has been collected and made available as a .csv file since 2015 on the website dati . Actually, starting in 2023, MIMiI has performed a data processing function and made a summary available. Just considering only data referring to Petrol (Benzina) self-service (outside the highways), we can observe in Figure 1 the evolution of the average price during the year 2023 for the Autonomous Province of Trento. Figure 1 : Evolution of prices for the Autonomous Province of Trento 2 The analytical model In this section we introduce the costs faced by the agent (player) i -th when the price of the next day p_{i}^{+} must be decided on the estimated average price \overline{p}^{+} and describe how the transition ( 1 ) may be generated. What is uncertain in the decision process of the i -th player is the knowledge of the average price of the next day, \overline{p}^{+} . We then assume that the single agent i -th, in its decision process, uses a personal estimate of \overline{p}^{+} as \tilde{p}_{i}:=\overline{p}+\sigma^{i}\varepsilon_{i} (2) where \sigma_{i}>0 is a fixed coefficient and \varepsilon^{i}\sim N(0,1) is a normally distributed random variable with \varepsilon^{i} and \varepsilon^{j} independent when i\neq j . We now introduce the costs faced by the agent i -th in its decision process for p_{i}^{+} . In the following, [r]_{+}=\max\{r,0\} is the positive part, and the parameters \alpha,\beta,\gamma,\delta>0 are fixed. We also introduce the notation p_{i}^{-} for the price that agent i -th is making the actual day. i) Competition cost. This cost takes account of the fact that choosing a value for p_{i}^{+} lower than the (estimated) average means that the agent earns less (in average) than its competitors: c_{1}(\overline{p},p_{i}^{+})=\alpha[\tilde{p}_{i}-p_{i}^{+}]_{+}. (3) ii) Fidelity cost. This cost takes

Read the complete text