A Comparative Multi-Hazard Risk Assessment of the US High-Voltage Transmission Network
2026
Read A Comparative Multi-Hazard Risk Assessment of the US High-Voltage Transmission Network (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2605-23053.txt.
Introduction
Bor and six coauthors assess multi-hazard risk for the US high-voltage transmission network with one consistent framework. The framework links hazard data, fragility models, and economic impact. Across nine hazards plus a compound freezing rain and wind gust scenario, tropical cyclone wind causes the largest expected daily damage at 137 million dollars. Tornado causes the largest downstream output loss at 4.93 billion dollars per day. A 250-year geomagnetic storm costs 2.07 billion dollars per day. The compound scenario affects 237.4 million people with 85.16 billion dollars per day in losses.
Catalog record
| YEAR | 2026 |
|---|---|
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 64092 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2605.23053
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
A Comparative Multi-Hazard Risk Assessment of the US High-Voltage Transmission Network Abstract Modern economies depend critically on high-voltage power transmission networks. Yet this infrastructure is routinely disrupted by natural hazards ranging from earthquakes and floods to tornadoes and geomagnetic storms. Risk assessments have historically addressed hazards in isolation, leaving no common basis for comparing economic impacts across the full hazard portfolio. This study addresses this gap by developing an integrated framework linking hazard characterization, fragility modeling, and macroeconomic impact propagation. The framework is applied consistently across nine primary hazards and one compound freezing rain and wind gust hazard. Using national hazard datasets and a US high-voltage transmission network of over 13,000 line segments and 10,000 substations, we derive failure probabilities, expected damage, affected population, and downstream economic output losses. Among individual hazards, tropical cyclone wind produces the largest expected daily damage at $137 M/day, followed by lightning at $87 M/day, earthquake at $47 M/day, flood at $46 M/day, tornado at $42 M/day, and landslide at $34 M/day. Downstream economic output losses are largest for tornado at $4.93 B/day, followed by flood at $3.59 B/day and earthquake at $3.02 B/day. A 250-year geomagnetic storm produces $2.07 B/day, placing space weather within the range of major terrestrial hazards. The compound freezing rain and wind gust scenario produces the largest stress-test disruption, affecting 237.4 M people and yielding a modeled downstream output loss of $85.16 B/day. These results should be interpreted as first-order bounding estimates, with the compound scenario representing an upper-bound stress test. Overall, the framework establishes a consistent baseline for prioritizing investments in transmission network resilience. † † journal: Earth’s Future † † authors: D. Bor, E. J. Oughton, R. S. Weigel, R. Yang, T. Clower, A. Newman, A.R. Valle † † corresponding: E. J. Oughton, [email protected] Department of Geography and Geoinformation Sciences, George Mason University, Fairfax, VA Space Weather Lab, George Mason University, Fairfax, VA Schar School of Policy and Government, George Mason University, Fairfax, VA NSF NCAR, Boulder, CO keypoints We compare ten hazards affecting the US high-voltage transmission grid using one hazard-to-economics framework The compound freezing rain and wind gust scenario dominates stress-test losses, while tornado leads individual hazards in modeled downstream economic output loss A 250-year geomagnetic storm produces the same-order output losses as major terrestrial hazard scenarios Plain Language Summary High-voltage transmission lines and substations are exposed to many natural hazards, including earthquakes, floods, tornadoes, wildfires, lightning, freezing rain, and geomagnetic storms. These hazards have been examined separately in the literature, making it hard for grid planners and policymakers to compare risks across hazards or decide where resilience investments matter most. We develop a common method for comparing natural-hazard risks to the US high-voltage transmission network. The method integrates national hazard maps, grid asset data, damage models, replacement costs, population exposure, and an economic model. The coupled model estimates how power disruptions affect different sectors of the economy. We find that tropical cyclone wind, lightning, earthquake, flood, tornado, and landslide are the leading individual hazards for physical grid damage. Tornado, flood, and earthquake produce the largest modeled economic losses among the individual terrestrial hazards. A rare geomagnetic storm can cause losses comparable to those from several major terrestrial hazards. A compound freezing rain and wind gust scenario produces the largest disruption. However, this should be treated as an upper-bound stress test, as the hazard data are only available at the state level. These results provide a first-order comparison of power-grid risks across the full hazard portfolio and can support future resilience planning. 1 Introduction The power transmission network is the backbone of modern economic activity. It supports computing, manufacturing, transport, finance, and the data centers that power the ongoing expansion of artificial intelligence. However, this infrastructure is frequently exposed to natural hazards, including earthquakes, floods, tornadoes, wildfires, and geomagnetic storms. Each hazard poses distinct physical stresses on transmission lines and substations. The literature has largely addressed these threats in isolation. Seismic fragility of substations, flood exposure of distribution infrastructure, and wind vulnerability of transmission towers have each received sustained attention. For extreme events with return periods exceeding 100 years, however, the economic consequences of transmission failure remain poorly quantified across this hazard portfolio. Moreover, studies evaluating these threats within a common analytical framework remain scarce. Existing assessments are methodologically inconsistent. They employ different intensity measures, fragility formulations, and economic models, making cross-hazard comparison effectively impossible. Thus, infrastructure operators and policymakers allocating resilience budgets across competing threats lack the comparative risk metrics needed to make informed decisions 67 . Space weather adds a further dimension to this problem. Geomagnetic storms induce quasi-DC currents in long transmission lines that can saturate high-voltage transformers. In extreme cases, they can trigger cascading blackouts. The 1989 Hydro-Québec collapse, for instance, left six million people without power for nine hours 63 . Socioeconomic impact assessments for space weather have grown in recent years, spanning the UK 55 , the US 82 , and New Zealand 42 . However, these assessments remain methodologically isolated from terrestrial hazard analyses. This makes it difficult to answer a basic policy question: how does a 100-year geomagnetic storm compare, in economic terms, to a 100-year flood or earthquake affecting the same network? We address this question by extending the physics-to-economics framework of 54 to eight terrestrial natural hazards: earthquake, riverine flood, landslide, wildfire, lightning, tropical cyclone wind, hail, and tornado. The framework couples per-substation geomagnetically induced current (GIC) estimates with transformer-specific fragility functions and input–output economic propagation. The same network representation, fragility database, and economic model are applied consistently across all hazard types. This produces comparable metrics for expected daily damage, affected population, and sectoral output loss. Space weather serves as a comparator within this landscape. This paper addresses the following research questions: RQ1 Which transmission assets and regions face the highest multi-hazard risk, and what failure modes dominate under each hazard type? RQ2 How do hazard-induced transmission failures propagate to sectoral economic output loss, and which sectors are most exposed? RQ3 How do geomagnetic storm impacts on the US transmission network compare quantitatively to terrestrial natural hazards at equivalent return periods? 1.1 Hazard-specific fragility and risk assessment The vulnerability of power grid components to individual natural hazards has received substantial attention. The literature remains organized by hazard type, with each community employing distinct intensity measures, fragility formulations, and performance metrics. Seismic fragility analysis of substations has the longest history. The Hazards United States (HAZUS) methodology 21 has long provided the most widely used standardized baseline across voltage levels. 28 developed early analytical fragility curves for equipment and structures at a Memphis substation. This work relied on analytical methods because earthquake damage data were scarce for eastern US facilities. More recent studies have constructed configuration-specific models that account for internal component layout, line-level faults, and short-circuit modes. These studies find that fragility can vary significantly across substation archetypes 2 . Network-scale frameworks have extended this further to system-level seismic risk and retrofit planning 38 . They have also supported substation resilience quantification through transmission capacity metrics with recovery simulation 37 . Distribution systems have attracted comparatively less attention because the literature has historically prioritized transmission infrastructure 40 . Wind and hurricane fragility research has focused heavily on