Not all black holes decohere quantum superpositions
Anna Biggs 1, Stefano Trezzi 2 · 2026
Read Not all black holes decohere quantum superpositions by Anna Biggs 1, Stefano Trezzi 2 (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2605-23880.txt.
Introduction
Anna Biggs and Stefano Trezzi examine whether near extremal charged black holes erase quantum superpositions outside them. Their thought experiment splits a charged particle across two places. Large quantum wobbles of the near horizon geometry at low temperature might be expected to destroy coherence. Instead, a spin induced energy gap in the black hole spectrum drives the decoherence rate to zero at late times near extremality. Even above the gap the rate stays suppressed. So quantum gravity effects protect the superposition.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Anna Biggs 1, Stefano Trezzi 2 |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 70310 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2605.23880
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Not all black holes decohere quantum superpositions Anna Biggs 1, Stefano Trezzi 2 Abstract We study the decoherence induced by near-extremal charged black holes on quantum systems in their exterior. Specifically, we analyze a thought experiment recently discussed in the literature, where the quantum system is a charged particle prepared in a spatial superposition. Near-extremal black holes are known to exhibit large quantum metric fluctuations of the near-horizon geometry at low temperatures. We show that, at late times, if the black hole is sufficiently close to extremality, these quantum gravity effects make the decoherence rate vanish. This phenomenon is due to a spin-induced energy gap in the quantum black hole spectrum. For energies above the gap, the decoherence rate becomes nonzero, but is still suppressed relative to semiclassical expectations, so these quantum gravity effects always enhance the coherence of the superposition. 1 Introduction A central hypothesis in the study of quantum black holes is the idea that, from the outside, a black hole is described by a unitary quantum system with a number of internal degrees of freedom of order the black hole entropy. One strategy for learning about these degrees of freedom is to study them operationally, by comparing the observable properties of black holes to those of more familiar quantum systems. An interesting observable to consider is the decoherence that a black hole induces on its environment. When coupled to a qubit via the electromagnetic or gravitational field, finite-temperature matter is expected to decohere the qubit at a constant rate at late times. The rate itself depends on the resistivity or viscosity of the material Biggs:2024dgp . This effect can be understood as the result of the qubit becoming entangled with the microscopic matter degrees of freedom. Recent work has shown that black holes also produce this effect in semiclassical gravity Danielson:2022tdw ; Danielson:2022sga ; Gralla:2023oya . 1 1 1 When the qubit is sourcing an electromagnetic field, the rate of decoherence induced by the black hole is comparable to that of ordinary matter. In other words, it is easy to find ordinary matter with the same “resistivity” as the black hole. In the gravitational case, the effective black hole “viscosity” is high compared to most matter systems. Further exploration of this effect has been carried out in Wilson-Gerow:2024ljx ; Danielson:2024yru ; Li:2024guo ; Li:2024lfv ; Danielson:2025iud ; Kudler-Flam:2025yur ; Danielson:2025aji . From the semiclassical metric description, the existence of a Hilbert space of black hole microstates which become entangled with the qubit is not manifest. However, their role in the decoherence effect can be inferred indirectly from the causal structure of the horizon. In this respect, the decoherence effect can be viewed as illustrating another way in which semiclassical gravity appears to “know” about its own microstates. From the standpoint of QFT on the curved black hole background, we would say that the qubit becomes entangled with the black hole by virtue of the field it sources falling behind the horizon. In other words, the black hole degrees of freedom responsible for the decoherence have an emergent semiclassical description in terms of a spacetime with a horizon. So, the finding that typical black holes decohere their surroundings once more reinforces the view that black holes admit a conventional quantum Hilbert space description. On a separate front, recent insights on near-extremal black holes have shown that, at very low temperatures, these black holes exhibit large quantum metric fluctuations of the near-horizon geometry which significantly modify observables such as their absorption cross-section and emission spectrum Brown:2024ajk ; Mohan:2024rtn ; Maulik:2025hax ; Emparan:2025sao ; Biggs:2025nzs ; Lin:2025wof ; Emparan:2025qqf ; Betzios:2025sct ; Kraus:2025efu ; Rakic:2025svg ; Luo:2026epp . For example, the low-frequency electromagnetic and gravitational absorption cross-section of near-extremal charged black holes is highly suppressed relative to the semiclassical prediction, which is due to a spectral gap in the quantum-corrected density of states Emparan:2025qqf . A natural question is then how these quantum gravity effects modify the decoherence rate that near-extremal black holes induce on quantum systems in their exterior. We address this question in this work, specifically for near-extremal Reissner-Nordström black holes in four spacetime dimensions. For concreteness, we analyze the thought experiment proposed in Danielson:2022sga ; Danielson:2022tdw , in the case where the quantum system being decohered is a simple spatial superposition of a single electrically charged particle. We are interested in the limit where the superposition—prepared by an experimenter typically called “Alice”—is held stationary outside the black hole for a long proper time T , and any radiation emitted during the separation or recombination of the particle is made negligible. 2 2 2 This can always be obtained by performing the separation and recombination processes slowly enough. The decoherence effect in this context has been explained from a number of complementary perspectives, including as the result of a “black hole memory effect” wherein soft radiation emitted by the superposition is absorbed by the black hole, causing a change in the gauge potential on the horizon. See Satishchandran:2025cfk for a recent review. Arguably the simplest and most general way to analyze this problem, and the one we will employ in this paper, is to derive a low-energy effective theory for the interaction between the black hole and the quantum superposition which only involves operators describing the electromagnetic multipole moments of the two systems. From this perspective, the decoherence arises due to thermal or quantum fluctuations of the black hole multipole operators and can be expressed purely in terms of their correlation functions. These correlation functions capture the dynamics of fields which probe the near-horizon region of the black hole. For near-extremal black holes, the semiclassical description of the near-horizon region breaks down when the black hole energy above extremality, E , approaches the “breakdown scale” E_{b}=\frac{G_{N}}{r_{0}^{3}}=\frac{\pi}{r_{0}S_{0}}\,, (1.1) which is the energy scale at which quantum gravity effects become important Iliesiu:2020qvm . Here, S_{0} and r_{0} denote respectively the (naive) semiclassical entropy and horizon radius at extremality, 3 3 3 Viewed from the far zone, at leading order the black hole cannot be distinguished from a classical extremal solution characterized only by the scale r_{0} . The much lower temperature scale 1/\beta appears only in subleading corrections in the expansion away from the extremal geometry, controlled by r_{0}/\beta . and G_{N} is Newton’s constant. As the black hole approaches extremality, the classical near-horizon geometry becomes approximately \text{AdS}_{2}\times S^{2} , where the length of the \text{AdS}_{2} “throat” is controlled by the inverse Hawking temperature \beta . In the quantum regime E\lesssim E_{b} , the length of this throat exhibits a large quantum variance. In order to correctly describe the black hole spectrum and dynamics, this gravitational mode of the near-horizon geometry needs to be quantized explicitly. Remarkably, the fluctuations of this mode are large for macroscopic black holes, meaning that quantum gravity effects can be dominant in spacetime regions where the curvature is much smaller than the Planck scale. Moreover, this regime is accessible by gravitational path integral methods, and the mode in question is described by a quantum mechanical theory whose action is given by a Schwarzian time derivative Moitra:2019bub ; Iliesiu:2020qvm ; Iliesiu:2022onk ; Kapec:2023ruw ; Rakic:2023vhv . Correlation functions of the black hole multipole operators have been