The Sensitivity of Substructure Lensing to SIDM Core-collapse Model Variation Preprint: APS/123-QED

Charlie Mace, Birendra Dhanasingham, Zhichao Carton Zeng, Francis-Yan Cyr-Racine, Xiaolong Du, Annika H. G. Peter, Andrew Benson · 2026

Read The Sensitivity of Substructure Lensing to SIDM Core-collapse Model Variation Preprint: APS/123-QED by Charlie Mace, Birendra Dhanasingham, Zhichao Carton Zeng, Francis-Yan Cyr-Racine, Xiaolong Du, Annika H. G. Peter, Andrew Benson (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2605-24174.txt.

Introduction

Mace and six co-authors test how sensitive substructure lensing is to models of self-interacting dark matter core collapse. Strong lensing probes dark-matter substructure, and compact halos from self-interacting dark matter should leave distinct marks, but collapse timelines are hard to model. The authors vary the choices, from smooth versus instant collapse to probabilistic versus per-halo evolution, and trace each through the two-point correlation of the deflection field. Most variations shift the signal at small scales, though spotting the gaps depends on the probe.

Catalog record

CREATORCharlie Mace, Birendra Dhanasingham, Zhichao Carton Zeng, Francis-Yan Cyr-Racine, Xiaolong Du, Annika H. G. Peter, Andrew Benson
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE66782
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2605.24174

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

The Sensitivity of Substructure Lensing to SIDM Core-collapse Model Variation Preprint: APS/123-QED Charlie Mace, Birendra Dhanasingham, Zhichao Carton Zeng, Francis-Yan Cyr-Racine, Xiaolong Du, Annika H. G. Peter, Andrew Benson Abstract Strong gravitational lensing has emerged as a powerful probe of dark matter substructure, and shows particularly strong promise as a test of self-interacting dark matter (SIDM). The compact halos produced by SIDM can leave distinct imprints on lensing observations, but the core-collapse timeline for subhalos is difficult to model accurately. This difficulty is an obstacle to accurate substructure lensing predictions, where small variations in core-collapsing subhalos can lead to significant differences in the lensing power. To quantify this problem and inform future lensing analyses, we test various methods of modeling core-collapsing halos and show the effect of each variation on the two-point correlation function of the effective deflection field’s divergence and curl. Our tests include smoothly evolving density profiles versus instantaneously collapsing halos, probabilistic collapse versus individual halo evolution, and variation of the initial and final density profile parameters. We find that the two-point correlation function is sensitive to most of these variations at small length scales, but the detectability of these differences will depend on the observational probe. I Introduction Self-interacting dark matter (SIDM) is a set of particle physics models that include interactions between particles other than the gravitational force, in contrast to commonly invoked cold dark matter (CDM) models, where there is no such interaction. In SIDM models with elastic collisions, which are the focus of this study, the heat transfer facilitated by dark matter interactions will cause the characteristics of dark matter halos to evolve over time, starting with the formation of isothermal, constant-density cores. This core formation stage is predicted to be followed by a process called the gravothermal catastrophe, or core-collapse, which produces a small dense core in the center of the halo 49 ; 2 . The dynamic evolution predicted by SIDM models may resolve several contradictions between cold dark matter (CDM) models and observational data, such as the diversity problem (CDM; 20 ; 71 ; 27 ; 76 ; 77 ; 80 ; 40 ; 51 ; 16 , SIDM; 48 ; 45 ; 79 ; 15 ; 103 ; 14 ; 65 ; 100 ; 105 ; 104 ; 78 ) and the cuspy halo problem (CDM; 29 ; 60 ; 67 ; 59 ; 97 ; 31 , SIDM; 47 ; 7 ). One potential probe of SIDM is substructure lensing, where we observe strong gravitational lenses and infer properties of the substructure inside the lens and along the line-of-sight 56 ; 18 ; 69 ; 41 ; 42 ; 68 ; 19 ; 35 ; 36 ; 23 ; 22 ; 87 ; 96 ; 32 . These tests are highly sensitive to the core-collapsed dark matter halos predicted by many SIDM models, which would strongly perturb the lensing potential of their host 87 ; 50 ; 30 . Observations of strong gravitational lenses have found evidence for subhalo perturbers, through detection of isolated line-of-sight structure 91 ; 89 ; 90 ; 88 ; 69 ; 41 ; 52 ; 92 and also measurements of flux ratio anomalies of multiple-image lensed quasars 35 ; 34 ; 37 ; 43 ; 63 ; 33 ; 32 . Inferring the properties of dark substructure from gravitational lenses requires accurate modeling of both the lens substructure and the line-of-sight structure for a given model of dark matter. Recent work has demonstrated that line-of-sight structure imparts a unique signature on the lensing potential. This signature can be understood through “effective multiplane gravitational lensing,” a method in which we define an effective gravitational lensing potential which incorporates the cumulative effects of line-of-sight structure on the lensing deflection map 23 ; 22 ; 21 . The statistic of interest in this analysis is the effective lensing potential’s two-point correlation function, which is projected against Chebyshev polynomials and quantified by the relative strength of each multipole moment. While these observational probes are promising tests of dark matter structure, the constraints they provide rely on the robustness of our substructure and line-of-sight structure models. For SIDM in particular, accurate modeling of the rapid and drastic gravothermal catastrophe is crucial to accurate predictions for lensing observables. Current approaches to core-collapse models involve a number of choices and simplifying assumptions regarding the collapsing halo profile, such as assuming the core-collapsing halo instantaneously transitions from its initial density profile to the final core-collapsed state. As an additional challenge, the timescale on which a given halo collapses is often dominated by uncertainty. Some of this uncertainty is from a lack of numerical precision 55 ; 73 , and some stems from the complex evolution of the systems we are trying to model 30 ; 104 ; 46 . It is not immediately clear what the best modeling choices are, and what effect various simplifying assumptions have on the complicated pipeline of substructure lensing inference. This uncertainty is a disconnect between existing inference and the underlying physical models they aim to test. Without a solid understanding of this problem and guidance for clear modeling choices, the ability of lensing observations to illuminate the nature of dark matter will be limited. To quantify this modeling challenge, we test various modifications of the SIDM core-collapsing halo density profile in the context of substructure lensing. These modifications represent modeling choices that can be made when generating a subhalo and line-of-sight halo population for a substructure lensing inference study. Our modifications include variation of both the initial halo (uncollapsed) and final (core-collapsed) density profiles, and comparisons between instantaneously collapsing and time-evolving halo profiles. Our baseline core-collapse model is a gravothermal fluid solution calibrated to N -body simulations of isolated SIDM halos, and model tidal evolution based on SIDM substructure simulations. We implement our model variations into random realizations of main lens subhalos and line-of-sight structure generated with the open source package pyHalo 34 , assuming a Planck 2018 cosmology 75 . We vary the density profiles of perturbing substructure, testing their impact on effective multiplane gravitational lensing predictions. This paper is structured as follow. In Section II we detail how we generate realizations for lensed systems, implement various SIDM models, and perform gravitational lensing calculations. Next we present our calibration to N -body substructure simulations (Section III.1 ), and show results for our density profile variations (Sections III.2 and III.3 ). We summarize our findings in Section IV . II Methods In this section we describe how we generate realizations of galaxy-scale lens systems with subhalos and line-of-sight halos, model core-collapse in these realizations, and produce lensing statistics from these models. First, we include details of the N -body simulations we use to model tidal effects (Section II.1 ), and how we generate the CDM subhalos and line-of-sight halos for our lensing realizations (Section II.2 ). Next, we replace the CDM halos with SIDM halos by modifying the density profiles. We discuss our various SIDM profiles, starting with our continuously collapsing model (Section II.3 ) and variations to the collapse threshold (Section II.3.4 ), and moving on to models with binary core-collapse (Section II.4 ). We end the section with an overview of effective multi-plane gravitational

Read the complete text