Breaking the Chains of Probability: Neutrosophic Logic as a New Framework for Epistemic Uncertainty in Large Language Models

Maikel Yelandi Leyva-Vázquez, Florentin Smarandache · 2026

Read Breaking the Chains of Probability: Neutrosophic Logic as a New Framework for Epistemic Uncertainty in Large Language Models by Maikel Yelandi Leyva-Vázquez, Florentin Smarandache (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2605-24053.txt.

Introduction

Leyva and Smarandache test neutrosophic logic, which treats truth, indeterminacy, and falsity as independent, for modelling uncertainty in language models. Standard probability forces probabilities to sum to one, collapsing ignorance, paradox, and vagueness together. Across GPT models, five phenomena, and three prompting strategies, the neutrosophic approach let truth plus indeterminacy plus falsity exceed one. They call that state hyper-truth, seen in 35 percent of evaluations, mostly under ethical contradiction and paradox. The approach preserves truth values in fuzzy settings and flags conflict, pointing toward more transparent systems.

Catalog record

CREATORMaikel Yelandi Leyva-Vázquez, Florentin Smarandache
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE46510
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2605.24053

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Breaking the Chains of Probability: Neutrosophic Logic as a New Framework for Epistemic Uncertainty in Large Language Models Maikel Yelandi Leyva-Vázquez, Florentin Smarandache Abstract Large Language Models (LLMs) are predominantly governed by probabilistic frameworks in which the sum of outcome probabilities is constrained to unity. This architectural limitation, often imposed by Softmax layers, leads to a collapse of uncertainty that makes it difficult to differentiate between epistemic uncertainty (ignorance), paradox, and vagueness. We present an empirical investigation of the application of Neutrosophic Logic—a framework that treats Truth ( T T ), Indeterminacy ( I I ), and Falsity ( F F ) as three independent dimensions—to model epistemic states in LLMs. We conducted experiments on a family of four OpenAI GPT models (GPT-4o, GPT-4-turbo, GPT-3.5-turbo, GPT-4o-mini) across five linguistic phenomena: logical paradoxes, epistemic ignorance, vagueness, ethical contradictions, and future contingencies, under three prompting strategies (neutrosophic, probabilistic, and entropy-derived). Our findings reveal that the neutrosophic approach, by allowing T + I + F > 1 T+I+F>1 —a state we term hyper-truth —provides a richer representation of a model’s declared epistemic state. Across N = 100 N=100 valid unconstrained evaluations, hyper-truth emerged in 66.0% of Strategy-1 calls (Wilson 95% CI: [ 0.563 , 0.747 ] [0.563,\,0.747] ), with the highest rates observed in ethical contradiction (95%) and future contingency (70%); a Pearson chi-square test of phenomenon × \times hyper-truth association is significant ( χ 2 = 11.32 \chi^{2}=11.32 , d ​ f = 4 df=4 , p = 0.023 p=0.023 ). Mason (2026) 15 independently replicated and extended an earlier release of this work across five additional model families from five different vendors, reporting hyper-truth in 84% of unconstrained evaluations. We do not claim that hyper-truth is an intrinsic latent variable inside the model; rather, that unconstrained neutrosophic prompting elicits declared epistemic states that probabilistic prompting structurally suppresses by Proposition 1. We conclude that the integration of neutrosophic evaluation layers is a critical step toward more transparent, reliable, and ethically aware AI systems. Keywords: neutrosophic logic; large language models; epistemic uncertainty; hyper-truth; uncertainty quantification; indeterminacy; ethical AI; plithogenic structure Reproducibility: All code, prompts, raw data, and figures are openly released under the MIT License at https://github.com/mleyvaz/neutrosophic-llm-logic . The v2.0 release (this study, N = 100 N=100 ) is the current main branch (also tagged as v2.0 ). The v1.0 release (December 2025, N = 20 N=20 ) is preserved at tag v1.0 . The v2.0 release is permanently archived in Zenodo with DOI 10.5281/zenodo.19911845 . Published in: Neutrosophic Sets and Systems, Vol. 99 (2026). DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.19954583 . This is the authors’ preprint version with corrected first-author ORCID. Open code and data: https://github.com/mleyvaz/neutrosophic-llm-logic (MIT License). 1 Introduction The deployment of Large Language Models (LLMs) in high-stakes domains—medical diagnosis, legal reasoning, autonomous decision-making, and scientific discovery—has made robust uncertainty quantification (UQ) a first-order requirement 4 ; 18 ; 24 . A model that cannot reliably signal when it does not know is unsafe; but a model that cannot distinguish not knowing (ignorance) from knowing of a conflict (paradox) is epistemically impoverished in a more fundamental sense. Yet the underlying architecture of contemporary LLMs is rooted in probability theory, where outcome probabilities are constrained to sum to unity by Softmax normalization 7 ; 8 . This forces a zero-sum game in which any increase in uncertainty must subtract from truth or falsity, a phenomenon we term the collapse of uncertainty 22 . The constraint hinders the ability of LLMs to distinguish between aleatoric uncertainty (statistical uncertainty inherent in the data) and epistemic uncertainty (model uncertainty due to lack of knowledge) 9 ; 21 . Consider a concrete illustration. When a model is asked to evaluate the statement “This sentence is false” (the Liar paradox), a probabilistic architecture must compress its response into a distribution over {True, Uncertain, False} summing to 1. There is no way to simultaneously assign high belief to both Truth and Falsity—the constraint forces one to crowd the other out. In contrast, Neutrosophic Logic 19 treats Truth ( T ), Indeterminacy ( I ), and Falsity ( F ) as three independent dimensions, none of which subtract from the others. A paradox can simultaneously hold T=0.8 , I=0.9 , and F=0.7 —a triple whose sum exceeds 1 (hyper-truth, T+I+F>1 )— expressing the genuine conflict inherent in the statement rather than forcing an artificial resolution. This is not merely a theoretical distinction. As AI systems are deployed in ethically sensitive domains, the ability to represent genuine moral dilemmas—where an action can be simultaneously right and wrong under different value frameworks—becomes safety-critical 6 ; 3 . A probabilistic model answering an ethics question must collapse its uncertainty into a point estimate; a neutrosophic model can declare the conflict outright through a hyper-truth signature. Recent work on UQ for LLMs has explored several alternatives: semantic entropy with linguistic invariances 13 , self-consistency checks via SelfCheckGPT 14 , and conformal abstention policies 24 . These approaches address calibration and abstention but operate within probabilistic representations and therefore inherit the collapse-of-uncertainty limitation. The present paper tests the following hypothesis empirically: under unconstrained neutrosophic prompting, current LLMs will declare hyper-truth at non-trivial rates specifically in cases of paradox and ethical contradiction, while probabilistic prompting will structurally suppress this signal. We frame this hypothesis within a formal SVNS apparatus, and report experiments across 300 API calls on four OpenAI GPT models and five linguistic phenomena. Mason (2026) 15 independently replicated and extended the v1.0 release of the present work (December 2025, N=20 ) across five additional model families from five different vendors (Anthropic, Meta, DeepSeek, Alibaba, Mistral), reporting hyper-truth in 84% of unconstrained evaluations and confirming that the phenomenon is cross-vendor rather than an OpenAI-specific artifact. The present v2.0 manuscript responds to Mason’s replication by increasing the sample size to N=100 , formalising the SVNS apparatus, and clarifying that the central claim concerns declared epistemic states elicited by unconstrained prompting rather than intrinsic latent variables. Contributions. The main contributions of this paper are: 1. A formal SVNS apparatus for modeling declared epistemic states in LLMs, including six definitions and two propositions that characterize the structural difference between neutrosophic and probabilistic representations (Section 3.1 ). 2. An empirical demonstration, across 300 API calls on four GPT model families and five linguistic phenomena, that unconstrained neutrosophic prompting elicits hyper-truth in 66.0% of evaluations (Section 4 ). 3. A statistically significant association ( \chi^{2}=11.32 , p=0.023 ) between phenomenon type and hyper-truth incidence, with ethical contradiction as the primary driver (OR = 13.34, p=0.0014 ). 4. A cross-strategy analysis (neutrosophic vs. probabilistic vs. entropy-derived) showing that the largest representational gains are concentrated in ethical contradiction ( \Delta_{T}=+0.267 ) and epistemic ignorance ( \Delta_{I}=+0.383 ). 5. A discussion of the implications for AI safety and alignment, connecting the hyper-truth phenomenon to the problem of representing genuine moral conflict in large-scale language models. Paper organization. Section 2 surveys related work. Section 3 introduces the formal SVNS framework, linguistic phenomena, and experimental design. Section 4 presents empirical results. Section 5 discusses implications, limitations, and connections to the plithogenic extension. Section 6 concludes. Prompts are reproduced verbatim in Appendix A . 2 Related Work 2.1 Uncertainty Quantification in Large Language Models The problem of UQ in

Read the complete text