Supersymmetry Without Time-Reversal Invariance in Model A: A FRG perspective
Sankarshan Sahu, Bertrand Delamotte, Adam Rançon, Matthieu Tissier · 2026
Read Supersymmetry Without Time-Reversal Invariance in Model A: A FRG perspective by Sankarshan Sahu, Bertrand Delamotte, Adam Rançon, Matthieu Tissier (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2605-24029.txt.
Introduction
Sahu and three co-authors show SUSY alone does not guarantee time-flip rule in Model A motion; an extra check is needed. They build a model that is SUSY yet breaks time-flip rule, while arguing that time-flip still emerges as a large-scale pattern. With the functional renormalization group, they show the action contains the slope of the balance action, whose flow matches the balance theory order by order in the slope series. The same logic yields the Ising model's total-spin spread within Model A.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Sankarshan Sahu, Bertrand Delamotte, Adam Rançon, Matthieu Tissier |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 73627 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2605.24029
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Supersymmetry Without Time-Reversal Invariance in Model A: A FRG perspective Sankarshan Sahu, Bertrand Delamotte, Adam Rançon, Matthieu Tissier Abstract We show that, contrary to common belief, supersymmetry alone is not sufficient in Model A dynamics to ensure relaxation toward a stationary state satisfying time-reversal invariance (TRI). An additional condition on top of supersymmetry is required for TRI, which we analyze in detail. We explicitly construct a model that is supersymmetric but violates TRI, and argue that, at least perturbatively, TRI nevertheless emerges as an effective large-scale symmetry. Using the functional renormalization group (FRG), we further show that the dynamical effective action, Γ [ φ , φ ~ ] \Gamma[\varphi,\tilde{\varphi}] , contains the derivative of the equilibrium effective action, Γ eq [ φ ] \Gamma^{\mathrm{eq}}[\varphi] , whose renormalization-group flow is identical to that of the equilibrium theory order by order in the derivative expansion. Finally, extending the same line of reasoning, we show that the probability distribution of the total magnetization in the Ising model can be recovered within the Model A framework. I Introduction All N -body statistical systems satisfying the detailed balance relation have time-reversible dynamics in the steady state. This property, which implies that no steady-state currents exist, distinguishes them from other systems that reach a steady state at large time. In a non-trivial way, and for Langevin dynamics, these systems can also be described at mesoscopic scales by field theories – the Martin-Siggia-Rose-de Dominicis-Jannssen (MSRDJ) 11 ; 8 ; 10 method – satisfying supersymmetry. This symmetry is more mysterious because it involves auxiliary, non-physical, Grassmann fields, which are only brought into play to take into account a Jacobian in the construction of the field theory. These fields can be completely eliminated from the MSRDJ field theory using It \bar{\rm o} ’s formulation of stochastic calculus, but supersymmetry is then hidden, much like the gauge symmetry of electromagnetism once the Coulomb gauge is chosen. The popular belief is nevertheless that supersymmetry expresses nothing more than time reversal symmetry in the MSRDJ field theory involving Grassmann fields, when no particular stochastic calculus choice is made. There would thus be a trade-off between the simplicity of It \bar{\rm o} ’s calculus, which does not involve any Grassmannian fields – and which generalizes to non-thermal stationary systems – and the abandonment of explicit covariance under supersymmetry. In what follows, we consider \mathbb{Z}_{2} -symmetric scalar models whose dynamics are governed by a Langevin equation with Gaussian noise. Although we restrict the discussion to this class of systems, most of our arguments can be extended to models that reach thermodynamic equilibrium at long times. This article has four main goals. (i) We first show that supersymmetry alone does not guarantee that the equilibrium dynamics is time-reversible. (ii) Using It \bar{\rm o} ’s prescription, we then prove that, order by order in the derivative expansion, the renormalization-group (RG) flow of \Gamma^{(0,1)}[\varphi(x,t)=\varphi(x),\tilde{\varphi}(x,t)=0] is closed, where \Gamma denotes the effective action and \tilde{\varphi}(x,t) the response field. In other words, this flow is independent of \Gamma^{(0,n)}[\varphi(x,t),\tilde{\varphi}(x,t)=0] with n>1 . (iii) We further show that this flow coincides with the RG flow of the (derivative of the) equilibrium effective action – or Gibbs free energy – \Gamma^{\rm\,eq}[\varphi] . (iv) Finally, we demonstrate that the RG flow of the equilibrium probability distribution of the order parameter – L^{-d}\int_{x}\,\phi(x) – can be obtained from model A in the long-time limit. Point (i) is nontrivial since it implies the existence of models that satisfy supersymmetry while breaking TRI. From an RG viewpoint, this observation is intriguing. It indicates that, within the space of \mathbb{Z}_{2} -symmetric scalar models, the supersymmetric sector forms a subspace that is stable under the RG flow but does not coincide with the set of models satisfying a time-reversal dynamics à la model A. The latter defines a smaller RG-stable subspace within the supersymmetric one. We show that for \mathbb{Z}_{2} -symmetric scalar systems, the operators that preserve supersymmetry while breaking TRS are highly irrelevant in the RG sense. This strongly suggests that, at criticality, the RG flow is attracted to the usual Wilson–Fisher fixed point, where TRS is effectively restored at long distances and long times. Points (ii) and (iii) are not new 5 ; 14 . However, we provide a proof that is particularly well suited to the functional renormalization group (FRG), and in particular to its most widely used approximation scheme, the derivative expansion. 1 1 1 parallel with translation invariance At first sight, point (iv) may appear as a straightforward consequence of points (ii) and (iii), and in a sense it is. However, we are not aware of any alternative derivation of this result. Indeed, at equilibrium, one can derive from first principles the relation between the probability distribution function (PDF) of the order parameter and (a slightly modified version of) the Gibbs free energy, that is, of the effective action. By contrast, no such relation has been established for model A. To the best of our knowledge, the argument given in point (iv), although indirect, provides the only derivation of this result to date. II Model and supersymmetry We consider Model A dynamics, i.e., a dynamical \phi^{4} theory that relaxes toward thermal equilibrium at long times. The dynamics is governed by the Langevin equation \partial_{t}\phi(x,t)=-\frac{\delta H[\phi]}{\delta\phi(x,t)}+\zeta(x,t), (1) where \zeta is a Gaussian noise and H is a general Hamiltonian that can for instance be the standard \phi^{4} Hamiltonian: H[\phi]=\int_{x}\left[\frac{1}{2}(\nabla\phi)^{2}+V(\phi)\right],\qquad V(\phi)=\frac{r}{2}\phi^{2}+\frac{u}{4!}\phi^{4}. (2) The noise has zero mean and variance \langle\zeta(x,t)\zeta(x^{\prime},t^{\prime})\rangle=2\,\delta(t-t^{\prime})\,\delta^{d}(x-x^{\prime}). (3) Using the Martin–Siggia–Rose–de Dominicis–Janssen (MSRDJ) formalism, the generating functional of correlation and response functions can be derived from the Langevin equation ( 1 ). At this stage two convenient choices can be made. One may adopt It \bar{\rm o} discretization, in which case the Jacobian appearing in the MSRDJ construction is equal to unity and can therefore be ignored. Alternatively, the Jacobian can be expressed in terms of Grassmann fields; the resulting supersymmetric formulation allows one to treat all fields simultaneously through the introduction of a superfield that collects them. II.1 MSRDJ formulation Using It \bar{\rm o} calculus, the generating functional reads Z[j,\tilde{j}]=\int D\phi\,D[i\tilde{\phi}]\,\exp\left(-S[\phi,\tilde{\phi}]+\int_{x,t}(j\phi+\tilde{j}\,\tilde{\phi})\right), (4) with action S[\phi,\tilde{\phi}]=\int_{x,t}\left[\tilde{\phi}\left(\partial_{t}\phi+\frac{\delta H[\phi]}{\delta\phi}\right)-\tilde{\phi}^{2}\right]. (5) Within this formalism, TRI corresponds to an invariance of the action under the transformation \displaystyle T(t)=-t,\quad T(\phi(t))=\phi(-t) \displaystyle\quad T(\tilde{\phi}(t))=\tilde{\phi}(-t)-\dot{\phi}(-t) (6) where the x -dependence of the fields has not been mentioned to alleviate the notation. Let us notice that the action S is proportional to \tilde{\phi} which, in It \bar{\rm o} , is a consequence of causality and it can be shown 5 that this property holds for all 1PI correlation functions and thus for the effective action. II.2 Supersymmetric formulation In the supersymmetric formulation the generating functional becomes Z[J]=\int D\Phi\,\exp\left(-{\cal S}[\Phi]+\int_{\varpi}J\Phi\right), (7) where \Phi is the superfield \displaystyle\Phi(t,x,\theta,\bar{\theta}) \displaystyle\equiv\Phi(\varpi)=\phi(t,x)+\eta(t,x)\bar{\theta}+\theta\,\bar{\eta}(t,x)+\theta\bar{\theta}\,\tilde{\phi}(t,x), (8) with \varpi=(t,x,\theta,\bar{\theta}) and where \theta and \bar{\theta} are anticommuting Grassmann variables. The supersource J collects the sources j and \tilde{j} together with the Grassmann sources \gamma and \bar{\gamma} , J=\tilde{j}+\gamma\bar{\theta}+\theta\bar{\gamma}+\theta\bar{\theta}\,j. The action reads {\cal S}[\Phi]=\int_{\varpi}\left(\bar{D}\Phi\,D\Phi+H(\Phi)\right), (9) where the covariant derivatives are defined as D=\partial_{\theta}-\bar{\theta}\partial_{t},\qquad\bar{D}=\partial_{\bar{\theta}},\qquad\{D,\bar{D}\}=-\partial_{t} (10) and \int_{\varpi}=\int d^{d}x\,dt\,d\bar{\theta}\,d\theta. (11) The action {\cal S} is invariant under supersymmetry transformations generated by Q=\partial_{\theta},\qquad\bar{Q}=\partial_{\bar{\theta}}+\theta\partial_{t},\qquad\{Q,\bar{Q}\}=\partial_{t}. (12) III The functional renormalization group Several arguments presented below rely on the functional renormalization group (FRG). We briefly introduce