Pressure and Size Dependence of Roton Emission and Vortex Creation by Moving Objects in He II in T → 0 T\to 0 Limit: Generalized Nonlocal Gross-Pitaevskii Model

Nicolás P. Müller, Ladislav Skrbek, Yuri A. Sergeev, Giorgio Krstulovic · 2026

Read Pressure and Size Dependence of Roton Emission and Vortex Creation by Moving Objects in He II in T → 0 T\to 0 Limit: Generalized Nonlocal Gross-Pitaevskii Model by Nicolás P. Müller, Ladislav Skrbek, Yuri A. Sergeev, Giorgio Krstulovic (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2605-24075.txt.

Introduction

Müller and three co-authors study roton release and vortex birth by objects moving in superfluid helium-4, using a generalized nonlocal Gross-Pitaevskii model. From zero to the pressure where helium freezes, near 25 bar, they tune force settings so the model's excitation spectrum matches the pressure-shifting dispersion curve. On flat planes, disks moving through still helium yield two key speeds, one for roton release and one for quantized vortex birth, each varying with pressure and obstacle size. 3D runs with moving spheres are also noted.

Catalog record

CREATORNicolás P. Müller, Ladislav Skrbek, Yuri A. Sergeev, Giorgio Krstulovic
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE46000
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2605.24075

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Pressure and Size Dependence of Roton Emission and Vortex Creation by Moving Objects in He II in T → 0 T\to 0 Limit: Generalized Nonlocal Gross-Pitaevskii Model Nicolás P. Müller, Ladislav Skrbek, Yuri A. Sergeev, Giorgio Krstulovic Abstract In the framework of generalized, nonlocal Gross-Pitaevskii (GP) model, we study numerically the pressure- and size-dependent mechanisms of roton emission and vortex nucleation by objects moving in superfluid 4 He. As far as the authors are aware, this is the first attempt to analyze the pressure dependence of these mechanisms and the associated critical velocities within a single theoretical framework. For each of several pressures in the range from 0 to the solidification pressure of ≈ 25 \approx 25 bar, we chose the parameters of the interatomic interaction potential such that the resulting excitation spectrum for the generalized, nonlocal GP equation approximates fairly accurately the pressure-dependent dispersion curve determined experimentally by Godfrin et al. , Phys. Rev. B 103 , 104516 (2021). In the two-dimensional approximation, for circular obstacles (disks) moving in quiescent 4 He, we calculated two critical velocities—one corresponding to the roton emission and the other to the nucleation of quantized vortices—as functions of pressure and the obstacle’s size.We also comment briefly on three-dimensional simulations of the roton emission and vortex nucleation by moving spherical obstacles. preface Cryogenic phase of 4 He, the common isotope of helium, belongs to the most investigated fluids in nature. Its liquefaction by Kamerlingh-Onnes on July 10, 1908, marks the beginning of modern low temperature physics. The discovery of superfluidity by Kapitza Kapitza and Allen Allen opened the path to investigations of the new class of condensed matter systems, the quantum fluids, whose properties cannot be described by Navier-Stokes equations but depend on quantum mechanics. The extraordinary properties of the superfluid phase of 4 He, for historical reasons known as He II, are at present fairly well understood, thanks to influential works of early investigators. They include theoretical work of London London who linked superfluidity with Bose-Einstein condensation, introduction of the two-fluid model (experimentally verified by Andronikashvili Andronikashvili ) and prediction of second sound by Tisza Tisza and Landau Landau 1941 ; Landau 1947 ; second sound then experimentally discovered by Peshkov Peshkov1 ; Peshkov2 . Onsager Onsager predicted the existence of line singularities—quantum vortices in the superfluid component of He II, whose circulation is (usually singly VinenSingle ) quantized in units of \kappa=2\pi\hbar/m_{4} , where \hbar is Planck’s constant and m_{4} is the mass of the superfluid particle, the 4 He atom. Their existence leads to quantum turbulence, first considered as a theoretical possibility by Feynman Feynman and investigated in pioneering experiments in thermal counterflow of He II by Vinen VinenOld . Landau Landau 1941 ; Landau 1947 predicted the shape of the dispersion curve as consisting of linear “phonon” part at small k followed by a broad local maximum and “roton” minimum. Cohen and Feynman FeynmanCohen56 suggested to determine the dispersion curve experimentally by using inelastic neutron scattering. A number of experiments confirming the Landau’s prediction followed Glyde2018 ; Godfrin et al. 2021 . A moving body, such as a nearly macroscopic positive ion “snowball” or negative ion “bubble”, accelerated in He II Meyer61 by an electric field to a certain critical velocity, can generate excitations—rotons, phonons and/or quantized vortices RR64 ; Rayfield66 (or, alternatively, cause cavitation SkrbekSergeevCritVel )—destroying superfluidity. Fundamental critical velocities for roton generation and vortex creation in isotopically pure bulk He II in the zero temperature limit have been investigated by McClintock and coworkers in a series of experiments in Lancaster Phillips73 ; Allum77 ; Stamp 1979 ; Nancolas82 ; Ellis82 ; Bowley82 ; Ellis and McClintock 1985 ; Nancolas85-PhilTrans ; Nancolas85 ; Hendry88 ; Hendry90 (see also a detailed review by McClintock and Bowley McClintock and Bowley 1995 ) and theoretically by Bowley and Sheard Bowley77 , Bowley Bowley84 , and Muirhead, Vinen and Donnelly Muirhead (see also Ref. BarenghiMcClintockMuirhead ). We should also mention here the fundamental theory of roton creation by moving ions developed earlier by Iordanskii Iordanskii68 and Volovik Volovik70 . At low externally applied pressures, negative ions created charged vortex rings, while at high pressures above 10 – 11 bar the drag on a moving negative ion remains negligibly small until a critical velocity, {v}_{\text{rot}}^{\text{crit}} is attained, which is close to the Landau critical velocity {v}_{L}^{\text{crit}}\approx\Delta_{\text{R}}/\hbar k_{0}\,, (1) where \Delta_{\text{R}} and k_{0} are, respectively, the pressure dependent roton energy gap and the wave vector k_{0} at the roton minimum Brooks77 ; Godfrin et al. 2021 , and then quickly rises, until at another critical velocity vortex generation occurs. These Lancaster time of flight experiments are considered as low temperature classics. A pressure dependence of the ion’s critical velocity {v}_{\text{rot}}^{\text{crit}} corresponding to the emergence of roton emission was correctly attributed by McClintock, Bowley and their co-workers (see e.g. Ref. Bowley77 and the review by McClintock and Bowley McClintock and Bowley 1995 and references therein) to the pressure dependence of the Landau critical velocity given by Eq. ( 1 ). However, {v}_{\text{rot}}^{\text{crit}} does not exactly coincide with {v}_{L}^{\text{crit}} , see e.g. Ref. Ellis and McClintock 1985 for detail. The pressure dependence of the critical velocity of vortex creation, {v}_{v}^{\text{crit}} was known from the results of experimental measurements Rayfield68 ; Stamp 1979 ; Bowley82 ; Hendry90 , backed up by semi-classical theoretical calculations of Muirhead et al. Muirhead (see also Ref. BarenghiMcClintockMuirhead ) and Bowley Bowley84 . Note, however, that the values of {v}_{v}^{\text{crit}} predicted by Bowley’s calculation were higher than those calculated by Muirhead et al. and observed experimentally. The study presented in this article is motivated by two recent developments, one theoretical and the other experimental. The former is an application of the generalized, nonlocal Gross-Pitaevskii (GP) model to the study of roton emission and nucleation of quantized vortices by objects moving in superfluid 4 He Muller and Krstulovic 2020 ; Muller and Krstulovic 2022 . The latter is a detailed experimental study by Godfrin et al. Godfrin et al. 2021 of the properties of superluid 4 He at elevated pressures; this study resulted, among other important findings, in the accurate quantitative description of the Landau dispersion curve for pressures ranging from P=0 to P=24 bar, the latter being close to the pressure of solidification at \approx 25 bar. Our article, after discussing the situation in the historical context, offers a physically motivated approach which enables us to analyze the physical mechanisms responsible for the pressure dependence of two critical velocities, {v}_{\text{rot}}^{\text{crit}} and {v}_{v}^{\text{crit}} within a single theoretical framework based on the generalized, nonlocal GP model. Because a numerical analysis of this model presents substantial difficulties, our study is mainly restricted by the analysis of the modeling, two-dimensional (2D) problem (although we comment, rather briefly, on three-dimensional (3D) calculations as well). Nevertheless, the results of our 2D numerical simulations explain the underlying physics of the problem in qualitative agreement with experimental observations. I introduction I.1 Dispersion relation at different pressures The most fundamental property of a many-body system is represented by the dispersion relation for elementary excitations, E(k) , where E and k are their energy and wavenumber, respectively. For superfluid 4 He at saturated vapor pressure (SVP), Landau 1941 ; Landau 1947 predicted the shape

Read the complete text