Joint Bayesian models for validating spatial health-event databases against a gold standard: separating global and local discrepancies
Mathias Brugel, Florine Kempf, Camille Ternynck, Marta Blangiardo, Michaël Génin · 2026
Read Joint Bayesian models for validating spatial health-event databases against a gold standard: separating global and local discrepancies by Mathias Brugel, Florine Kempf, Camille Ternynck, Marta Blangiardo, Michaël Génin (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2605-23791.txt.
Introduction
Brugel and colleagues propose a Bayesian framework for map-to-map validation of spatial health databases, comparing a candidate database against a gold standard. The framework uses random and structured error models, in which the candidate database is modeled as a shift from the gold standard, and compares both with a shared model. Global measures accurately recover map-wide shifts. Applied to Crohn's disease data, all models agree the candidate database reproduces spatial patterns with an overall signal about 7 percent lower.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Mathias Brugel, Florine Kempf, Camille Ternynck, Marta Blangiardo, Michaël Génin |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 65791 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2605.23791
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Joint Bayesian models for validating spatial health-event databases against a gold standard: separating global and local discrepancies Mathias Brugel, Florine Kempf, Camille Ternynck, Marta Blangiardo, Michaël Génin Abstract Abstract The reuse of medico-administrative and synthetic spatial data may overcome some limitations of population-based registries, provided rigorous validation is performed. However, no tool exists to spatially validate a candidate-for-reuse database (CFRD) against a gold standard (GS). We propose a Bayesian framework for two-dimensional (global and local) map-to-map validation of spatial health-event databases. We consider an error-model family (random [REM] and structured [SEM]) in which the CFRD is modelled as a departure from the GS. Both are compared with a shared component model (SCM). Global disagreement is assessed using the database-specific intercept difference ( RR_{\mathrm{global}} ), while local disagreement is measured by the exceedance probability of the database-specific error term. Disturbance scenarios included null, uniform, clustered, and random perturbations in the CFRD. Sensitivity, specificity, false detection rate, and Matthews Correlation Coefficient assessed detection performance. RR_{\mathrm{global}} accurately recovered map-wide shifts across all models and scenarios. REM and SEM behaved were both sensitive and specific to local discrepancies. SCM was more conservative. Applied to Crohn’s disease data from the EPIMAD registry and a CFRD, all models reached the same conclusion: the CFRD reproduced global and local spatial structures with an overall signal about 7% lower. Extensions to other outcome distributions, spatio-temporal models and calibration constitute natural next steps. Keywords: data reuse; spatial database validation; Bayesian hierarchical models; disease mapping; shared component model. 1 Introduction Population-based registries are epidemiological gold-standard data but remain geographically limited, costly to maintain over time and not widely accessible ( 32 ) . The secondary use of data enables new questions to be addressed from existing data, at lower cost and within shorter timeframes ( 31 ) . In spatial epidemiology, health data reuse is especially relevant as it can substantially extend the spatial coverage of a study and facilitate the investigation of its causes. Medico-administrative data are a potentially valuable data source, but remain poorly spatially validated ( 26 ; 5 ) . Moreover, the advent of spatial synthetic data opens new applications. Once generated, one must assess whether the synthetic version adequately reproduces the spatial signal of the original source without materially distorting its geographical structure ( 23 ; 24 ; 25 ) . Such reuse should remain conditional on rigorous validation against an appropriate reference source. In this setting, the comparison is paired and asymmetric. Both data sources are observed on the same areal support and are intended to describe the same underlying spatial phenomenon, area by area, making them paired. Moreover, one source is treated as the reference, or gold standard, whereas the second source is evaluated as a candidate reusable database, introducing asymmetry in the comparison. Therefore, validation of spatial databases versus a gold-standard goes beyond generic spatial pattern comparison. The objective is to determine if a database adequately reproduces both common global latent spatial structure and local disagreement while accounting for spatial dependence, count-data uncertainty and the asymmetric nature of the relationship between both databases. A useful statistical framework should answer to this complex issue. Existing methodological literature only partially addresses this objective. Global and local Moran’s I and Geary’s c were initially developed to characterise autocorrelation in a single or a set of maps ( 2 ) . Lee’s bivariate index combining Pearson’s correlation and Moran’s I is another notable example ( 18 ; 21 ) . These metrics rely on t -tests, weighted kappa coefficients, and related agreement summaries ( 20 ) . They describe spatial co-structure or overall agreement, but remain essentially descriptive as they do not explicitly model areal count uncertainty, encode an asymmetric reference-versus-candidate comparison, nor decompose into shared spatial signal, global shift, and local discrepancy. Spatial scan statistics were initially developed for cluster detection, and can be repurposed to local disagreement assessment. They search over a collection of candidate windows and identify those maximising a discrepancy or likelihood-ratio criterion ( 17 ; 16 ; 6 ; 7 ; 1 ) . They have already been used to compare two spatially structured databases, including for Crohn’s disease in France ( 12 ) . However, they are primarily designed to identify one or several unusual clusters rather than to assess agreement over an entire territory. Moreover, their interpretation depends on the geometry of candidate windows and they are generally formulated symmetrically rather than in a reference-versus-candidate perspective. Most importantly, they do not directly distinguish map-wide shift from local residual disagreement. Spatial point process methods have been used in this context; for instance Ripley’s K -function, a permutation procedure comparing point patterns ( 14 ) . More recent developments compare spatial intensity surfaces including kernel-based nonparametric tests, comparative evaluations of first-order procedures, and kernel mean embedding approaches for normalized intensity comparison ( 9 ; 10 ; 30 ) . These methods do not address areal count data and typically target a symmetric two-sample question of spatial similarity. Bayesian hierarchical spatial models provide a natural basis for addressing this gap. They allow joint modelling of spatially structured outcomes, explicit representation of spatial dependence, and coherent uncertainty quantification at both global and local scales ( 4 ) . They have also proved useful for decomposing shared and source-specific spatial variation across related diseases or outcomes ( 13 ) . However, to our knowledge, they have not been systematically developed and evaluated for the specific problem considered here: the validation of one spatial health-event database against another when the comparison is both paired and asymmetric . The main contribution of this paper is to recast spatial database comparison as an asymmetric validation problem with distinct global and local inferential targets. We develop a principled framework for map-to-map validation of paired spatial health-event databases against a reference source. We consider three joint Bayesian models: a random error model (REM), a structured error model (SEM), and a shared component model (SCM), as alternative latent representations of common and source-specific spatial variation. Across these models, we distinguish two complementary dimensions of disagreement: a global discrepancy, captured by the intercept contrast between databases, and a local discrepancy, assessed through posterior summaries derived from source-specific latent components. We evaluate the operating characteristics of this framework in a simulation study covering different perturbation structures, magnitudes, and directions, and illustrate its practical relevance by comparing Crohn’s disease incidence from the French inflammatory bowel disease registry (EPIMAD), taken as the reference source, with estimates derived from the French national hospital discharge database (PMSI). 2 Methodology We rely on Bayesian hierarchical spatial models to compare two spatial databases through global and local discrepancy summaries. Section 2.1 introduces the common likelihood and notation. Section 2.2 presents the primary asymmetric error-model family, namely the random error model (REM) and the structured error model (SEM), in which database 2 is modelled as a departure from the reference database 1. Section 2.3 defines the global intercept contrast, the local posterior discrepancy summaries, and the associated decision rules. Section 2.4 introduces the shared component model (SCM) as a symmetric benchmark comparator, and Section 2.5 describes the priors on hyperparameters and implementation. 2.1 General modelling framework Consider a collection of I areal units indexed by i\in\{1,\dots,I\} and two data